M16 registered receiver repair service recommendations sought...

I’m no lawyer, but I’m pretty sure this constitutes mail fraud at the very least. And given the probable amount of the transaction, and that state lines were likely crossed, is almost certainly a felony. Civil liability aside, there are definite criminal ramifications here. I would engage the full force of law to your advantage if I were you.

Please keep us updated.

I’d settle for no less than full refund. Way too much money to be repairing it right off the bat. Regardless factory A1 or conversion, it doesn’t seem like the prices have taken off to much on the last year or so. Can always find a similar deal.

You would think a few phone calls would put several agencies into action, but having seen this exact same thing almost a dozen times I’m here to tell you nobody cares. Not the post office, not the police in your town, not the police in the sellers town and not the ATF.

REFUND.

M60Joe…he can repair it.

Sent from my SM-G900T using Tapatalk

I’ve done a few repairs to War Bird parts that are no longer made. I can think of a couple of ways to repair the egged out hole.

As far as repairing or getting a refund, that depends on how much you paid for it and how much it will cost to get another lower. If the machinegun registry remains closed, even repaired receivers will continue going up in value

Exactly. Brokering items that are not in one’s possession is not wise.

Take the refund. Do not start down the rabbit hole of repairing this. The only way I would do so is if the purchase price was very significantly under market. Knowing (I think) from whom you purchased this, it was more likely top of market. You can find another 16 from a reputable dealer who is not a broker.

That will go nowhere and require significant time and energy. I would instead take the refund, be thankful I didn’t need to fight to get the refund, and focus my energy on finding the right transferable M16.

I would say that unless the item is local or regional, the majority of MG deals don’t have the buyer inspecting the item. When dealing with a reputable seller it just isn’t really necessary unless it is a very rare item. I have personally never inspected any MG I have purchased. But I have dealt with reputable people, either dealers or trusted individuals.

Registered Receiver (RR for short) M16 refers to the fact that the lower receiver is the registered MG and not a registered lightning link or drop in autosear (DIAS). RR M16s come in many flavors. There are factory made M16s from Colt and other gov contractors. Then there are the semi lowers converted to auto by various SOTs (and some individuals prior to 5/19/86). These include converted Colt SP1s and conversions of non-Colt lowers. Sendra, Olympic Arms, and Essential Arms receivers were commonly used in conversion. Sendra lowers were forged. Early Olympic were machined from billet (often rough in appearance and soft), while later were forged. EA were cast. Group Industries also made some stainless steel cast lowers. Non-Colt RRs typically have some degree of spec issues.

Egged out FCG pin holes, while not common it can occur. Especially when shooting a lot of 9mm on one’s lower without the use of proper FCG pins. And even with the proper 9mm pins, this can still occur.

OP, what is the outcome of this?

Egged out FCG holes may be one thing, having the receiver gouged in an effort to stake them and having the ears damaged and the trigger guard JB weld gunked in place is quite another!!

It is currently going badly and heading towards court. The seller wants the gun sent back before refund and I want the refund before sending the gun back. From my e-mail traffic (names have been changed to protect the guilty)…

"Just as you required me to send money before you sent the firearm, I require you to refund my money…before I return the firearm.

Why? One, obvious trust issues with Mr. X (Mr. Z may possibly be innocent?). Two, the firearm is potential evidence if need be at trial, civil, criminal, or both. Three, I want to ensure that there is no discrepancy regarding the amount.

My records (I have made records request with Mr. Bowers as well) show delivery of payment was received on June 27th 2016.

I would like to receive my money by July 1st. That would be just over 1 full year."

They ignored my concerns and the rest of the e-mail and simply reiterated their desire for me to send them the gun as soon as possible.

That’s it for now.

I wonder if they might agree to have the receiver sent to an uninterested third party, such as a Class 3 dealer. Perhaps even the original broker?

That’s part of the problem. The seller and the so called third party NFA dealer/broker are best buds. In fact, the address for Mr. X on the form 4 and the business address for the NFA dealer Mr. Y are the same. Very strange. Mr. X lives in the shop? They’re room mates? Keep in mind these two people have the same freaking address and Mr. Y (NFA dealer) claims to be innocent in the scam & didn’t know & hadn’t seen the gun (claims to have just taken the serial # off the box, at the least, extremely unprofessional) & there were early discrepancies with the serial # that resulted in significant delays, the whole thing reeks of willful criminal fraud bait & switch. There is no way in hell that I am sending the gun back till I get my money back. Other than that, see you in court says I.

What did your lawyer advise you do?

You know what really pisses me off is that this gun was purchased with money from a Uniformed Services Employment Re-employment Rights Act Federal law suit when my civilian employer illegally fired me while I was in basic when I joined the National Guard. So, now I’ve been double and triple ****ed.

Don’t know yet. I just called and asked for a referral yesterday.

TED

Ted, would I be correct to assume that you’ve made Mr. Bowers fully aware of the situation? I’d think that he doesn’t want scammers on his forum.

Given that the 3rd party dealer and seller have the same address, it appears to me like the 3rd party was willfully used in the scam to give the seller plausible deniability.

As for a lawyer, be careful with them. They make money off of billable hours. Some are very happy to drag things out simply to pad their own pockets. Personally, I’d hire a lawyer in the state where they reside and have him immediately sue both parties. I wouldn’t have him screw around with begging and negotiating. Once sued, the scammers will likely want to resolve the issue. Your lawyer can then work up an agreement where they send the money to an escrow service, you return the rifle, and then the escrow service pays you. Good luck, don’t let the process beat you down, and (most of all) don’t let the scammers be successful by keeping the rifle.

Exactly how would you do that since it would be considered a transfer?

Great question. How would you do that? I imagine the ATF NFA Branch isn’t getting involved in the fraud aspect of this, because an actual serial numbered receiver was exchanged, but they would have to be involved with the transfer back.

Wouldn’t that act as a measure of a safeguard against fraud in the refund aspect of this?

Any news on this situation?

After speaking with lawyers and Federal law enforcement and what I believe to have been some back channel reasoning and explaining possible outcomes (I have no evidence or personal knowledge of this just my suspicion based on timing of conversations and responses as well as tone changes in communication), we are currently at a “check is in the mail”. USPS.com tracking says it should be here tommorow.

TED