I’m not an expert but when asked I recommend the M&P (but always suggest they spend a little more for a Colt) .
But the Aero does seem to have good specs and a fairly good reputation. For argument sake if you get one of the premium PSA’s with the FN barrel and better bcg it would look good on paper but I’d want someone skilled to look over it for potential QC issues.
So what is the best recommendation for a first time owner in the $500-$600 range?
My advice to someone with a $500-$600 budget would be to keep saving your pennies.
Colt OEM1 or OEM2 is the best deal going, in my opinion, if you can find them.
I don’t know why Aero has such a solid reputation, they are budget level parts, and it shows. When Grant at G and R sells BCM complete lowers for $380, how much can you possibly be saving by buying Aero? I think Aero costs more money, because you are wasting $$$ on crap.
This. Not sure I would want to have one for less than the colts are going for. U can’t even really build one for less than 8 that I would bet my life on. Hell my last one cost me 2700 finished. To me colts 6920 is budget priced but not a budget rifle.
But I still want to know the best of the budget guns, I won’t get one but many first time owners will, and the m&p generally has a good rep. Might as well point them towards the one with the least negatives.
Maybe I should have asked if anything beats the m&p at the price point
I think technically a PSA Premium has the best specs which on their premium line is very close to colt/bcm on paper. That said, PSA’s quality control/assembly quality and customer services doesn’t have the same reputation that S&W has and although the M&P 15 sport has more commercial spec features such as a 1:9 twist 4140 barrel, it seems that the M&P Sport are more consistent in terms of build quality and attention to detail. Don’t know to much about Aero Precision.
If I was buying I would go with the PSA due to the better specs and since I feel comfortable troubleshooting the rifle if need be. For a first time buyer however, I would go with the M&P Sport.
If you’re looking for “an AR” and like 95% of owners, no. (no carbine classes, 1k rounds a year or less)
In that specific low-end price point, they’re a fine option.
IMO, “buy once, cry once” is valid in just about everything, but the reality is plinkers and very casual gun owners are going to have a tough time paying $200 more for a rollmark and some other details they don’t understand. I think more ARs are better for us, and I sure would hate to see someone write off the platform based on cost, when they could spend $600 and have a functional rifle. Hopefully they get the bug like everyone here and become involved. Again, IMO, more exposure the better.
M&Ps run fine, if a little rough, and S&W will take care of you if they don’t. I try and be a good friend and suggest a higher end builder, but if they’re price sensitive, better a cheap functional AR than no AR at all.
A first time owner especially needs something that doesn’t suck. PSA can turn out acceptable uppers, but also puts out alot of garbage. I have no experience with Aero .
Best answer is for them to save a bit more and just get a Colt as was mentioned, but of the three I would choose S&W.
M&Ps feel like garbage compared to my Aero. M&ps work but that’s about it for me. I got my Aero M4E1 on sale. Usually 900 some bucks. I got it for 775 out the door. They build to order and I’m a bit over 1000 into it now after optics and mags.
But it’s been a great rifle. That’s not to say there aren’t others that are better. Just going off of my experience
For a full carbine/rifle, of the 3 listed I would recommend the M&P based on brand history and reputation with customer service. I have had good experiences with Aero customer service though–order issue only, not equipment related.
I have found it very difficult to convince people who are very casual shooters (someone who wants an AR just to have one) that there are quality and manufacturing differences worth $200+ more in the Colt than the basement budget models. Desired use is different for everyone and a vast market is our friend (think cars and trucks). Honestly some of the guys I know who have bought ARs recently shoot less than 120 rounds a year, so for them the hobby-grade should work just fine.
I’ve been wanting to get my hands on a DEF15 to check one out. A few weeks ago a large seller on GB let a few go for 569 and while I was waffling, both sold. The only ? for me on it are:
Are they still using AR15 instead of M16 carrier?
What RE are they using? Not much of an issue for me, but will be for others. All the stocks come either milspec or commercial and my preferred stock (UBR) comes with a tube anyway. Also, 6060 vs 7075 I’ve never seen an RE break.
Other than that, good luck finding anything else at that price with 1:7 twist, 4150, chrome lined, etc.
My buffer spring shed a coil after 750 (granted it still ran fine but was just a bit shorter.) rounds. I called the same day and they next day shipped me a new buffer spring no questions asked. I also spoke with their tech guy and let them know just in case it was a supplier/manufacturer problem.
Yes. I also have a PSA premium. It only has 600 rounds through it, but no issues.
I would pick the PSA out of those Three mainly because of The FN barrel and the Mil-spec BCG.
“King of the budget ARs” must rank up there with jumbo shrimp, mighty midgets, honest politicians, clean coal, fair trade, etc.
S&W makes an OK product and has systematic customer service, but I have seen dimensional issues in several of their rifles. Not severe enough to prevent function, but something I don’t consider acceptable.
I’ve owned a number of PSA uppers. Some were well assembled, some had issues, most often FSB alignment (not vertical). One of their BCGs, years ago, was dimensionally off in a way that prevented function, but was not obvious just in looking at it. They have great specs on paper but lack the quality control of more prestigious brands. Their customer service is also hit or miss. Caveat emptor.
I would think that Ruger and Windham Weaponry would be on a list of better cheap ARs, though I haven’t owned their products. Likewise, Armalite makes a pretty decent product in the moderate price range.
I’m sure why Aero Precision gets so much grief here. I have a bunch of their stuff and haven’t found actual defects in any of it made since 2012. I think their handguards and uppers are innovative. The current barrels seem to be well made for the price point. I do have two of their older lowers (c. 2010) and those have a minor dimensional issue, which I only discovered when trying to use one of them with a buttstock that also has a dimensional issue in the opposite direction, and way back then the anodizing wasn’t great. But I haven’t seen those issues on their newer products (again, since roughly 2012). I’ve also found their customer service to be pleasant and reasonably responsive (I have used it for shipping and ordering issues, not quality problems).
Still, at current prices the best advice is to save a few more pennies and get either a Colt OEM model or a BCM setup. Modest additional cost for much more confidence inspiring quality control, at least if you want a basic setup.