Thanks for the responses. I have spent quite a bit of time evaluating various rear BUIS, and have never found one that completely satisfied by sense of proper design. Elsewhere on M4C there are a couple of longwinded gripe fests from me with pros and cons. Thus far I have used and evaluated:
Magpul MBUS (Gen 1, couldn’t bring myself to get a Gen 2)
Troys (regulars, SKD, and di-opter)
GG&G (regular)
GG&G MAD
PRI (Troy-like)
Brownells (regular and 360) – NOTE: actually very nice sights, except for the extended nut that lies close to the CH latch, and, they tend to work better with extended front sight posts
ARMS (several types, all sold off)
And those are just the flip ups. I have probably left off a few, and, for those who care, the KACs just don’t appeal to me. Others that have problematic reps include Mangonels, MaTechs, and others. If I knew what I know now about the MAD, I never would have bought it.
The problem I have with designs is that manufacturers treat them like “back ups” (i.e., as though they don’t have to be as good as primary optics). But, guess what guys, if your “primary” goes down, the iron you go to had better be as good as (or, almost as good as) the primary you would have chosen if irons were your only choice.
What a I would like to see in a flip up BUIS are these features:
-Tough
-Held and Locked solidly in the upright when deployed; not held in place by a spring
-Able to be initially deployed with the small or the large aperture (my choice)
-Windage knob located at the base of the sight, or, with a very small and difficult to adjust knob higher on the sight
-If it uses a flip type aperture, I want it to use a bar or spring steel detent (like the carry handle sight or the GG&G regular sight), not a simple ball detent
And I haven’t even begun to address the issue of aperture types: sizes, same plane or offset. I can work with just about anything, as long as the list above gets me the type of sight I can have confidence in when deploying.
A few of the above sights come close, but that’s my wish list.

ETA: Ordered a set of the Skirmishes, and we’ll see.