LMT MRP piston vs. HK 416

Following the success of British SA80A2 project that HK did for British MoD, HK carry that momentum to the M16 platform as the next logical choice. As soon as the HK 416 hit the military market, been a favorite combat platform for the elite of the elites, and a much desired weapon in the US civilian market with street prices that reached the astronomical 5000.00 for a complete barreled piston upper, HK recoil buffer and buffer spring.

This year LMT pushed out their long under development piston system based the MRP (Monolithic rail platform). LMT has had a piston system from as far back as the SCAR solicitation, but due to production schedule/availability, timing and LMT ‘s desire to come out with a system to topple the rest, resulted in the delivery of the system until now. The standard direct gas MRP has been the Ferrari of all M4/M16 platforms with features such as quick change barrel, solid one piece rail platform, and now a piston system. Most of the piston system on the market including the HK 416 has a much different recoil impulse than the direct gas guns, the felt recoil is more of a sharper jolt. The HK 416 recoil impulse is not as smooth nor is it as soft as the direct gas guns, but for reliability, there is no matching the capability of the HK. LMT MRP in another hand, it is about as smooth and as soft recoiling as the direct gas gun, in comparison to the HK 416, the LMT piston system are far more like the recoil of the direct gas guns than anything I have shot recently, including the LWRC, POF, and PWS.

We set up the LMT piston system with just the basic, EOTech 556, Midwest Industry flip front and rear SPLP sight, TangoDown rail panels and vertical grip. The host lower has a H2 buffer with standard recoil spring. All testing was shot using the latest in magazine technology, the new TangoDown ARC polymer magazine.

The accuracy of the piston MRP is also on par to the hammer forged barrel on the HK 416. We shot prone from 100 yards, the scoped used was a Leupold MR/T 2-8X36 with illuminated mil-dot mounted to a American Defense Manufacturing 30mm quick detachable mount. Both guns shooting a 1-2MOA group with Hornady 75GR TAP, about 2-3 MOA with Lake City M855 and also M193. We also ran Wolf but that ammo was more for reliability testing than actual accuracy. The numbers posted by the LMT MRP are on par with any combat carbine currently fielding. I believe if I used a match trigger for the testing, the accuracy results would be slightly better.

As far as reliability, the HK has proven itself time and time again on the battlefield; can the LMT match its pace? As HK are already a proven system, we concentrated on the MRP piston. We shot 500 rounds of wolf, 500 rounds of M193 and also 500 rounds of M855 plus a saluted of reloads and factory ammo from various shooters at the training session that day. The total round count came to approximately 2000 rounds during the day. The LMT piston worked flawlessly. And the internals only took a simple wipe down to get it clean. However due to Wolf ammo, we had to scrub the throat, chamber and also the bolt head to get rid of the red sealant common on the Wolf ammo.

HK 416 utilize a lot of proprietary components, from barrel, barrel nut, bolt, bolt carrier, to firing pin, none of this is interchangeable with the Direct gas guns, and you would have to run the HK buffer and spring in order to keep the recoil impulse in check. But with the MRP you actually have a few more common parts to the DI gas gun than the HK, you can still run the standard bolt and firing pins inside the MRP which are some of the more commonly replaced parts in the AR system. With the HK, you would pay a high price for the armor’s tool just to remove the barrel, with the LMT, two torque screws which keep the barrel secured in the monolithic rail platform. For those of us that are not on a government budget, the MRP is definitely a lot easier to service than the HK 416.

HK piston is a top loading system, although the rail system on the HK 416 is supposed to return to zero, a lot of operators I spoke with never like to remove the rail to clean the piston since re-zeroing the PEQ15 are very time consuming task. LMT MRP is a front loading system; all parts are easily accessed by removing the front gas regulator plug, so you do not have to remove the rail system to access the piston. Also the plus is adjustable for standard fire and suppressed fire; this is a major plus for those that run suppressed guns. We had the opportunity to shoot both system with the excellent AAC M4-2000 and the result was interesting. With a suppressed piston system, it is naturally much louder than a suppressed DI gas gun due to the gas regulator releasing excess gas. The LMT MRP shot slightly quieter than the HK 416. We measured with a studio quality sound meter placed at the shooter’s left ear. The HK piston system shot approximately 1.5dB higher than a DI gas gun, but with the LMT the sound suppression came within 1 dB of the DI gas gun. Both guns ran higher cyclic rate when suppressed, but it was still slower than a Colt M4 suppressed.

LMT MRP piston system, it is on par with the weight of the HK 416, which is heavy compare to a Direct Gas M4, but you give up in turns of weight to gain the ultimate reliability in an AR system. But With the LMT MRP piston system, you have a platform (so far) that is just as reliable as the HK 416, but at half of the cost (street price LMT at 1400.00 vs. 4000.00 for the HK 416), less recoil, softer shooting platform with slightly more common parts than the HK 416. Only remaining question is how reliable is the piston system design? This will require more than just the 2000 rounds I shot in a day, I will have to keep this gem and run a lot more rounds through it. I plan on taking this gun with me to Larry Vicker’s carbine class in South Hill, Virginia in a month time.

Thanks for the detailed review. Good to see someone with your reputation taking on the task of putting the LMT through its paces. Looking forward to the after action from the LAV class.

E

Thanks SMGLee for that great comparo!!! I’m glad to see how the LMT performs. This is the first well written ‘test’ of the LMT system. I’m really glad that you compared it with the HK416.

I’m looking forward to your report on how it performs during your upcoming class. Also, if Larry has any input towards the LMT.

I really like my LMT Piston!!!

Wow! Outstanding pics, and side-by-side comparison. Thanks for all your work and for putting that online. This is the kind of stuff that keeps me coming back to M4Carbine.Net. Also, if I ever decide to take the plunge and get a GP rifle, you’ve convinced me that the LMT is worth a serious look.

Good work!!!

Sounds great, I look forward to shooting it!

Great write up! Thanks for sharing. I have not even had the chance to shoot my LMT MRP piston yet. Hope to get out sometime this week.

Thanks, for the great comparison and pictures. Looking forward to an AAR after your class.

Great post.

A few questions:

  1. How does the LMT deal with carrier tilt, since if I remember correctly, it lacks buffer pads and an anti-tilt carrier?

  2. How does the LMT deal with excess gas, as if I remember correctly it doesn’t have a bleedhole?

thanks?

The LMT has anti-tilt pads on the carrier.

Thank you for the report, Mr. Lee.

Thanks for the report, I love my LMT Piston, but won’t get a chance to really work it out for a while.

The LMT bleeds gas forward through a small hole, not into the handguard like some designs. I paid only the $1440 retail for my upper while it was in stock for a couple hours. Like anything AR these days, the retail price holds true as long as you find it in stock from a reputable dealer (difficult task, but the same goes for a RRA upper and everything in between). Now that HK is releasing the whole rifle later this year it will be interesting to have an apples/apples price comparison for the $1995 LMT Piston rifle vs whatever they price theirs at.

Talk about the systems and don’t argue about what it cost and where, etc, etc.

Thanks for the great comparison Lee! I have been waiting for someone to compare these two guns. Please keep us updated on the LMT as the round count goes up and after the Vicker’s class.

As of right now, my AR buying days are over… everyones are unless you get really luckie… but if things change and you can buy LMT lowers, uppers, ect ect agian… the LMT MRP upper and Defender 2000 lower are on my must have if obama does not fuck it all up list… for right now all my money is going on mags, ammo and I have to pick up a pistol… but anyway I think the LMT MRP beats the HK in looks alone… much more sleek look to it and it has a much better price for a better rifle… I have a LMT Carbine and I love it. best AR I have owned… maby in a year or so when all the back orders gets filled you will be able to get stuff like you once could and I will for sure be picking up one if obama has not made it to where you have to turn in your freedom and stops you from getting anymore freedom… Im just going to enjoy what I have… I really want a LaRue 16" upper befor I get a piston since it really seems like more of a fad right now… I know they work better wet and all that but there are still some tweeks that need to be worked out of the piston type rifles… its just somthing you really dont need for a home defense or match grade rifle as long as you know how to keep your gun clean and you will have to do that if it uses a piston or not… I just need to ask one thing what is this whole recoil thing over piston AR’s? I hear there is much more recoil then with the standerd M4/AR-15/M16

How about filling us in on those problems

Ditto that, I’m genuinely interested in one of these.

After handling almost all of the various WunderCarbines I’m kind of drawn to the LMT – perhaps that is due to familiarity – but I’m glad to see some testing trickling out. If there are issues coming up, I want to know what they are.

I’m willing to bet we will never see any proof of this statement.

Can anyone name a weapon system that hasn’t ever had to go back to a factory because of a problem? I can’t. Anything made by humans is susceptible to being screwed up. I am sure that no XCR has ever been returned, right? :confused: :rolleyes:

…I was holding back from typing a similar sentence.

I’ll be awaiting for his reply, if none, his post will be gone.