I am looking for a lightweight 16" upper, preferably with 1/7 twist. It seems like the “brand” names generally available are:
Colt
Bushmaster (1/9 only, I think)
DPMS (1/9 only, I think)
CMMG
Of course, I would like the Colt but it is the most expensive and is not a flat top. The CMMG seems about as highly regarded as Colt and almost as expensive. The Bushmaster Superlight seems to have a good reputation here. The DPMS is the cheapest. But is there really that much difference?
I can also get a really good deal on a RRA upper such that I would consider having the stainless 1/8 barrel turned down to a lightweight profile.
Also, are YHM lightweight FF qaud rails about as light as the get, maybe even lighter than CAR handguards?
I have 2 Colts and have had a Bushmaster superlight. I prefer Colt just because but the Bushmaster is a good one as well. The 1/9 twist doesn’t make it a gimp, I have a 1/7, 1/8 and a 1/9 and am finding out the 1/9 twist seems to handle the 77 grain bullets just as well as anything else.
I simply switched uppers on one of my Colts and it has quickly become my favorite “do all” gun.
I think the Daniel Defense rails are the lightest with LaRue not too far behind.
I have had no dealings with DPMS or CMMG and would pass on turning down a RR myself but it could be done.
Do you know if that’s special individual order or special group order? In other words, can I just call them up and say “I would like to order one single .625’ 1:7 barrel please” and have it arrive at my doorstep some months later?
I believe that they will sell you any configuration barrel they make in 1:7" twist on an individual special-order basis.
Lead-times will be long though as they are most likely going to wait until that specific profile is being run again and then put a 1:7" blank in the machine at the end of the normal run of 1:9" barrels.
I don’t know this for sure, but this is what I have always heard.
I just received several 1-7 twist barrels from Bushmaster a month or so back.
Had them in less than ten days from the time the order was placed.
Since they were bought out things seem to be improving but getting a superlight barrel in 1-7 from them may take some patience.
We have finally decided to condense all of the barrel assemblies we have into one ad. We will try and update the quantities as we sell the barrels. Thanks guys and here is what we have:
11.5" Hbar 1/7 or 1/9 Twist…$235.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $245.00 for Credit Cards!
14.5" Hbar 1/7 or 1/9 Twist…$225.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $235.00 for Credit Cards!
14.5" Hbar 1/7 or 1/9 Twist Fluted…$275.00 Shipped for Cashier’s Check or Money Order. $285.00 for Credit Cards!
14.5" M4 1/7 or 1/9 Twist…$245.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $255.00 for Credit Cards!
14.5" M4 1/7 or 1/9 Twist Perm Attached Phantom…$270.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $280.00 for Credit Cards!
16" M4 1/7 or 1/9 Twist…$245.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $255.00 for Credit Cards!
16" Superlight 1/7 or 1/9 Twist…$245.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $255.00 for Credit Cards!
16" Hbar 1/7 or 1/9 Twist…$235.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $245.00 for Credit Cards!
16" Hbar 1/7 or 1/9 twist Fluted…$290.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $300.00 for Credit Cards!
20" Gov. Profile 1/7 or 1/9 Twist…$245.00 Shipped for Cashiers Check or Money Order. $255.00 for Credit Cards
All barrel assemblies are pre-ban configuration with bayonet lug and A2 flash hider.
Each barrel assembly includes the delta ring assembly, roll pin, gas tube, A2 flash hider and standard handguards. All of these barrel assemblies are chrome lined. These are being sold as complete barrel assemblies only.
I’ve already got a complete lower. I think I will start with a plain-jane 16" M4 upper. I don’t think think the M4 barrel profile (real one; not HBAR under the handguards) is much heavier than a pencil barrel.
Then I can play with it and figure out what I like. Maybe down the road a bit if I still want something light build another upper with a superlight or pencil barrel.
You might take a look at http://www.ar15barrels.com. The owner (Randall) actually responded to your question, but didn’t interject his own services.
He can make you what you want, and you will have the pleasure of dealing with someone that actually cares about you and your business. If you have any issues, he is just a keystroke away. And his quality and fitting will be far superior to anything BM would send you.
Hold out for what you want. You’ll be happier in the long run.
PK Firearms builds 16" LW uppers with Bushmaster barrels. It wont be as nice as the Colt (as everyone here will be sure to let you know!), but it’s better than a sharp stick.
The AR world is bad ju-ju. Too much neat stuff too easily installed/switched/traded. BTW ordered some stuff from Brownells today and if you ordered five of their mags you got a free Lula loader. Since I have zero mags (I have a complete lower) I took them up on that deal.
I had studied AR15barrels.com for a while. I had notions of getting a Wilson (RRA) stainless barrel and having it turned down. RRA because I can get them at a good deal, and SS to have the faster twist and no finishing required. Still might do that in the future.
It turned out that I struck a deal today for a used CMT flattop upper with Colt pencil barrel and Colt S/A BCG.
I bought a preban Colt Gov’t Sporter in 1994 and sold it in 2001 (in a bout of Peacemaker fever). I liked that Colt for range shooting but it was rather heavy to haul around (thus my desire for a 16" lightweight this time). Ironically, this was not the hot setup (1x9 HBAR) of the AR world at the time. My how the AR world has changed since then. The possible AR condigurations now is mind-boggling. Mags are probably cheaper now than then, adjusted for inflation – never thought I’d see that.