Legal concerns modifying agency issued AR's & siuppressor concerns ; fact or fiction?

I am working for an agency that is not very large and we have a tactical team. The current train of thought is no RDS on patrol rifles. Only for the tactical team. “no one needs adot sight on a patrol carbine. They don’t shoot past 50 yards anyway. The batteries die quickly. They don’t hold a zero etc. yes, 90’s mindset.

It was suggested that the agency purchase suppressors for team carbines to help keep a low signature if contact is made, mitigate hearing loss and comp claims in the future and he is against them. No Go. “if an operator is engaging a threat in a hallway and you step out from a room you just cleared, you won’t hear the shots and will walk into the line of fire!!! “. Questions have arisen on how much an officer can modify their weapon for ease of use, ergonomics etc.
Handguards, buttstocks, pistol grips, handguards, optics. Resistance is high on doing any of this,. Even if any install of a part that needs tools would require an armorer to install.
So I have my work cut out for me in trying to guide them into the 21st century. My questions arise from our obtaining new patrol rifles and accessories etc. for them.
One size does not fit all and officers at a higher level of training and interest in weapons have some good ideas on how they want to set up their rifles. Budgets dictate what an agency can afford. But if an officer is willing to invest in the tools that may make him more effective and efficient, what are the real, fact based concerns? I am curious as to what real life concerns there actually are and what facts they are based on that set these types of polices.
I understand there may be some liability in modifying an agency weapon but I know of adjacent agencies that allow their tac team guys to use personal rifles that have been inspected and certified by their agency armorer.

  1. Can anyone cite a lawsuit or legal action against an officer or agency that resulted from an officer installing an aftermarket handguard, different stock, sights, or upper receiver barrel/assembly on an AR type rifle that was involved in a shooting or any other circumstance?

  2. Has anyone ever heard of an officer or agency being involved in a legal action or lawsuit as a result of an officer using a privately purchased holster and used on duty? was the holster the same make and model or retention style as agency issue?

  3. Does anyone have any firsthand knowledge of the concerns about suppressors that I mentioned above. That they can cause a Blue on Blue due to an officer not hearing gunfire in the next room and walking into it? I never heard a suppressed M4 that was that quiet. But maybe I haven’t seen enough movies yet.

Any additional input or copies of agency policies that allow for this would be appreciated to support my arguments based on facts.

The answer to 3 is simple. Fire a suppressed AR next to him. Hammer home the workers comp issues of shooting an AR indoors. Not only the sound but the pressure. OSHA can change management’s minds for them.

Show up at a city council meeting the next time the police budget is up for review.

Ask the city how much they paid out on their last hearing-related disability claim. Then ask about agency pricing on suppressors.

“Orders of magnitude” will be a phrase you might hear.

I work for a rather large dept and all our patrol carbines are privately owned. Our policies on the AR are pretty lax. They have to be at least 16" non NFA or 10" minimum if you want to carry an SBR. Aimpoint is allowed. We have no restrictions on rails, stocks, etc.
As far as holsters, we are issued 6360. If you want to carry a WML, you have to provide your own 6360 that is light compatible.

There’s so much in your post, I don’t know where to begin. Sounds like your first battle is to change the minds of the idiots above you. All the concerns being voiced have been dispelled many times over. All one has to do is look at the major progressive agencies across the country (and some smaller ones too) in regards to red dots, etc… Suppressors are popping up more and more. If you do a Google search you will find multiple articles and papers in regards to hearing loss, etc…

Our agency permitted the installation of different handguards and optics on department issued carbines if they were approved by the Chain of Command and installed by a certified department armorer. The officer had to qualify with the new optic before carrying the carbine in their squad car.

We were also permitted to wear a personally purchased holster if it was similar in appearance to a department issue holster and was of the same or higher security level. The officer had to qualify with the new holster and their service pistol before using the holster on duty.

I am not aware of any legal repercussions in either instance.

Modification of the fire control group of any weapon carried on duty was strictly prohibited. We have no experience with personally purchased sound suppressors.

*Tagged for more info on 5.56x45 suppressor that will attenuate sound so that one cannot hear it being fired in a hallway through a hollow-core door adjacent to the shooter.

Not to mention the large gap between the bottom of the door and floor.

I could buy into this if the guy that can’t hear it is taking fire from unsuppressed weapons on his side of the door.

Maybe people should train not to charge out into hallways without a care in the world.

I only know of one that modified an issued G17. I don’t recall the exact parts and brands, as I remember, trigger, guide rod and some springs, 100 yards of grip tape:eek: Shoot was good, all that mattered, no issues. However, on the flip side, all issued 700 sniper rifles were pulled and triggers replaced as someone modified triggers and one went boom.

A suppressed AR fired indoors is as loud as a 9mm pistol unsuppressed. (my unscientific observation) The idea behind suppressing TAC team’s guns is to be able to tell WHO is doing the firing when other members are in different rooms/areas.

I don’t think they’re anywhere near that loud, but they are definitely not quiet. If you can’t hear a suppressed AR fired inside something is terribly wrong with your hearing.

To the OP: it sounds like your admin is just being lazy. There are plenty of large departments who use aimpoints, allow furniture swaps as long as they don’t affect fire control or gas system, and get along just fine. I’ve never heard of anyone getting into hot water on a GOOD shoot because of equipment mods. Kill the neighbor because of an ND on an out of policy modded weapon, and watch the fur fly.

One of the problems I had as a Patrol Captain was officer modified department weapons. Often times the mod was done by a single officer for his personal preference. That modification would hinder the other 3 officers assigned to that unit as they could not adapt to the modification. We did have a shooting once that the defense attorney tried to make a big deal out of the officer’s personal sidearm that had non-factory sights. That was quashed very quickly by the prosecutor.

  1. No Idea on any lawsuits or legal actions. Admin and line level guys love to talk liability and getting sued, but when asked for evidence, things usually go quiet. Agencies around the world some how make this work. Talk to surrounding agencies or State level agencies and see if you can get a copy of their policies they have in lace as a model for you.

  2. For our department, individual purchase holsters are allowed. The make/model go into your range file, and the deputy must “show proficiency” (meet POST draw/fire time standards) with the holster before it is allowed on the street.

  3. Sounds ridiculous and not grounded in reality to me.

Our agency went to Aimpoint PRO red dot sights a few years ago. It happened like most things usually do: The decision makers had to actually try out the RDS themselves and realize they work. The same thing is slowly happening now with pistol mounted lights; a member of admin tried a pistol mounted light during a night qualification shoot and “Taa-Daa” the ball got rolling.

You have to get the conversation started and grounded in reality with your admin. Source up a few RDS’s and have shooters of all proficiency levels shoot them. Compare qual scores before/after. Run some time sensitive drills and show on paper the actual results in a way they can see it. I would think that when put on a clock or under pressure, the benefits of a RDS should begin to become apparent. Use shooters of all skill levels, don’t just cherry pick your top shooters and Johnny Operator SWAT guys, ad don’t just focus on your worst shooters. Show the benefits to the average street officer/deputy.

In regards to individual modifications to carbines: For a very long time it was forbidden, and only the SWAT guys could do cool stuff (grips, stocks, VFG, lights, etc). Over time some patrol guys said screw it and just started making the mods themselves. Over time, admin reacted and realized it was a fight they were going to lose so they put a system of accountability in place. All mods or swapped in/out gear must be documented and on file for that particular gun. The mods must be done or overseen by a range guy who’s name also goes on the file. Nothing crazy, and you have to be able to return the gun to stock condition with minimal effort (no rails, pulling barrel nuts, triggers, or other internal changes). We run the Mapgpul MOE handguards, noting fancy by any means but it’s a solid interface to mount lights, hand stops, VFG’s, etc.

I’m 6’05" so showing them how one size does not fit all was quite easy. The old skinny A2 grip was no bueno, and and BCM Mod 3 fits my hand nicely. I’m also a lefty, so am ambi charging handle and ambi safety are an easy sell.

You gotta accentuate the positive, and for your benefit by no means should you get some tackleberry guy up there with tons of crap on his rifle. Show Admin some gaudy awful tacky rifle from TOS as an example of what not to do, and in the end ask for RDS, lights, and the option to change out grips and stocks.

what he said the moron who says its a 50yd world needs the dallas fiasco shoved up his ass. if he can popredict a 50 yd shot and no more then have him predict when u will need to use them and DONT GO.

budget a problem???
cut out some of the fancy cars for city exe/clerical.
cut out some new furniture
cut out the annual picnic for the mayor’s people
the paint on the walls is just fine
have the fat ass union steward match the city $$$$ dollar for dollar to be used for weapons gear.
have him hold a reverse rifle for $$ for the troops gear./
have the city council give up their annual picnic for the good of the loyal COPS ON THE JOB

NOT L.O.L.

morons sheeeeesh

carbine 357

Op, so long as your within the guidelines of department policy and or approval you should be gtg.

As echoed earlier your command is being ignorant and lazy.

I hate hearing crap like that. As an administrator for a 200 person agency might I suggest re-assessing and coming at it from a different direction. There are many proposals and writings on this subject. Look for them and contact other agencies for what they did. You might look at promoting 3 things, officer safety, public safety, and liability protection. The bean counters like anything that enhances the first two, and lessens the third. I know you know all the arguments so I won’t go into them here but I will say that the potential financial loss is far greater not having a RDS than it is not having suppressors.

As to modifications, at one time we had several members of our SWAT team carrying thier personal rifles I built for them. I was the only armorer for quite awhile and all mods went through me, and now as Chief Deputy they still do. I won’t let them change out the issued Aimpoints or FCG on department rifles unless it’s approved by me (most won’t buy an SSA so the answer is NO) and as far as other things, some have single points, some 2 points, different attachment options, many have lights, many don’t, we issue pistol lights and of course SWAT has lights but many patrol guys buy thier own rifle lights. Stocks, grips, rails, BUIS are not standardized for us. I want to know and approve what they are doing and in many cases will have them bring me their rifle and I’ll add the items myself so I know it’s right and it gives me a chance to teach a bit and enhance the Deputies knowledge base. In many cases if they leave it with me they get it back painted ala Pat Rogers method as we are a rural agency.

This was touched on in a previous post. Your first, main, and most arduous battle will be city councils. Buying new/better/controlled weapons and accessories will not be something they will be keen on doing.

Per hearing loss, they may not have any WC claims precedence. A lot of places, esp. smaller agencies, have a very real, very dangerous “it couldn’t happen here because it hasn’t happened here” mentality.

While they are home in bed; they are effectively gambling with your safety and that of your fellow officers.

If you can go personal purchase path, as long as all NFA papers are in order and you fall under your agency’s policy you should be fine. If your agency has no policy or no one distinctly qualified to write up a competent, practical long arm policy; try to find a larger agency that does and adapt your policy to fit it provided the sample policy fits within your states UoF doctrine.

FWIW, I was told that provided no illegal modification/cute decoration (i.e. punisher skulls, racist/anti-social slurs, or religious inscriptions) you, in theory, should have no trouble with a jury.

Just document all modifications, date made, who installed them(i.e. certified gunsmith/armorer), what the modification does, and zero data. I was taught in patrol rifle that all longarms should be booked regardless of policy.

Why?

Well, if you did everything in line and appropriately; you will likely never get True Billed. It is rare and so rare that it makes national news for an officer to get True Billed in a shoot. It has to be really sketchy and brow raising.

The main concern is policy violation and civil trial. You can, in theory, violate policy but not necessarily violate the law. You can be fired, no doubt. And you can be left wide open civilly as a consequence. Same if your policy was shoddily written though that falls more on the Agency Head.

All well and good, but this is where most Councils balk. How many shootings have you had in a 5 year span? 10 year? 20 yeat?

If less than 5, most Councils see it as “asking for trouble”.

Same with Felony warrant services. Is there a necessity? Are they frequent enough that you could articulate a need to a reluctant council?

If your Chief will get the policy written up and allow personal use, expect zero support in a shoot from your City.

It seems most Councils(and this is personal opinion) only want the police to generate revenue. They get leery of any equipment upgrades. Even getting new fleet vehicles, body armor, radios, etc.

I’ve heard people say with a straight face “I’ve had the same car for 15 years. Why does the department need new cars/factory rebuilds?”

And that is for vehicles required to cover x amount of miles by 2 or sometimes more officers daily.

You have an uphill battle indeed. At the end of tge day, and I mean this respectfully, it is the Chief’s call how far this will go. He could fight it (and risk his contract) or accede to the Council.

If I were making the case, I would cite these smaller areas that get active shooters. Doubly so if you have even one bank in your area.

Sidearms are purely defensive. Don’t try to bore them with training or personal comfort. They won’t care. Name and Number Syndrome.

Good luck. And FWIW, your life is priceless.
Take that how you will.

ETA I forgot to extrapolate. Why Book A Basic Rifle?

A lot of these lawyers will bring up data books/sheets in civil trial where the burden of proof is much less stringent Anything to make you look undertrained/ignorant/incompetent. Some people think it is too nitpicky. Nope.

It doesnt have to necessarily be like a Countersniper Rifle log. Basic Zero info with updates every time you qual. Keep it with the rifle. You can never be too squared away.

Per someone getting in trouble IIRC there was a guy who got in a beef in the Southwest(Arizona? New Mexico? Cannot recall off top of head) who had “You’re F____ed” on his dust cover. You want to make it so you did what you had to do. IMHO opinion, I think Geissele has gotten where it is fairly conventional, provided you dont pop in a 3 gun trigger (which Geissele expressly advises against).

Suppressors are good mainly to reduce muzzle flash. It will still be loud and louder still if you are taking fire from subjects. Your training and practiced movements/group skills will do more to reduce friendly/sympathetic fire than whose gun is louder. Plus most shootings occur in low light conditions.

If I wanted to encourage policy change, I would reach out to other agencies and request a copy of their patrol rifle policies and administrative rules on the use of personally purchased duty rigs. If other governments and agencies already approved changes to administrative rules pertaining to patrol carbines and duty holsters for their service pistols, I believe that would carry some weight when trying to persuade your Chain of Command and city council. Be ready to present materials on costs and risks as well.