Joining the 1-4 Variable Club

Which one to pick (extended vs. SPR) will depend on your scope and where you want the eyepiece to end up. I went with the SPR mount which puts my P4Xi further forward than the extended. You have to play around with your scope and figure out where it needs to be. Look at where the turrets end up relative to the receiver, then pick the scope mount that places the rings in the right place on the tube. A good point to start would be with the eyepiece at the end of the upper receiver. Move it forward or backward depending on how you shoot and the eye relief of the scope.

https://aeroprecisionusa.com/scope-mounts.html

Using old Trijicon tr accupointnmodel w/ fire red triangle, and Trijicon accupower 1-4X green duplex. Picked
up a PA 1-6X recently, but don’t have much time with it. I do find Trijicon glass tough to beat, at the price point, but would likely be using that Steiner if I already didn’t have the Trijs. Mounts are simple SWFAs cantilevers, but no issues reported.

I have a 1.25-4x Leupold VXR (similar eye relief to the Mark AR) in an Aero SPR mount and it just barely allows an NTCH weld.

Maybe you don’t go NTCH, but the SPR mount gives some flexibility. For adjusting eye relief, it is A LOT easier to move it back on the upper than getting a too short cantilever forward and there is negligible cost in price and weight to get that flexibility.

I will also add that would be a super SUPER light combination. Scope + mount will come in almost a 1/4 lbs less than the 16 oz+ weight of typical lpv scopes before adding a mount.

A short (not the really nice included one) T-15 key will fit in a Magpul or BCM grip to get to the iron sights of needed.

I don’t do nose-to-charging-handle. That’s the main reason the only ACOG I really learned to love was the TA33.

I have the P4xi with the AP “SPR” mount, great scope with a non cluttered reticle and a very bright red dot. The SPR mount positions the rear of the scope over the charging handle which gives me proper eye relief. If Steiner made a P5xi or P6xi, I would be all over it.

I’d like to look into a Trijicon Accupoint with cross-hair-and-dot reticle. I’d have to handle one in person to see how the light transmission is, though.

Maybe it’s my perception, but I don’t think my TA33 ACOG has the same light transmission as the Leupold scopes I’ve owned over the years.

I’m running a Nightforce NXS 1-4X24 with the FC-3G reticle. Nice and bold reticle at 1X needs no illumination under daylight shooting. Does have a BDC and wind holds out to 600 that are valid at 4X. Otherwise the BDC is totally unobtrusive and barely noticed when just running off the the center segmented circle and dot. Made to zero at 200 yards, which is what I prefer, also end up with a perfect coincidence zero at 50 yards.

Eye relief is generous, and optical quality is in my opinion pretty good. A very slight amount of distortion around the edge of the field of view common to 1-x variables. I don’t really notice it while shooting. Light transmission seems very good. Color rendition is very neutral.

Scope is very short, fairly light, and reportedly very robust. My other Nightforce has proven to be extremely robust.

Mounted in a Nightforce Uni-Mount, which gives enough cantilever forward to shoot nose to charging handle if you insist. I have it set so the ocular housing is about 1” or so forward of the charging handle because I do creep a stock particularly in prone position or sitting cross legged. Mount is bombproof strong, returns to zero like a champ if removed and replaced, but is still reasonably light. Uses titanium cross bolts and nuts, probably unnecessary but saves a bit of weight and certainly strong. Lots of clamping force when torqued down to 65in-lbs, rock solid on the upper. The whole combination zeros easily and has never lost zero.

I run offset Magpul MBUS Pro sights on the DD V11 Pro this optic lives on, so a QD mount is not needed. In fact I hate QD mounts, but that is personal.

Deleted due to low knowledge base.

To me, my VXR seems brighter than the P4XI even though the exit pupil on the P4XI is listed as quite a bit larger.

I just received my Steiner PXI 1-4X from Sport Optics for only $439.99
It will be going on a Sig MCX Virtus 300 9" barrel Blackout pistol in a Geissele high mount.

FYI: Grant has the Aero Precision mounts.

http://www.gandrtactical.com/Aero-Precision_bymfg_51-4-1.html

I’ve been running the VX-R Firedot circle (111231) for about 5 years in a LT104 at work. I’ve got about 15 of them on the street in use. The reason I like that reticle set up is we have mostly eotechs in our patrol rifles. The fire dot circle was an easy switch when shooting up close. I also like that leupolds are fairly light weight compared to others. A couple of the push button switches stopped working and Leupold immediately replaced them. We have had no other issues with them. David

This is why I think ultimately I will get a Trijicon Accupoint–as funds allow. I bought the Leupold for now to get me by and let me decide if I want to stick with that type of optic.

I was in the same boat. I loved the TA33. I tried the variable route a couple years ago but ultimately went back to the TA33 due to lack of daylight bright reticles or the eyebox was too small, the TA33 spoils you in that regard. I shoot ntch but still appreciate a huge eyebox.

I have since jumped on the variable bandwagon and I am very happy with the Steiner P4XI in an Aero SPR mount. The only other two variables I liked were the Accupoint 1-4 and the Vortex PST 1-4, BUT, the vortex wasn’t daylight bright and the reticle options of the Accupoint are lacking for any longer range shooting.

so, Doc - it look like we’re seeing a pattern here with the P4xi being a very popular choice for an affordable LPV. That should be at the top of your next purchase list.
The problem I see with using the Leupold to make your decision about LPVs is that it’s not a true 1x, and to me; it does detract for very close range drills like shooting on the move.

If you use the Mr. Guns & Gear standard for true 1x (being able to co-witness irons like an Aimpoint) then the P4XI then it isn’t a true 1x either, but less magnification than the VXR.

I like the VXR circle reticle better for catching the eye when not illuminated, but the P4XI holdovers are more useful.

I do think the VXR eyebox is more forgiving if the 1.25x isn’t a deal breaker.

Illumination brightness is effectively the same. I like the auto on/off on the VXR, but much prefer the P4XI rotary dial instead of having to cycle all the way through levels to go up or down in brightness.

I definitely will consider the Steiner. My thing is with optics: I want to handle one and actually look through it before purchase. Not a lot of people around here are going to carry the Steiner.

I’ve alway liked Leupold because of the superior light transmission. Even my TA33 ACOG doesn’t seem to have this, although it could be my perception.

True, My Leupy is not a 1x; it’s a 1.5x. My 50+ year-old-eyes actually appreciate that. As soon as I shoulder the weapon I’m looking at the target a little closer–not enough to cause over-magnification issues, but enough to be useful.

For CQB? I practiced in-house clearing with the Leupold and a weaponlight mounted to my carbine. No problem that I could see. That’s why I opted for a simple duplex reticle and not a “busier” one. The duplex gives you the focal point without all the range-finding bells and whistles that you probably don’t need if you mainly shoot 0-200.

Still, no optic is off the table if I can handle it and see its advantages in person…

That’s the sucky part for me too and had to effectively take a leap of faith off written and YouTube reviews. Whether it was luck or research, I was happy with both purchases. Overall plusses for me, but with details of each I would tweak if I could which applies to most purchases.

FOV on the PX4i is 110 ft at 1x and 27.5 ft at 4x and is true 1x, according to Steiner. It also has a constant eye relief through the magnification range. The Leupy VXR is 1.25x on the low end and has a 74.2 ft FOV at 1.25x and a 29.4 ft FOV at 4x. The VXR’s eye relief distance also changes .430" thousands of an inch through its magnification range.

I sold my Accupower 1-4 “Green Reticle” to buy the Steiner, I do not regret my decision. The Accupower is fast on target with its segmented reticle, but it is definitely not daylight bright.