I’m no EMT and have never played a doctor on tv, but I stayed at a Holiday Inn Express once, so here’s my 2 cents. Like others have posted, she bled out a lot of blood in that short time. You can see the pool of blood already forming at her feet and legs as she was helped down by the men. That was even before she started to bleed from the mouth and nose. Her eyes were rolling in less than 15 seconds and around 30 seconds the blood started coming out of her mouth and nostrils. I think she died in less than a minute as she didn’t respond to all the commotions around her. I doubt she could have survived that shot even if she was in the OR.
Nothing could have been done, she was dead the minute they pulled the trigger even if she was laying on a table in the OR prepped for surgery with a full trauma team prepped. If I had seen that at work I would have been able to do basically what they did and then we would have pronounced her. It is reprehensible that this happened however no medical care in the world could have saved her.
Judging by where the bystanders were applying direct pressure, the round penetrated either her superior vena cava or aortic arch as well as her esophagus. There’s nothing anyone could have done. Exsanguination (bleeding out) occurs in less than 2 minutes if either of those vessels is ruptured. Looking at the video, she lost approx 3 liters of blood in less than a minute and a half. It was a fatal shot, unfortunately.
I’m a medical physician. That poor woman could not be salvaged even if she was laying on a gurney in an emergency department the moment she was shot. May she RIP.
That vid made me so fuckin angry when I saw it. It is sad to see an innocent young lady shot dead, right next to her father, by a bunch of fuckin cowards. I could imagine myself, standing next to my young daughter when I watched that clip. My heart climbed in my throat.
that was a very sad video. those who shot her are a bunch of cowards no doubt.
I dont think there was any saving her, she was bleeding out awfully fast, by the time she was helped to the ground there was already blood pooling on top of here and underneath her. there was blood coming out of her mouth within seconds.
I think that weather or not they could have drained the fluid out of her lungs, she would have died from loss of blood. my heart got a little heavy watchin that one.
Only hitting the brain or the upper spinal cord will instantly kill someone. Like previous posters have said, it can take a while to bleed out. Judging by the blood at the end she was either hit in the heart, or some major artery was punctured, in addition to the lungs. When you breath in you’re actually contracting a muscle down to create a vacuum to suck the air in. Pressure wise you’re naturally defaulted to breath out. Thus if there’s any sort of puncture to the lungs the lung itself is going to start to collapse and suck in other things. IE no more air for you. Anyone who’s had a pneumothorax can tell you exactly how much it blows chunks. It’s treatable to a large degree in a hospital, but the bullet destroying a major blood vessel isn’t.
Neda’s only cure would have been someone killing the shooter first.
Honestly I wouldn’t want anyone working on me if they thought I had no chance. I want someone with the mindset of that 1% chance that she can make it. I’m gonna do everything that I can to save her.