In search of a subcompact

I am in search of a subcompact and would like you guys opinion of them. Which do you carry and why? Which are good options? Thank you for all your input.

I carry a P2000SK because I’m an HK snob, but I also own a G26 and it carries equally well. I find the Glock to be quite a bit less comfortable to shoot because its grip is so short and fat, but the trigger is tough to beat. The only mod I’ve made to the SK is I added an HK45C mag release, and that makes it one of the sweetest subcompacts on the market IMHO.

The glock 26 is a pretty awesome carry gun, I got just over 2k rounds through mine with no issues, just swap out the stock sights.

g26 and hk p7 are my little guns of choice.

It’s not for me, but the M&P 9C I just bought my wife for our anniversary (which falls on Valentine’s Day) is really nice.

I carry a P2000SK in .40S&W, my wife has a S&W M&P9C in 9mm that she really likes and a G27. If you’re going .40, go HK if you are going 9mm the 9C or the G26 are great options.

I am looking heavily into getting an M&P9c because it is the same size as a G26 as far as concealment is concerned, and carries 2 additional rounds in the factory mag than a G26. The fact that I also carry an M&P9fs plays into this decision as well.

I’d suggest an M&P compact or a subcompact Glock in whatever caliber tickles your fancy. I currently carry a Glock 26 regularly, but am waiting on an M&P40c, primarily because they fit my hands a bit better.

What are you using for a full size handgun?

My choice is the G26. It’s pocket-able if that mode of carry becomes necessary, and it takes the full size magazines for reloads.

EDC=Glock 26

It works very well for me…

Drew

When it comes to “subcompacts,” I class them into three categories - backups, pocket guns, and mouse guns. For me, a backup is a small, light FIGHTING pistol that compliments your primary, either as a second pistol on your person, or as a smaller version of your primary for deep concealment applications. Pocket guns are, simply, guns that you can carry easily in the pocket of most slacks or shorts. Mouse guns are guns you carry “when you can’t carry a gun,” and typically are very small, very light, and in questionable calibers.

FOR ME, I wouldn’t consider carrying anything under “backup” size as a primary defensive pistol. Again, FOR ME, I consider the following to be “backup” sized guns: G26/27/33, M&Pc’s in 9/40/357, HK P2000sk’s, etc. Any of the above will do, and, FOR ME, the logical step is to obtain a backup that’s a miniature version of your daily carry “primary,” or at least a VERY similar design/action. My choice is the G26, which allows me to carry a G19 +2 magazine on the belt as a reload.

When we start talking about pocket guns, you’re in the realm of the J-frame and similar sized “snubbies,” Kahrs, Ruger’s new LC9 (though it’s on the largish side for pocket carry), Kel-Tec’s PF9, the Rorbaugh, and similar. In this category, the Kahr PM9 is my choice - offering excellent sights, decent trigger, decent capacity, decent caliber, and well above average (for this class of pistols) accuracy. If the PM9 dropped off my list of authorized carry guns, I’d probably look for a S&W 340 M&P - which I consider pretty darned close to the pinnacle of snub nose revolver development.

Mouse guns come from a HUGE number of manufacturers, in every caliber you can think of up to and including .380 ACP. The top three contenders in this category, IMHO, are the S&W Bodyguard, the Ruger LCP, and the Kel-tec P3AT. For my money, even as a “running shorts” gun, I wouldn’t trust my life to anything under .380 ACP, though there are LOTS of folks out there who swear by their .32s (especially in Kel-tec). Of the three .380s I listed, the Bodyguard has the best sights and trigger, and comes with an integral laser, but you pay the price in size and weight, it’s really only fractionally smaller than the PM9. The P3AT and LCP will actually conceal fairly well in the front pocket of your jeans, which is saying something. I’ve never owned an LCP, so I can’t really comment on it, though it seems like they’re still back and forth on “new gun” teething issues with it. The P3AT, on the other hand, I’ve owned two - the first was a POS that wouldn’t feed ball reliably, and which shot groups in the 12-24" range at 7 yards - despite repeated trips back to the factory. The second one I owned was reliable with everything EXCEPT Corbon JHP, and was “coke can” accurate out to about 10 yards - which is WAY more than can reasonably be expected, IMHO, from a pistol like this.

Regards,

Kevin

This is exactly my dilemma. My current fs is an M&P9 w/ DCAEK and yesterday I shot a guy’s 9c w/ DCAEK and it was a completely different trigger feel. I was set to buying the 9c but after feeling that trigger I am very confused. I was not able to keep 10 rds in 6in @ 10 yds and to me that is unacceptable. I am not sure if the trigger feels different because my fs is the thumb safety version and his 9c wasn’t or what.

I use a G27. My fullsize gun is a G22. I can use the same holster for both and it can take the fullsize mags. I really like the concept of the chopped down duty gun. The difference in trigger feel may have been a fluke with that particular gun. I’ve felt a lot of Glocks that had different trigger pulls even though they supposedly had identical parts. Try a few more for a larger sample size. BTW, can the subcompact be had with a thumb safety? It would seem important to keep consistent.

I’ve tried a few compact guns in the past with poor results. My shooting with them was always much worse in terms of accuracy and followup. However I’ve been running a fullsize M&P9 for a few months and decided to try a compact. I set it up exactly the same way I have my FS set up. To my surprise I can shoot the SC almost as well as the full size, so I guess my advise would be to get the compact version of whatever fullsize you’re most familiar with.

I carry a S&W M&P9c, loaded with either Speer Gold Dot +Ps or BHA hollow points, in a CompTac holster with one spare mag. It works well, fits my hands almost perfectly, and is a great shooter.

That is the reason I didn’t stick with the M&Ps. When I went searching for a compact I couldn’t find one that was even remotely close (trigger pull & feel) to my fullsize. In the end I went with the G26 and I’m glad I did! It started off at a “summer” carry but I loved the little guy so much that it splits year around duty with my G19. Take a hard look at the G26.

I have a 9mm P2000 SK V3, they are also available in .40 S&W and .357 Sig.

My SK has great ergonomics, is extremely accurate and dead nuts reliable.

It’s soft shooting especially given it’s size and it’s fun at the range.

Very easy to control on single shots, double taps and rapid fire.

The P2000 SK’s adjustable grip should fit almost anyone.

Take a close look at one dvdlpzus, I think you might like it.

I just picked up a 2000SK and am new to H&K. What does the addition of a 45C mag release give you? And what kind of holsters are those?

The P2000/SK and USP/c mag release levers can be a little tight and difficult to manipulate at times. By adding the HK45c mag release, you gain a larger paddle and more leverage that = better and easier magazine release. It’s a 2-minute upgrade and well worth the purchase.

As for my preference regarding a sub-compact, I run a P2000SK V3 9mm. Love it!!