I need another Glock and would like more opinions

I just sold off 2 toys I didn’t use and want to “reinvest” the money back into my hobbies. I a CHP holder in NC and carry a G19 or Kahr PM9 daily. I am of the low speed persuasion but do take classes and shoot IDPA. This pistol will mainly be a IDPA/class gun and my carry G19 would be my back up.

Do I want a G34, which I would consider a game gun, A G17, which is the Glockfather and would be great from the bedside, or another G19 which I know and love?

Then for a G17 or G34, should I consider the Gen 4 or stick with a Gen3? If I got another G19 I would get a Gen 3 for parts interchangeability.

Thoughts?

I am by no means an expert, but I have had a 26 for a few years. I just got a 17 for the bedside and love it. It is a Gen 3 - kinda OCD, but I wanted them to match.

If I just had the 19, I’d get a 26. I have a 19 and a 26 now and I’d like to get a 17 when funding permits.

I know it wasn’t on your options. But the 26 works at times when the 19 doesn’t…

Okay, let me get this straight. You would get a G26 for IDPA? When does a 19 NOT work? I guess when you are trying to carry it in your sock…

OP, the G17 is one of the finest 9mm’s ever made and it would certainly work for IDPA…

Thanks. Also I mentioned I had a PM9, it goes pretty much anywhere.

I just picked up a new gen3 g17 last week, plan on mounting an RMR on it this coming week, great gun.

you dont need other gun for IDPA, with your g19 you are pretty good… if you shoot idpa and overcome your g19, then is moment buy other one…

for IDPA it is a pretty good idea to shoot what you carry…

the g17 is good too, but if you already have a g19, you can buy a g34 and do a trigger job… but if you are no an expert shooting like 4 shoot/second, you are ok with the g19…

I use a M&P9 for IDPA and get a g19 to use both. and I have a friend with a g26(short barrel) and he get good scores too.

17, 19, 26, 34- you know you’ll be fine with whichever. but since you carry the 19, i say you should do ALL of your shooting with the 19. classes for sure, but competition too. and have them configured identically.

or just get another fun gun and use the carry gun for classes and competition. if i ever get off my ass and start doing Action Pistol at my club, i fully intend to use the very glock 17 i carry every day.

you and that gun are literally attached at the hip… it should be figuratively, as well.

I will have the triggers set-up the same and the same sights, but I would like the longer sight radius for games.

I currently shoot about 6K rounds a year in classes, competition or “on the clock” at my local range. My G19 and I are tight.

Well then…

I didn’t see that you wanted to get a gun for IDPA, that said, I’ll echo the above statements and say to use your G19 for IDPA. There are plenty of times when the Glock 26 conceals better than the G19, not really sure if I need to expand on why that is or not.

If I could only have 2 glocks in your situation it would be the 19/26. If I could have 3 then the 17/19/26 (or 34 instead of 17), the 17 being my IDPA gun, and the 19/26 being my concealed weapons depending on situation.

Two is one and one is none.

Get another G19. That way you have a backup and all your holsters and everthing will work.

Then you can get a G17, a G26 and a G34 in that order afterwards. Because you’re not going to be able to stop :stuck_out_tongue:

IMO, Glocks should be purchased in this order: Compact, Sub Compact, Full Size, Niche.

I love my G34. I shoot it the most out of my other glocks. I have 2 19’s, 20, 23, and a 36.

I recently got a 19 gen 4 over the holidays and I really really like it. So I guess my vote may be biased.

Like others have said, having a spare is never a bad thing.

I voted for G19 and wish I would’ve went this route instead of G17 and G19.

I carry a 34 concealed daily. So I chose that.

I used to carry a 19 but then I realized I had no problem with the 34, and since it is my sidearm of choice for my pistol and carbine classes it was a no brainer.

My vote is for the 19 because it’s your primary carry pistol. After you have two of those, then start getting other models.