First off let me start by saying that no matter what anyone says I’m just glad that Magpul got someone to produce this rifle.
So on Friday me and a buddy of mine took my ACR and his SCAR 16 to the range. Long story short…the ACR won…I will explain.
After having zeroed the SCAR we decided to get them a little dirty, we both detached our slings from the front point and left the rear attached. Holding the loose end of the sling tossed them out into the muddy retention pond.
I wish I had taken the time to document this more but hindsight is 20/20
Anyway, after getting them out of the water we shot them…the ACR won in that it downed 60 rounds with no failures. The SCAR on the other hand failed to cycle, it would fire one round and then you would have to manually cycle the bolt. It took field striping the rifle and rinsing all the mud out to get it running somewhat…it would still fail to cycle about 60-70% of the time.
My friend is now getting ready to sell his SCAR and get an ACR
Unfortunately due to this test I did go ahead and clean the hell out of the ACR, round count before cleaning was at about 2300
I’m also including some slow motion videos from a few weeks ago
As for your test. Completely un-scientific and since have no idea what variables came into play it really means nothing. I highly doubt that your testing was more exhaustive than the testing which the SCAR was put through by SCOM.
It was not meant to be a scientific test…if the gun doesn’t run when it gets a little muddy then it is worthless to me. Not to mention I find it funny that I have yet to see a video of any kind of mud or over the beach test with the SCAR. From what I’ve seen the SCAR has allot of flaws and simply put after the hell I have put my ACR through I am much more inclined to trust it with my life than I will ever be with a SCAR
This is a ridiculously silly test, and if your friend is that willing to sell his SCAR after it, he must have been eager to sell it in the first place and simply needed an excuse.
I have extreme doubts that the ACR could currently pass all the tests that the SCAR had to pass. Heck… Bushmaster can’t even ship the rifle with proper 5.56 chambers - why would I expect them to do proper testing?
Some people have had to have extra rings installed on the ratchet mechanism because some rifles are shipping without good enough quality control to catch that it was insufficiently tightening the barrel.
I’d repeat the test 5 or 10 times…
1 test really tell you nothing
nice vids btw
I have extreme doubts that the ACR could currently pass all the tests that the SCAR had to pass. Heck… Bushmaster can’t even ship the rifle with proper 5.56 chambers - why would I expect them to do proper testing?
not to sound like a ACR koolaid drinker or smartass but .mil ACR are made by Remington not Bushy…I bet those are made to different specs
I am sorry, but I highly doubt that yuor experience rivals that of the people who tested it. Exactly what experience do you have a with a military issued SCAR?
I have fired civilian SCAR’s and .MIL issue ones. Aside from the quirky things like the reciprocating charging handle and getting used to the controls I can’t say that I experienced issues.
But, I highly doubt that it would have progressed as far as it did with such a flaw. Especially in light of the fact that the SCAR 17 surely isn’t going anywhere and it is the same weapon with an obvious caliber change.