Think what you want. I have personally tested at least 20 different brand / versions of SSDs (as I am sure you have since you seem to be so knowledgeable).
I have experimented with SSDs in RAID configurations to try and speed access to Oracle databases, I have tried various drives in single configurations to test boot, read-write operations, and failure rates.
Many of the early OCZ and Kingston drives had high failure rates because of some “manufacturing inconsistencies”. I have a stack of them, but they are really too light to be paper weights.
Also there are some issues we have seen with the controllers on SSD drives not working in all systems. Mac Pros seem to be finicky. We have had issues with SSD drives with Adaptec RAID controllers.
And if you try to clone SSD drives on a Logicube OmniClone for a mass deployment it is certainly a hit or miss if they will all work. Try to clone from one SSD to another? Forget about it.
How many drives have you personally tested? And reading Amazon reviews does not count.
Additionally there are a number of issues with data recovery if an SSD drive has a failure of any kind. Due to the fact that each drive manufacturer implements wear-leveling using different algorithms it is nearly impossible to recover deleted/lost data.
Also as Skyyr pointed out in his post SSDs have a finite number of RW cycles. This in essence means your drive is getting smaller and smaller with each use. Of course if all you do is surf the Internet and post on M4C your drive will last a long time. However in my job we actually use our computers and write to disks frequently with large volumes of data.
To continue in the advantage/disadvantage vein, when you look at the cost per MB or GB it is very hard to justify an SSD drive except in specific circumstances.
Let’s say you are a performance junkie. A 240GB OCZ RevoDrive is listed at $624 on Newegg. A 300 GB WD VelociRaptor is $149. A dollar here and a dollar there and pretty soon you are talking real money. Does the OCZ have nearly 5 times the value of the WD? Perhaps. Depends on your particular situation.
Maybe we should look at a more pedestrian example. Maybe the 240GB OCZ Agility is a better bargain at $489. However when we compare that to the 750GB Seagate Momentus which is a hybrid drive with a very large cache and 3GB/Sec SATA interface at $100 there is still a huge difference.
If you are a road warrior and want an SSD to increase battery life of your portable, an SSD may fit the bill. SSDs consume much less power and are obviously soundless since there are no moving parts.
However if you actually need a drive with capacity an SSD is a rather pricey option.
I can take this to any level you want. But this is a firearms site so no need. Guns are way more fun, computers are just work.