I did a search here and couldn’t find quite the answer I was looking for. Maybe I missed it.
I just finished assembling my new upper using the following parts:
Sabre Defence 1:7 14.5in 5.56 chrome lined mid-length barrel
Rock River Arms BCG
Yankee Hill Machine (“Keyhole” marked) stripped upper
Clymer 5.56 GO and NO-GO gauges from Brownell’s.
I assembled everything using the proper tools and a Snap-on torque wrench that was recently re-certified. Torqued the barrel nut to 35ft-lbs then tightened it until the next hole aligned with the gas tube.
I thoroughly cleaned the chamber of the new barrel and inserted the NO-GO gauge. It didn’t even come close to closing. Good. I moved onto the GO gauge. The bolt began to slightly rotate into the locked position behind the locking lugs of the barrel extension. However, it would not go into full battery. I had another brand new RRA BCM laying around so I tried it. Same exact problem. I then tried chambering some M193 and various .223 Hornady and Prvi rounds. They all chambered with no more effort required than closing the bolt on an empty chamber. Next I tried a slightly used (less than 100rds) RRA BCG that I had out of another fairly new rifle. This bolt closed on the GO guage with only moderate force. (i.e. I was able to push it closed wit the palm of my hand.)
It’s important to note that the bolts were NOT stripped during these test. Is that my problem? Will stripping the bolt give me the required added clearance?
Is there a known issue between RRA bolts and Sabre barrels?
Being that the bolt “almost” locks, would it be safe to shoot low powered .223 ammo to “break in” the new bolt and chamber?
Thanks for the help guys. This is my first time assembling an upper. I’m an anal retentive Mechanical Engineer so I like mechanical things to work perfectly!
With brand-new bolts check to make sure the extractor is going over the rim of the headspace gage, otherwise the bolt carrier group may not be going all the way forward (as you noticed, may not be rotating and locking into the barrel extension).
DO NOT drop the bolt carrier group onto the gage by hitting the bolt stop and letting that huge mass bash the gage into the chamber.
The extractor was going over the headspace gauge. For that matter, it was extracting it. While doing these tests the upper and lower were not mated so I was not dropping the bolt onto the gauge.
I always remove the extractor when checking headspace.Just makes it easier for me.
As far as not closing on a go…both of my new Armalite M15A4 20" uppers I bought last fall were tight on a go gauge.I installed LMT BCG’s and they headspaced perfectly on a go and would not close on a Brownells Colt 5.56 Field.So I ran with it.
Checking the depth of the bolts showed the Armalite bolts had .002" less recess to the bolt face than the LMT.
Same with my older 2000 model Armalite M15A2.It will not close on a go gauge and has an excessively tight leade to boot.It shoots .223 Rem ammo perfectly,but will not chamber 5.56 NATO at all.Forces the ogive of the bullet into the leade which is nota good thing.
So I would try another/better bolt and see what you get.
My recommendation would be to get a FIELD gage since there is no requirement for a GO or NO GO in the TM. If it passes then you are good to go. Bushmaster sells a true 5.56 FIELD gage for about 25.00 or so. Also, Bill Ricca had genuine USGI gages for about the same price. I bought 3 of them and use one at my shop all the time. I also use the FIELD gage on my personal AR’s as well.
Can’t answer your last question but I will say this: Do Not chamber a cartridge and insert BCG into upper that is not fully mated to a lower! Let’s say the assembly slips out of your hand, next thing you know have a .224 hole in your foot and the BCG flew out the upper and hit you in the twig and berries. I know you probably thing you are safe enough to do this, but it’s this type of complacency that hurts people. Use the gauges, save the ammo for the range.
I honestly do appreciate the warning. I guess it’s something I never really thought about. Luckily, I happened to have the upper held in a vise while working on it. (Rubber jaw pads holding the free float tube.) Normally, I don’t have it secured like that. 95% of the time while working on guns, it’s just sitting on the bench in front of me.
Cartridge/ammunition specs will be tighter than chamber specs.
A chamber reamed to “GO” dimensions is supposed to accept any “in spec” cartridge. That means the “in spec” cartridge has to be shorter dimensionally than the chamber spec.
The “No Go” covers the allowable variance in the chambering operation.
Purchasing a FIELD guage when your chamber won’t accept a GO guage won’t address your situation.
I’d recommend you remove the ejector and test accordingly. If still snug, send it back. It would need further reaming.
It can be, but it’s hard on tooling and you’ll lose the benefit of the chrome-lined chamber.
If it comes to the point where further reaming is warranted I’d request they replace it with a new CL barrel and verify that the chanbering job is within GO/NO GO specs.
I guess my point was that if everything is new and was assembled properly and you were to insert a FIELD gage and the bolt did not close as per the TM then I would call it good. I really don’t get into the whole GO/ NO GO thing since there is no requirement for one in the TM. Just my thoughts and YMMV.
This subject of the headspace within the AR has been one of the areas that raised itself during the design of the 6.5 Grendel. Being able to address both cartridge and also chamber it was interesting to see the interaction.
It is usual for the go gauge to use a common datum diameter and length to that shown for the chamber minimum. Lacking the mechanical leverage of a bolt action and beset with multiple contact points the ability of a chamber to digest a go gauge in an AR without slaming the action is normally an indication that the finished chamber is at least 0.001" longer than the minimum and more typically 0.002".
It is also common to see even well made assemblies bed the high spots during the first 10 to 50 rounds and this, together with the removal of the phosphate from the lugs, will account for typically 0.002" and sometimes even 0.003" This bedding process is one of the reasons that if possible the bolt should remain with the rifle it started with.
As a final point, consideration should be given to the fact that the barrel will elongate the chamber by around 0.001" for every 35 F deviation above the original fitting temperature.
Given the OP description of the behaviour of the barrel with the go gauge I would assume that this barrel will settle to a very good condition.
Turning now to ammunition, this will by definition at the maximum condition still be smaller than the minimum chamber. I have not analized the 5.56 as I do not make this caliber but I would assume that the manufactureres will run to the bottom of the tolerance band. If so I would expect to see a drop of about 0.004 below the minimum chamber.
Returning to the OP the ammunition will be seen to fit easily and subsequent work across the rifle will settle the nominal headspace clearance to around 0.004/0.005" This can be investigated crudely by placing a circle of photocopier paper on the rear of the brass case and closing a bolt without the extractor and ejector in place. A very light resistance will be present. The go gauge will now close but adding the paper circle will prevent this.
Well I called Rock River Arms today. After only 5 or 10 minutes on hold I spoke with one of their techs, P.J. He was very helpful and willing to explain all I ever wanted to know about headspace and more. He said the situation I’m experiencing isn’t all that uncommon. It’s just that many rifles are never even checked with a GO gauge. He claims even RRA’s builders do not use GO gauges when assembling rifles. They only check with a NO GO gauge. The assembled rifles are then taken to the range and test fired. If they chamber rounds, then worrying about the headspacing being too short isn’t an issue. He insisted that since the lugs of my bolts rotate approx 1/3 of the way behind the barrel extension lugs, then it’s only a matter of a few dozen rounds before it would close on a GO gauge. I explicitly asked if the rifle blowing up is a concern and he said no.
Do you guys agree with this? I plan on taking it to the range this weekend and feeding it a box of Prvi .223 Match ammo.
Did you bother to read my post above? The military TECH MANUAL does not call for a GO or NO GO gage. The FIELD gage is the only one that is used. If the bolt closes on a FIELD gage then you follow the corrective action outlined.
Yes, I definitely read your post. And all responses to questions I post on forums for that matter. I appreciated your reply.
However, I do keep it in the back of my mind that this IS this internet. Not all of what is posted on forums is 100% accurate. I’m by no means doubting your knowledge of the subject. But hearing it straight from the mouth of someone at RRA or seeing it done on a respected website helps reaffirm the statements I read on forums.