HD Penetration Testing...in the Home.

Interesting video of the guys from Valor Ridge testing the penetration of some popular standard and HD 5.56, 7.62, 9mm, and even some .308.

//youtu.be/PbdmQ5IN2j0

Some of the rounds tested include standard Ball, Speer GDs (two different weights), TBBC, SMK, & HST. Nothing earth shattering but some of the results were a bit surprising. My favorite takeaway…

…“Refrigerators aren’t cover.”

Excellent video. Reminds me of the old box-o-truth website and testing.

Yup, great stuff. It’s always fun when people see what they “know” tested and proven wrong for the first time.

Exactly. I suspect it causes one to cling slightly less bitterly to one’s dogma.

And it’s always fun to shoot shit.

I thought the selection of ammo in the test was excellent. I’d venture to guess that many people in the shooting community have at least one of the included rounds loaded up and ready to go. I know I do, and it definitely gave me some things to think about. Hopefully they put out some more videos of this level of quality and relevance.

Looks fun. Was interesting.

Surprised they didn’t have a shotgun and some buckshot and slugs available.

And a .22 or .25.

enjoyed it.

Not trying to be a douche because that was fairly interesting to watch, but I’d love to see one of the guys who shoots gelatin do something like this so we could see the actual ballistic performance of the round after hitting these barriers.

I’d thought the same thing. As it stands, I definitely find value in what they did. But, it would have been even better if they’d introduced some gel. Granted, with all the rounds they fired, that would have required a lot of ballistic gel. If they’d used the Clear Ballistic stuff it might have been doable; as its not temp sensitive and is reusable. However, the results would have then been questioned by some, as there’s evidence to suggest that Clear BG is not a 1:1 match for the traditional BG.

Still, I like that they did this as a standalone test and took multiple shots with each load. It provides a rough expectation of how each of those rounds would react with potential misses in a HD situation. We always want to see what type of performance will be had with hits, but data on misses may be even more critical. I’m not under any illusion that I’d be guaranteed to have a 100% hit ratio if it came to defending my home. So, having an expectation when it comes to misses can help to mitigate the risk to any innocent individuals nearby.

There is a bit of data through drywall into gel. Iirc federal shows the test for each round. I think it’s one layer. It would be interesting to see, say fed fusion though increasing layers of drywall and gel to see the effect.

No need since Speer, Federal and Hornady already have after barrier performance gel shots on their websites. You can substitute the shots on steel for the refrigerator :stuck_out_tongue:

I think its more illuminating how much FMJs and OTMs deviate wildly after multiple barriers.

Lol. Good point.

You’re definitely right that there’s plenty of other info out there from the MFGs and YouTube ballisticians when it comes to gel and barriers. Still, as much as I trust the folks over at Federal, Speer, and Hornady, it’s nice to have additional data from outside parties to verify.

Well, as soon as the weather breaks I might be able to run this test. I was gifted some Clear Ballistics Gel last year, but have not yet had a chance to use it. I have a little bit of TBBC and 50gr TSX, a nice pile of Remington CLUB, and bunch of Fusion and GDs. Also did a bit of remodeling last Fall. So I’ve got plenty of Drywall, 2x4s, and Plywood. Although, the coolest thing is probably the windshield from our Cherokee Trailhawk that I saved. Damn rock cracked it on the highway. Definitely sucked spending the money to replace it…might as well make lemonade. So, for anyone that can look past the use of Clear Ballistics instead of genuine Ordnance Gel, I’ll be attempting to finally put it to use this Spring. Maybe I’ll put up a poll to see what everyone wants to see first.

As for other barriers, I’ve had a thought rolling around in my head for a while. Has anyone ever come across testing with a memory foam mattress acting as the barrier? It might sound dumb, but I’ve wondered how it would handle some of the common pistol and rifle rounds. Those memory foam mattresses are extremely dense and can be pretty thick. So, I’d imagine one would at least absorb a nice chunk of a bullet’s energy. I did find one thread that essentially asked the same question, but for mattresses in general. A couple people talked about NDs making their way through a traditional mattress and box spring, but that’s not all that surprising. If nothing else, hopefully I’m not the only one that’s had this random thought about memory foam.

This made me think of when I saw locals using a sand filled refrigerator is a part of their battle position while OCONUS. Better than nothing but definitely not the best.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I could see that being a decent “improvised” option if nothing better was available. It would be interesting to fill a box or tote/tub with sand and see how far rifle rounds would penetrate. There’s a company who makes bullet traps filled with rubber. IIRC, most of their traps are only about 2-3 feet deep. And, from what I’ve seen, they stop some pretty serious rounds. I’d imagine sand would do about the same.

Hmm never thought about that.

I’m curious about hp clogging with it, now that you got me thinking.

As my buddy always says, the perfect back stop IS the bad guy. Bullets are going to pass through most everything in your house. Don’t worry about it (and don’t miss). :wink:

C4

This was pretty cool Thanks for the link.

Definitely possible that it could clog a HP. Frankly, I’d only been thinking about the density of memory foam. Makes me want to test it even more now.

I’ve just always thought that if I somehow ended up hunkered down in the bedroom, a dresser and the 14" memory foam mattress would make a pretty good barricade/barrier. Likely scenario? Uhhhh No. Fun to ponder? I’ve wasted time considering far more unusual things :laugh:

Oh, the bad guy would certainly be A backstop :slight_smile:

Point taken on the pass through. Any self defense round that can’t defeat common barriers in the home probably isn’t much of a defensive round to begin with. So, hopefully their next video covers the “don’t miss” aspect.

No, that was some solid operatin’ brother! Refrigerators are about 2’ thick. If it is full of sand, that is like a 3 sand bags deep wall. I bet it would stop 7.62x51 (or 54) easy, I’ll take that ghetto bunker if it’s all I got any day.