FSB and hand guard lenghts

Hello everyone,

I’ve done my research here but I’d like to verify that I understand what I’m talking about. I’m building a ‘backup rifle’ and I want it to have a FSB (I’ve done folding BUIS up to this point).

If I have a 16" barrel with a carbine gas system, I can use a 7" hand guard and have an exposed FSB. If I want a longer rail I’ll have to use a low profile gas block.
If I have a 16" barrel with a mid-length gas system, I can use a 9" hand guard and have an exposed FSB. Anything longer will require a low profile gas block.

Correct?

Thanks you for your input and enjoy the new world.

JRCI

You are correct.

MM

Sounds Right.

You can get longer rails that have cut out for the FSB as well. Centurion. Troy.

Or find an appropriate Centurion C4 rail with cutouts and avoid having an exposed FSB.

I run a DD M4V1 and this is what it looks like: http://www.mrcolionnoir.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/02-050-2000l_1.jpg

I use Troy Delta rails for my middys. Not only do I keep the front sight but I can mount a light in front of it.

Add another fan of the FSB cutout options. I’ve got a Midwest Industries 12.5" on a Carbine length system that’s served me well.

If you don’t want a rail system the Magpul MOE SL handguards will give you about and extra 2" of gripping space as they wrap around the FSB. They come in both carbine and mid-length sizes.

Thank you all very much for the information.

I’ve looked at the Troy and Centurion rails and it would be nice to have more real estate, but I’m so used to not having to time the barrel nut (using Geissele and KMR rails) that I don’t really want to go back.
Since the 9.5" Geissele MK8 won’t fiit, I’d like to have a 9" KMR rail on this thing. I just need to make sure that it will fit on a midlength barrel with an FSB. Having never used an FSB before, I’m a little nervous :slight_smile:

Thanks again,

I found a picture of just what I’m looking for. Looks good to me.

JRC

The Centurion uses an OEM barrel nut, which is very easy to time as there’s miles of room for the gas tube in each notch. As long as the gas tube passes through, that’s all the timing you need. Takes less than a minute if your rifle doesn’t already have it on there. Do you already have an upper, or no?

And as far as rails; I’ve used Midwest Industries FSP rail, and it’s outclassed by Centurion for sure, but it’s a good alternative for a 12" FSP. It would fit over a carbine-length gas system. Centurion makes FSP’s for carbine and mid-length with rails extending out to the end of the FSB, but they don’t do the 12" carbine anymore. I personally could, and do on a couple of rifles, live quite happily with just a 9" handguard and a mid-length FSB. As for a 9" KMR behind an FSB, I am a big fan of that setup. The 9" will fit a mid-length without the handguard cap. What do you plan to actually mount, and how much real estate do you think you’ll actually use?

That’s what Ive been running for a few years…love it.

Thanks for the information. You bring up a good point. The only things that I would be mounting are a light and a hand stop. This rifle is intended to be a backup to my main rifle. That’s one thing that I didn’t point out. I’d prefer it to be a keymod rail as that’s what my main rifle is. If necessary I’d be able to swap the light and hand stop. I came across this rail from Strike Industries (Mega Fins G2) http://www.strikeindustries.com/shop/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/9df78eab33525d08d6e5fb8d27136e95/1/_/1_9_4.jpg that appears to do everything I want. But, the pricing is quite a bit lower than the other stuff out there, and that always makes me worry.

JRC

FYI- all I have on mine is an Inforce WPl sitting at 12:00 right in front of the FSB…and a stubby BCM pistol grip underneath. Been good for me.

My primary rifle has the Daniel Defense Omega 9" rail, with Surefire G2X Tactical, Vltor Scout QD mount and AFG2. Been running it for years and it has served me well. Though its noticeably heavier than my secondary rifle similarly equipped but with BCM KMR and ELW barrel, the DD Omega is still light for a quad rail, much lighter than my old issued M4.

I’ve gone through a similar thing, so I’ll share some thoughts from my A to B. It’s going to be a slight ramble (yes, there has been beer this morning), but hopefully it applies somewhat.

One of my go-to’s has a 12:00 light and finger stop on a KMR13, and I wanted things to be relatively similar with my irons-only/backup gun, but with a fixed FSB. I went back and forth on what I really needed. Did I need rails, free-float, or the most comfortable setup to be effective? I knew I wanted the light mounted to something metal, and I knew I had a propensity to ditch 7" handguards, no matter how committed I was at the start.

So with those parameters and a couple weeks of consideration, my top choices were pared down to;

  • 6920 with a shorter Centurion FSP or 12" MI FSP (as mentioned, I’ve owned one and despite it not being as nice as Centurion, it was solid enough)
  • DDM4V1
  • BCM Mid-Length with a KMR9, Centurion 9", or Centurion Mid-Length FSP
  • BCM Mid-Length w/Drop-in aluminum, or a PKMR if it were out to go with an MI or BCM FSB light mount.

The 6920 setups would work just fine. The MI FSP was a good handguard in my use, and an X300 at the front feels great. But, it’s a lot of bulk and weight for a simple light setup and a hand stop. The short Centurion FSP would be fine as well, it places the light exactly where it’d be on a 9" rail so comfort would be fine, but how much do I need a free-float? That question kept coming up for me. The DDM4V1 got eliminated for the same reasons as the 6920/12" FSP combo; weight/bulk. The free-float BCM setups all had the same free-float question as well. The mid-length FSP would certainly put the light further out and in a more comfortable spot, but when drop-ins and cantilever mounts are available, how much am I buying a “want” with the FSP Centurion? By this point, I was really leaning towards the drop-ins, and simply opted out of the KMR9 setup.

So I got another BCM mid-length, and explored the drop-ins. First, polymer drop-ins and an MI FSB light mount. It was functional, but the MI was just too bulky for me. I could of course use an IWC mount on CAR-style handguards, or a Magpul MOE, or wait for the PKMR, but I just kept going back to wanting my light on something metal. And that’s when I finally landed on a drop-in MI KeyMod handguard. It’s lightweight (lighter than MOE’s), it’s comfortable, I hung an M600U off the 12:00 that is out of the way but accessible, and I have just as much gripping space on a 9" handguard as I do on the KMR13 with the light and front sight at the end. And in use, I have had zero complaints.

So, I say all of that to say this… don’t be afraid of trying a standard mid-length and a 9" handguard. It’s a backup, after all. It doesn’t need to be the most comfortable, it just needs to be ready to roll when you need it. If you do need more real estate later on, that’s always an option, but a 9" drop-in makes a lot of sense to me after finally, reluctantly, going that route.

It seems we have pretty similar requirements. I think I’m going to go with a 9" KMR. I’d prefer a Geissele MK8 (I have one on another rifle) but 9.5" is too long and 7" is too short.

I hear good things about the KMR so that’s what I’ll go with. Like you said, I can always change it later and if I absolutely have to I should be able to offload that rail.

Thanks again for all the time you put into this.

JRC

No problem. The KMR9 should be a pretty safe bet for you, especially if your primary has a similar handguard on it.