Hopefully a thread like this already doesn’t exist - but if it does, it’s a bit hard to search for (for obvious reasons).
Just thought it would be interesting to hear what everyone’s first AR was. And what factors led to your decision to choose it. And what lessons you learned from it. I think this would be interesting, especially some of the SME’s or industry partners who are now in the AR-life full time.
Anywho, I’ll kick it off:
Mine was an LMT Defender 2000, their basic 16" M4 clone. I really had no idea what I was doing, I had moved home from college out of country, recently married, and just knew I really wanted a black rifle. I had grown up around shooting, but mostly historical guns or hunting rifles.
I walked in to a gun shop and let the guy at the counter steer me. I believe I paid around 1700.
I definitely got hosed on the price, but in hindsight, I’m still really happy that I ended up choosing a quality rifle. I still love LMT to this day. The rifle has since been parted out. Years later I began customizing it, starting with the standard fare (FF rail, etc…) and then eventually got in to buying many more. But I still keep the lower receiver around for builds and it’s fun to remind myself that it was my first one.
When the assault weapons ban was lifted, I was still in the military. I definitely wanted my own rifle at the time, but held off b/c I was never home. Anyhow, the first I bought on my own dime was a Colt LE6920. It’s worn many different outfits, been used and abused, but it’s been a great rifle.
Circa 2008: My first was a doublestar lower that I built with a ? LPK & (commercial) m4 stock set, bought a used CMMG 16" M4ish type upper. Didn’t stake the castle nut. Didn’t assemble the lower properly the first time. Learned something and sold it about a year later.
I started out on the opposite end of the spectrum, low quality/cost. Fortunately I’ve since wised up.
Mine was a “build” back in 2007, specifically a Del-Ton midlength kit on a Superior Arms (?) lower, with a cheapo LMT-style rear sight from UTG. Magazines were heavily used USGI (as in, gold-colored from the worn finish), and the furniture was basic A2-syle handguard, grip, and M4 stock. Carbine buffer. No optic. Never a single problem, aside from it making apparent how bad of a shot I was.
LMT 14.5" Upper
LMT Defender Lower with factory two-stage trigger and SOPMOD stock
LMT F/A BCG
Ordered the three pieces separately and avoided the FET.
Since then, the 14.5" gave way to a 16" middie barrel, the stock handguard to a Geissele MK4, and the SOPMOD to an UBR.
Colt 6920 based on the advice on this forum. Bought it probably right around the time I joined…2009ish? Since then, BCM 11.5" 5.56 and BCM 9" 300BLK. The 6920 was all dressed up but has since returned to a simple no-frills configuration. The SBR really spoiled me in terms of weight and balance so I stripped the 6920 down trying to make it as light as I could. Wouldn’t mind a mid-length at some point just for the hell of it. Not going to be this year though since I was filing Form 1s and 4s like mad early in the year.
Mine was a ban era Bushy A2 upper on a DPMS A2 lower. My father gave it to me when I commissioned. I know everyone hates Bushy and DPMS, but I have not had a problem with it in 11 years. I had the barrel threaded and threw an A2 muzzle brake on it. Although I haven’t had an issue, I will say the BCG does look pretty cheap compared any mil-spec BCG I have ever seen.
My most recent AR purchase was a BCM A4 upper I put on a lower I put together.
Bushmaster M4A3. I hadn’t been out of the Army that long but had already passed through the “everything else is better than ours” phase when I picked one up for $800 bucks. I upgraded it a lot over the years until I got to the point where the lower was the only original part.
Mine was a DPMS I bought in 2004 when Bush was up for reelection and we didn’t know if he would help reinstate the AWB after he won if he won. FWIW it shoots all Ammo including Tulammo and Wolf without a hiccup.
I now have Colts, Noveske’s and a BCM, but the DP ain’t leaving.
I wish I’d have found this site before my first AR purchase. It was actually because of all the issues that rifle had that I found M4C. Lower was a DPMS with a comercial stock, upper was a pinned 14.7 CMMG. That rifle was a mess. It was an impulse buy I bought with literally no research. Brass constantly got stuck in the chamber, failures to fire a few times a mag, and the list goes on. You’d have thought I bought a damn Fender guitar as much as that rifle loved to jam out. I sold it to fund a Colt 6920 after reading here and all has been good since.
2008 because of the political change. M&P from Gander. I had no idea of this site or Grant being a hop, skip and jump away. Planning on selling all before they confiscate, why take a loss… Better than losing them a boat accident.
Mine was a waste of hard earned money at $900. A Bushmaster xm15 m4a3. Based on childhood nostalgia hearing that BMs were good quality. Impulse bought it with no knowledge of their modern issues. $800 later, its actually something i can bear to call my own.
I bought in 2008 when I was 19. Obviously worried about the political climate, plus I just wanted a black rifle. CMMG lower with a Spikes M4 clone upper. Carry handle sights. I had been reading all the wrong sections over on TOS and then found this gold mine of knowledge. Not long after I sold it and bought a BCM 16 middy.