First 1911??

I am looking for a 1911. This will be my first so I have been searching for a great starter 1911. Most posts have SA, Kimber, and Colt’s. Anyone of these better than the others for a newbie to the 1911 world? Thanks

Preferences in the 1911 world can be very subjective but I prefer Colt 1911s. Others, I’m sure, will disagree but it would be worth your while to take a look at the Colt line. I would suggest the Combat Elite or possibly the 5" 1991 model for a more basic pistol.
:smiley:

SA MC Operator

I like SA milspec. Simple and most smiths will except it for a build gun.

V/r
Uglyguns

Get what fits your budget and what “you” will be happy with. I literally searched this and a few other sites for nearly 3 months getting as much info as I could to help me make a choice that I would be happy with. I am the same way with most firearms related purchases I make. In the end if you are happy, then all should be good to go.

Honestly with 1911’s there is alot of information. Prior to buying one, it is important to know ahead of time that you are getting into a EXPENSIVE maintinance intensive work-aholic project of a pistol.

That being said, much much mucch research is required. Look at Hilton Yams articles on 10-8 performance.com and use the search function here to read all the 1911 threads you can handle. Trust me, you will need this information in your selection, no matter what purpose you intend to use your 1911 for.

In any case, I prefer a custom gun, for numerous reasons. If you have the money (2-3K), it is THE route to go, as most 1911’s require trips to the smith (esp. if they are factory production guns) anyhow. If I were to go with a production gun, it would probably be a Springfield TRP or Operator. IMHO, they build some of the best production 1911’s (things are fitted well, proper TDP is followed, and should you have a problem they have unparalleled customer service!)

I have looked at some custom 1911s from Wilson and Les Baer and most are $1500-$2000 more than say a SA MC Operator that some people have posted as a good starter 1911. Do the custom 1911s warrant twice as much $$?

i suppose it would help to give some idea of what you intend to turn the pistol into

i myself would want a ww2 style one for the classic look

what is nice about a custom 1911 is you can fix what many believe to be errors in the original design, more attention to the proper tune and fit of the gun, quality of parts, and the means of production on said quality parts is often better. For example, the Wilson extractor on some of their custom models is rounded and polished while special attention is given to make NO alterations to the hook angle and are fitted properly to the gun individually as opposed to by a machine ( which is actually one of the things people send 1911’s to a smith for, re-tensioning of the extractor and its fit the firearm as it is key to 1911 reliability and universally important)
One other example is controlling how parts are placed on the frame. For example, the plunger tube on a Caspian frame is part of the cast, so that it is not for instance staked on. This helps becuase the plunger tube may become loose if staked on a 1911 after hard use, and when it becomes loose it is prone to “slipping” backwards and locking your gun on safe (a mild example)

To awnser that question truthfully, if you plan on running 1911’s up to or past 50,000 rounds in practice or match, a custom gun is the way to go, for the above states and so many other small details that over time and round count gradually contribute in increasing amounts over time. So really, it depends on how serious a user you are and what you plan on doing with it. Much similar to the pattern of how if you are a plinker…buy a Del-Ton or a DPMS, but if your or others lives are on the line, or you just want QUALITY kit that will live to be enjoyed by generations, you go to the Noveske or Wilson Combat et. al.

For a good basic 1911 I would recommend the Springfield Loaded or Desert Eagle 1911. Both are reasonably priced and should be shot quite a bit before deciding to carry.

If you have the cash then look for a Springfield TRP or Les Baer TRS (Thunder Ranch Special) in lightly used or new condition.

Colt or Springfield

It’s all about budget. If money is no object, you can go with a custom shop (Wilson, Nighthawk, etc.). However, Springfield puts out a good 1911 at a reasonable price.

Not exactly.

OP,
Much depends on what you want the 1911 for, what do you hope to gain by going to a 1911.

If you want a “basic” GI style gun, for playin around at the range, the SA “GI”, mil-spec or a Colt 1991 are good choices.

if you want a gun for serious self defense or duty use, that’s a whole other ball of wax, and you would be well advised to look over at 10-8 performance and 10-8 forums. Also plan on a 1911 operators course from LAV

The Colt Rail gun and SA MC operator are good starting points, as they have a rail, and I’m a huge believer in a weapon mounted light.
You could also surf the forums and gunbroker, and local shops for a good clean used gun, from one of the big makers, such as Wilson, SA Proshop, Baer, etc.

Bob

The 1911 will be used in multiple situations. First will be to a 1911 course the main reason for the purchase then HD. I have been to a few carbine/handgun training courses and a good handful of people including the instructors (Ken Hackathorn, LAV, etc.) mainly carry 1911s. That is why the intrigue. I don’t mind paying $2800 for a Wilson CQB but want to know that it is worth the extra $1500 over a SA MC Operator. Should I just buy a factory gun and later upgrade where and when I see that needs improvement. I know you can customize the 1911 to the teeth but will all those custom parts make a difference as a fighting pistol. I know a good barrel, bushing, trigger, fit and finish are important things. But for me I feel reliability is paramount over a custom part that is better looking than that of a factory gun but less reliable. Also having a rail for a weapon light is a option that I do like in a 1911.

I have noticed the differences, but then that is coming from me and my experience in the platform. In your case, you could go either way and have it be beneficial. How much of a differnce is noticed is usually dependant upon shooter experience and personal shooting preferance IMHO. But Im not the one buying the gun. For your needs, the MC Operator would probably be a great starting gun of decent quality to take to classes and use for HD.

Whatever route you choose to go, take reputable good classes from the likes of Hack and LAV, keep up on the maintinance (I recommend logs) and enjoy the firearm.

Automatic COLT Pistol

welcome to the centenial

Have you asked Ken and LAV why they are shooting 1911’s? What about the other shooters?
Many people have no idea why they are shooting a 1911, it usually amounts to, its what the cool guys shoot. or at least its what they think the cool guys shoot.
There is no magic to them, they have nice, easily tuned triggers, that make them very easy to shoot well. LAV has called them a crutch for poor marksmanship. Many of them come with tighter clearances and match barrels, which also make them shoot very well. That comes at a price though.

LAV, at least, does not generally recommend them.

For what you want, a Colt rail gun or MC operator, would be good choices. You get a modern style 1911, that starts to maximize the guns potential. They give you some room to mod the gun as you like to really maximize the guns potential. Or, if you decide you don’t like the gun, they will retain a good portion of their value.

FWIW, LAV stated he thought buying a complete gun and is proven reliable, and then tuning it, was better then a ground up build. He also said Colts were excellent platforms to build on.

HTH,
Bob

Good questions !

I shoot (and carry) 1911s because I like how they look, I carried one in Vietnam, I am more than reasonably accurate with them, I trust my ability to use them, I understand how they function and I can maintain and do minor repair on them. The preceding reasons are not in any particular order. I don’t care (beyond curiosity) what anyone else shoots or carries as, most likely, they will not be with me when I have to defend myself. One can carry what one can shoot properly and defend themselves with. Or not. I am easy to get along with when it’s not my business. As always, YMMV.
Also, polymer framed pistols have no soul; the 1911 does. :smiley:

Is colt worth the extra 200?

Depends on the models you are comparing and the money you have to spend. :cool: