Quick question on this. I checked page 251 and to me it seems that the measurement should be of the widest part of the expanded bullet only. Am I right or should I be measuring the widest and narrowest part. Widest being petal to petal and narrowest being inner part (between the petals) to inner part?
- Recover bullets from water-filled container. Using calipers, measure average expanded diameter of each bullet using instructions on page 251 (JHP Bullet Expansion) of MacPherson’s book.
If the bullet has no petals (like a lead hollowpoint), you just take 2-4 measurements across the expanded portion of the bullet and average them. If there are petals, you do still want the average expanded diameter, so you measure 2-4 times again, but make half of the measurements at the outside edge of the petals, and the other half between the petals where the diameter is the smallest. The reasoning is simple: the ‘gaps’ between the petals are not experiencing the drag that the petals are, so penetration would be greater than a bullet without the ‘spaces’ between the petals. This is one of two problems associated with doing water testing rather than gelatin testing. The other issue is that water will open up a bullet a little more (and a little easier) than gelatin or tissue will since it is more ‘fluid’, so expansion will be a little bit more when using water as a test medium.
‘PM’ me if you need more info.
-Ron Jones.
Thanks for the info. I just got Duncan’s book and have been reading through it. Hoping to get to the range soon to do some testing.
Can’t believe I found the book new on Amazon especially for the price. 
When I was in the IWBA, I read Duncan’s book (also IWBA) and then designed my own water-testing tank. I shot vertically into the tank and then measured the expanded bullet diameters, the expanded bullet weights and their chronographed speeds. This data was then used to estimate the penetration depths using the calculations in Duncan’s book. The calculations are more accurate than shooting horizontally through cartons, because the carton thickness (from front to back) is the smallest increment of measurment you can use with certainty when using the carton method (perfected by Gus Coty, also IWBA). To figure the estimated penetration depths closer than this requires a cetain level of ‘guesswork’ on how far the bullet passed inside the last carton by the dent or tear in its far side. I had the fortunate experience of having Duncan assist me in my work by inputing my data into his computer model, which gave me even more accurate penetration estimates than I got myself using his book. The water testing method with cartons is a quicker method than my tank, but my tank is more accurate, especially if I send my data to Duncan to input into his computer model. I will be eternally grateful for the help Duncan unselfishly gave me when I was trying to learn.
I wish that the computer program was available for sale or as freeware. I would love to be able to buy or view on line the IWBA articles also. I appreciate the help. I enjoy being able to get advice from real experts.
A lot of folks would like that, unfortunately I don’t see it happening anytime soon.
Take care.