Lets look at this logically and mathematically. Like Steyr said. We are where we are. Most everyone agrees they only understand force. Doing nothing and trying to “talk” is a sign of weakness to them.
So, what we are doing now will solve nothing and things will slowly just escalate as the powers that be see us as weak sauce if we continue our course. What does that equal? Exactly what we are trying to avoid, by staying on the course we are. In other words, in the end, we are accomplishing nothing by remaining calm and collected and partially neutral.
I’s like the Dad who has been sitting on the sidelines for awhile letting his snot nosed kids get away with things for too long and then finally losing his sh*t.
You get the evidence of Iran’s involvement, show the world the evidence, and send them back 1000 years for doing so. You then look at the rest of them and say who the **** else wants some of this, because we are tired of this bullsh*t. This is how it’s going to be, and you will all play by the rules that is set. If not, and you do not want to play by the rules…then ok…no rules…let’s play.
All we would be doing is going where we are already going, but doing so on our terms. It will never happen with this admin though.
So we are now doing anti aircraft duty for Israel. We already took a side with the Yemen/Saudi conflict, but by taking out missiles not aimed at the US ships, seems we have made it clear the US is now a target of opportunity. Obviously if the target had been the US ship, they must defend themselves. Taking up anti air defense for Israel seems a very different animal to me.
Was sending the missiles a test to see where the US stood which then puts us on the targeting list?
The US has been in the air defense biz in Israel for years. Not saying it’s right or wrong, just that it is not new.
Obviously we don’t have the imaging the ship’s CIC had, but I would find it difficult to believe the ship fired to intercept missiles the captain did not deem a threat. Especially in light of a service that likes to fire its ships’ captains every other hour.
Selling/supplying gear vs parking ships off the coast and intercepting missiles for them?
Everything I am seeing so far indicates the ship was not the target, but of course that may not have been clear at the time. The Q is then, when did the ship know they were not the target when they decided to take out those missiles?
I believe we manned Patriot batteries for them before. I am sure of duration or if it was an on again/off again thing.
I agree with wondering about when the ship knew it was not a target vs taking action against the missiles. I am also interested in the real-time decision-making. What led the captain to do that, when it’s not been done before? In other words, what was new? Different?
That’s the big Q which has big and wide ranging implications as to our involvement now. Intentional or not, I think the message sent is we are officially an active combatant in the conflict.
I think Iran, pro-Assad Syria, Hezbollah are actively trying to draw us in.
Neighbors are nervous: Egypt has not only said they will not accept refugees, they have also said that everything over the past couple weeks has been Hamas’/Palestinians’ fault.
Some want a regional conflict to kick off and it seems like for the most part, it may further isolate Iran from the others who may pretend to support the Palestinians (because it’s a thorn in the side of the Israeli’s no because they actually give a damn about the Palestinians) don’t want any real part of a war with Israel and by extension, the US and partners. Whether we should stick ourselves into that is a different topic, but here we are.
Unfortunately, Hamas caring even less about the Palestinians than anyone else, holds a strong hand as we play by rules they don’t follow.
Finally, I feel like under the layers the Russians have a hand in this.
When you send US warships towards any conflict, the intent is to send a message. It would be foolish to not set the terms of our presence at the first opportunity, not to mention the risk that inaction would pose to our sailors and Marines. These rockets my not have been targeted at our warship but continue ignoring armed aerial threats and eventually they will be. It’s the same with small boats. You set your exclusion zones and the first one to "wander’ past your limits, gets ordinance across their bow as a last warning. Message read loud and clear. It doesn’t put our warships on the targeting list, it takes them off.
Besides, shooting down unmanned rockets isn’t really a big deal. Last I checked, Hamas doesn’t have an air force. At least I don’t consider paragliders to be an “air force”. But hey, if they want to send one out over the med to give our Navy a welcome call, I’m sure we can arrange a warm reception!
We deployed there, that puts us in the game. Right or wrong, like it or not. We have our people in harms way.
And it was absolutely a test of resolve and response.
Anyone who remembers the endless years of Saddam ****ing with us, making us ramp up to the point of deploying and then saying “changed my mind” should recognize this BS.
I recall reading many years ago that when some of the Beirut hostages (the Terry Anderson crowd) were finally released from captivity the scum hostage takers said to them “New Jersey bad! No good!”. They were like WTF do they have against New Jersey? Hell they weren’t even from there.
Turns out the muzzies were referring to the USS New Jersey, which had indeed parked off the coast and shelled their asses while being beyond the reach of whatever weapons they had at the time.
In response to the USMC barracks bombing (40 years ago this coming Monday BTW) the New Jersey fired on targets in the Bekaa Valley which killed a senior Syrian general in his bunker. Obviously too little too late, but no tears were shed.
Yes, Sir, they are impressive in action. I know they are obsolete tech, but it’s just too bad. They represent an amazing time in history. I think we should keep one in service, for just such occasions. Hell, we waste billions on all kinds of nonsense.
Now it’s reported that USS Craney shot down 15 drones and 4 cruise missiles in a 9 hour period.
If they keep this up each day, she will run out of anti-aircraft missiles in a week.
If the Navy and Pentagon is that concerned, she will stay on station and they will bring everything to her, along with a couple of other ships.
As for battleships, I love them. I took my family to the USS North Carolina last week for I think the fourth time. I must have gone a dozen times when I was a kid. But a single submarine carries far more effective and targeted firepower now than did a battleship. But I do love those old battle wagons.
Where the hell have you been the last few decades? We’re already on everyone’s targeting lists. Even our Arab “allies” tolerate us because we’re occasionally a useful tool, but will support and host groups that actively attack us. This changes nothing.