Hi what is the Opinion on CMMG uppers?
I am looking for a New Upper and have narrowed it down between LMT and CMMG.
I am looking at a 14.5" with a Phanton 5C2 FH attached.
Thanks
Dave
Hi what is the Opinion on CMMG uppers?
I am looking for a New Upper and have narrowed it down between LMT and CMMG.
I am looking at a 14.5" with a Phanton 5C2 FH attached.
Thanks
Dave
I’ve got a 16" lightweight middy.
i’ve only put about 400 rounds through it, but it’s been flawless so far. they’re pretty quick compared to a lot of builders (i got mine in under a month… and this was during the holiday season)
for the cash i think they’re tough to beat. Hell for any price.
the MP test all their barrels and bolts. 4150 steel barrels.
they offer 1 in 7 twist on basically everything.
very nice fit and finish.
there’s some story floating around here or TOS that somebody got an upper with really soft front sight taper pins. seems to be a fluke most likely.
if i get another upper it’ll probably be a noveske though.
$$$
I’ve had a few issues with CMMG uppers, some just nuisances, some serious functional issues. And yes, they do have extremely soft FSB taper pins, which is a pain in butt as I’ve experienced it myself.
I have not had an LMT assembled upper, but I’d buy that over CMMG without a doubt.
Specifically, what would those be? Particularly the “serious functional issues”?
I have a CMMG 14.5 w/a Phantom and I have had no problems with it.
I’m in the same boat too. I’m looking for a good value 11.5" upper, and BCM could be a long wait. LMT doesn’t make an 11.5".
I’m trying to resist gambling on CMMG. I think this thread is helping me resist the temptation. ![]()
Mine has been 100%

I just ordered a CMMG from Pete at evilblackrifles.com He sounds very well informed and can likely answer your questions…in addition to offering a significant discount from MSRP.
That said, if money’s not an issue, and if LMT offers the model you want, I don’t see why you should hesitate getting one.
Barrel nut clocked wrong resulting in gas tube being angled inside the upper receiver. I’ve also seen a barrel nut that was barely even torqued, and some of their gas key staking isn’t very good. Another issue was the roll pin halfway out of the charging handle. While these things can easily be fixed, in some cases you’ll need special tools to do so. If you fix the problems that you sometimes get with their assembled uppers, then you’re probably fine. I just don’t trust them to be ready to go out of the box.
BTW, for anybody that tries to remove their taper pins: They’ll mushroom on the end you hit to remove them, essentially locking them in place. Center punch the pin, then drill into it enough to get below the surface of the FSB (use a drill bit a little smaller than the pin OD). Then use a smaller punch in the hole so the impact force doesn’t mushroom the pin above the outer surface of the FSB and prevent removal. You can even reuse the pin in a pinch if you were careful with the drilling.
LMT.
C4
A friend has CMMG 16" upper that shoots well and has no problems. He hasn’t tried to remove the FSB, so don’t know about the taper pins.
Simple yet to the point
I have also read about soft taper pins. DPMS also uses soft pins. I tried to take some out last spring. They just mushroomed. I dont know why they would use such soft pins.
Many believe that CMMG = DPMS.
C4
That is an interesting theory, especially considering that their “bargain bin” rifles are more often than not DPMS, as relayed to my from a friend in MO who runs into them at GunShows.
Hmmmmm
At least they are selling them at value.
Their “bargin bin” rifles do not use their regular uppers, at least according to them, and are built on lowers made by DPMS, Double Star and occasionally their own.
I have an acquaintence who is former MIL armorer now a LEO in MO near them, and he swears by their uppers. I got one for a friend and its GTG, but I haven’t tried to remove the FSB, so I don’t know about that part. Wouldn’t think they are in the same teir as Colt, LMT, or Noveske, but I wouldn’t call them crap either.
I have a CMMG lower and it’s fine.
Go with the LMT. I worked for CMMG from the time when they did nothing but DPMS. up to last Feb 07 5 years and things are not what they seem the reason I left . Keep in mind it is the one at the bench . Most all use the same parts from diff manufacture’s and just put the upper together. Some claim to do things they don’t
The pins in my CMMG barrel were so soft I cold not get them back in and getting them out was a pain. I bought Colt pins from Brownells and everything went back together perfectly.
CMMG makes a decent barrel but they cut corners on the small stuff like barrel extensions and taper pins.
Well there you have it!
C4
Wow, thanks Remember911. Good info to know.