Chicago Law Banning Handguns in City Upheld by Court

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=awIn1M4tWxi8&refer=worldwide

By Andrew M. Harris

June 2 (Bloomberg) – A Chicago ordinance banning handguns and automatic weapons within city limits was upheld by a U.S. Court of Appeals panel, which rejected a challenge by the National Rifle Association.

The unanimous three-judge panel ruled today that a U.S. Supreme Court decision last year, which recognized an individual right to bear arms under the U.S. Constitution’s Second Amendment, didn’t apply to states and municipalities.

“The Supreme Court has rebuffed requests to apply the second amendment to the states,” U.S. Circuit Judge Frank Easterbrook wrote, upholding lower court decisions last year to throw out suits against Chicago and its suburb of Oak Park, Illinois.

The Fairfax, Virginia-based NRA sued the municipalities in June 2008, one day after the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in District of Columbia v. Heller struck down a hand-gun ban in the U.S. capital district encompassing Washington.

“We clearly disagree with the court’s conclusion,” NRA attorney William N. Howard, a partner in Chicago’s Freeborn & Peters LLP, said in a telephone interview. “The next step will be an appeal to the Supreme Court.”

“We recognize that this may not be the end of this litigation,” Jenny Hoyle, a spokeswoman for the city of Chicago’s law department said, acknowledging the likelihood the NRA would seek further review. “We’re certainly prepared for that if this happens. We’re prepared to aggressively defend our ordinance.”

Second Amendment

Adopted in 1791 as part of the Bill of Rights, the Second Amendment reads in its entirety: “A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.”

In Heller, the high court struck down Washington’s 32-year- old gun law, which barred most residents of the city from owning handguns and required that all legal firearms be kept unloaded and either disassembled or under trigger lock. Six residents had challenged the law, saying they wanted firearms available in their homes for self-defense.

“Heller dealt with a law enacted under the authority of the national government,” Easterbrook wrote, “while Chicago and Oak Park are subordinate bodies of a state.”

Chicago’s law took effect in 1982, Hoyle said. While it allows ownership of long guns such as rifles, they must be registered annually with the city’s police department. Concealed weapons, semi-automatic and automatic weapons are not permitted.

Some exemptions apply to members of the military and law enforcement agencies.

Following Precedent

Chicago U.S. District Judge Milton Shadur on Dec. 4 rejected the NRA’s request that he apply the Heller ruling to the Chicago and Oak Park laws, stating he was bound to follow a 1982 appeals court ruling upholding a ban by the Illinois village of Morton Grove.

That decision came from the U.S. Court of Appeals in Chicago, the same body that issued today’s opinion. The 15 judges of the Seventh Circuit hear appeals from the federal courts of Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin.

Easterbrook, joined by Circuit Court Judges Richard Posner and William Bauer, said they, too, were bound to follow the precedent of a higher court, the U.S. Supreme Court, in its ruling on the Second Amendment not applying to states.

An appellate court departure from high court precedent “undermines the uniformity of national law,” Easterbrook wrote.

The judges rendered their ruling one week after hearing arguments.

Applicable Law

A San Francisco-based federal appeals court, with jurisdiction over cases from California, Oregon, Washington and six other Western U.S. states, in April ruled the Second Amendment can be read as applicable to states and counties.

Still, the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision in Nordyke v. King allowed to stand an Alameda County, California regulation that outlaws gun possession on county property.

Howard, the NRA’s lawyer, cited the Nordyke ruling as one of the reasons for his client’s challenge to the Chicago court outcome.

“This thing is headed for the Supreme Court,” University of Chicago Constitutional Law Professor Richard Epstein said in a phone interview.

“This is a question where you cannot run a split administration and there’s no way the circuits can resolve this amongst themselves,” he said.

The 7th Circuit case is National Rifle Association of America v. City of Chicago, 08-4241, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit (Chicago). The 9th Circuit case is Nordyke v. King, 07-15763, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (San Francisco).

To contact the reporter on this story: Andrew M. Harris at the federal court in Chicago at aharris16@bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: June 2, 2009 17:16 EDT

I was reading about this earlier today…it’s scary. Law abiding citizens cannot protect themselves against those who don’t follow the laws regardless. The law binds only those who follow it…it is no problem for those who will break the law anyway. (Consequences of breaking the law occur only after criminals are caught…it doesn’t stop what crimes are committed before the criminals are caught)

Well, no real surprise there. :rolleyes:

Cases like this are why President Obama is pushing so hard for Soto Mayor. She has ruled in the past that State laws supersede Federal, even if it goes against the US Constitution. She also stated Appeals courts set policy.

If you’re not an NRA member, join now and support the fight before it’s too late.

Wouldn’t it be a dream world where Sotomayer, in her experiences as a Latina woman in a bad neighborhood, agreed with the right to self defense? Sorry, still a bit sleepy.

Is this one of those decisions that didn’t go our way, but actually helps since they didn’t do some half measure or hold it up forever? Off to SCOTUS is goes. I can’t remember the last time that I rooted for the 9th circuit decision to prevail.

Hello,

Here’s a good artical that explaines how this Bull-Shit could litterally effect Thousands of Anti-Gun towns across America (If The People Allow It).

Artical Here: http://turnerradionetwork.blogspot.com/

pretty strong article…can’t agree with what is said in it…threats on the lives of judges, their families???

Don’t get me wrong- I do not agree that law-abiding citizens should not be able to have weapons for their protection…I am one of those citizens who firmly believes in the right to keep and bear arms…

I think it is a surprise. That is a pretty conservative court and Posner will go down in history as one of the most brilliant legal minds to sit on the bench.

The current nominee seems like a one-for-trade , at least in the 2nd Amendment area.

Best wishes for good health and long life for the 5 Heller case majority Justices :
Tony Scalia , Clarence Thomas , John Roberts , Anthony Kennedy , and Sam Alito.

They got phase one done. Hope they can stay around long enough to finish phase two.

I’m sure I’m being naive here but my argument is that:

  1. The Constitution guarantees that my 2nd Amendment rights are individual in nature.

  2. The Constitution (10th Amendment) says that, “The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people”. The 10th Amendment guarantees that federally controlled laws ie, the 2nd Amendment comes under federal regulation, not state.

  3. With that said, the NRA should be able to argue successfully that the 10th guarantees the 2nd…Federally, not by States rights!!! I believe that this is going to be the way that the arguments will proceed.

I’m grossly over simplifying things, but out Constitution is binding to all…including the states that live under it’s protection.

Well we all know how well gun control in Chicago works…

Ask Officer Alex Valadez…oh right you can’t.

http://www.suntimes.com/news/24-7/1603777,charges-officer-valadez-shooting-060209.article

Dumb motherf*($ers.

Following this flawed logic, the first ammendment would not apply to municipalities and states.

This showcases what an uphill fight we have ahead of us in the courts. The idea of the courts taking the 2nd amendment rights of law abiding citizens as seriously as it does the 4th amendment rights of terrorists and child molesters is enough to make many jurists queasy.

The positive side of this, however, is that it basically forces the USSC to rule on incorporation of Heller…which will be interesting. It will be quite funny to watch the liberal activists on the USSC suddenly become ardent originalist federalists on the issue of guns.

Some of the admendments are incorporated against the States and some are not. The 2nd is not. That means the court ruled correctly. However, it is within the SCOTUS power, I believe, to take the case and incorporate the right.

Heller doesn’t address issues on incorporation.

M_P

I think Posner was critical of Heller also.

Obviously Chicago’s gun ban has worked thus far and they can attest to it with this recent string of homicides http://www.dailyherald.com/story/?id=297588&

Chicago has 7 shooting deaths in 24 hours

Chicago had seven shooting deaths in 24 hours this weekend, and police say they have no suspects in custody.

All seven victims were men in their 20s or 30s, and all were shot to death.

The shootings occurred between 6:15 a.m. Saturday and just before 6 a.m. Sunday.

One victim, 30-year-old Demond Stansbury, was shot along with two of his cousins, who survived and are in fair condition.

The shootings spanned the city, happening on the North, South and West sides.

Chicago Police spokesman Roderick Drew says investigations into the shootings are ongoing.

On Saturday, police Superintendent Jody Weis spoke at an anti-violence march and rally on the West side.

Another article http://www.dailyherald.com/story/?id=297933&src=143

Court upholds Chicago handgun ban

A Chicago ordinance banning handguns and automatic weapons within city limits was upheld by a U.S. Court of Appeals panel, which rejected a challenge by the National Rifle Association.

The unanimous three-judge panel ruled today that a U.S. Supreme Court decision last year, which recognized an individual right to bear arms under the U.S. Constitution’s Second Amendment, didn’t apply to states and municipalities.

“The Supreme Court has rebuffed requests to apply the second amendment to the states,” U.S. Circuit Judge Frank Easterbrook wrote, upholding lower court decisions last year to throw out suits against Chicago and its suburb of Oak Park, Illinois.

The Fairfax, Virginia-based NRA sued the municipalities in June 2008, one day after the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in District of Columbia v. Heller struck down a hand-gun ban in the U.S. capital district encompassing Washington.

“We recognize that this may not be the end of this litigation,” Jenny Hoyle, a spokeswoman for the city of Chicago’s law department, said in a telephone interview, acknowledging that the NRA was likely to seek Supreme Court review. “We’re certainly prepared for that if this happens. We’re prepared to aggressively defend our ordinance.”

NRA attorney William N. Howard, a partner in Chicago’s Freeborn & Peters LLP, declined to comment immediately on the court’s decision.

Second Amendment

Adopted in 1791 as part of the Bill of Rights, the Second Amendment reads in its entirety: “A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed.”

In Heller, the high court struck down Washington’s 32-year- old gun law, which barred most residents of the city from owning handguns and required that all legal firearms be kept unloaded and either disassembled or under trigger lock. Six residents had challenged the law, saying they wanted firearms available in their homes for self-defense.

“Heller dealt with a law enacted under the authority of the national government,” Easterbrook wrote, “while Chicago and Oak Park are subordinate bodies of a state.”

Chicago’s law took effect in 1982, Hoyle said. While it allows ownership of long guns such as rifles, they must be registered annually with the city’s police department. Concealed weapons, semi-automatic and automatic weapons are not permitted.

Some exemptions apply to members of the military and law enforcement agencies.

Following Precedent

Chicago U.S. District Judge Milton Shadur on Dec. 4 rejected the NRA’s request that he apply the Heller ruling to the Chicago and Oak Park laws, stating he was bound to follow a 1982 appeals court ruling upholding a ban by the Illinois village of Morton Grove.

That decision came from the U.S. Court of Appeals in Chicago, the same body that issued today’s opinion. The 15 judges of the Seventh Circuit hear appeals from the federal courts of Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin.

Easterbrook, joined by Circuit Court Judges Richard Posner and William Bauer, said they too were bound to follow the precedent of a higher court, the U.S. Supreme Court, in its ruling on the Second Amendment not applying to states.

An appellate court departure from high court precedent “undermines the uniformity of national law,” Easterbrook wrote.

The judges rendered their ruling one week after hearing arguments.

The case is National Rifle Association of America v. City of Chicago, 08-4241, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit (Chicago).

Greg, he was, but if I recall correctly, not necessarily at the decision itself, but the way in which the Court arrived at the decision (i.e. the method of interpretation Scalia states was applied). The article that he wrote about it was pretty good, even if I disagree with it. For a student of the law, his opinions rank up there with some of the best to wear the robe.

I highly dislike this city, especially the Mayor.

Can we get a demographic analysis on these offenders? Are we sure these are the type that should dictate public policy?