carbine or midlength gas

i see everybody running midlengths these days but what are the real benefits of it over the carbine? is one more reliable than the other or more picky about cheap ammo? i see people say the midlengths are smoother shooting but other than that what is the real advantage over a carbine gas system?
thanks in advance

There are a whole bunch of threads about exactly this topic. Always try the Google custom search field in the upper right of the forum pages.

https://www.google.com/search?sclient=tablet-gws&num=20&newwindow=1&client=safari&hl=en&biw=768&bih=928&q=carbine+vs+mid+length+site%3Awww.m4carbine.net&oq=carbine+vs+mid+length+site%3Awww.m4carbine.net

You can find a lot of info here on that subject. Search for “carbine vs. mid length gas”

yeah i shouldve searched before i posted. i searched it right after i posted and theres a crap ton of info in there

I think the only excuse to have a 16" carbine is if your only rifle is a colt.

This ^

If you aren’t looking to build a pistol AR or SBR, go with the Mid-length.

According to some, it’s “softer shooting” and less wear and tear on the parts.

Regardless if it’s less wear and tear on parts, you should still have a strict preventative maintenance regimen, and not rely on your gas system to be some magic on preventing things from breaking.