I’ve read several threads here and other places where people claim having witnessed piston guns “failing” or “self destructing” but they usually make no other description of the failure. I’d like to see actual descriptions of parts or components that fail or break in the various piston designs. So the question is, have you seen or experience and actual parts breakage on a piston model AR? What part was it that broke? Any photos of the breakage would be fantastic.
Things like carrier tilt are not germane here unless they actually broke something as that issue seems to be fairly well remedied.
I’m wondering if descriptions of piston guns failing are due to other poor components (out of spec barrels, etc) making the gun fail or are actual breakage of parts?
Good topic, I’d be interested as well. Other than some abnormal wearing of receiver extensions due to tilt, I haven’t seen any parts breakage reports either. As a piston owner (LMT) I’ve definitely paid lots of attention to the piston discussions and reports on the various boards.
Mine was attributed to the magazine, not the gun. Barrett 6.8 mags have a lip at the rear of the follower that my bolt catch had gotten underneath preventing me from stripping the magazine from the weapon, it happened enough I ordered a few C Products magazines and havent had an issue since.
Hopefully a few who repeatedly poo-poo the piston guns will chime in at some point.
I don’t own one so Im certainly not a koolaid drinker but find the idea a good one for guns with suppressors, I have very mediocre results with gas guns using a can. Reliability takes a nose dive in my experience.
My 416 had few issues but it did have a few. First issue was when a leg of my firing pin retaining cotter pin broke off and locked my bolt halfway back. Second i had a bolt prong sheer off on the non extractor side. I continued to shoot the gun for at least a couple of thousand rounds to see how it would do and it even continued to work after the second prong sheered off…third prong sheered off and gun became a bolt action. Justmy limited experience with the 416. Would still trust ,y life to it if parts weren’t so hard to get…ultimately i decided that a well maintained di m4with plenty of replacement parts was a better fit for me than a high speed gun that i couldn’t maintain properly in regards to parts.
I put an Osprey kit on one of my ARs , it’s timed right with my barrel and it has been perfect. No tilt (comes with BC), only thing I notice is a weee more wear on the carrier key.
Some piston/ Bolt combo kits and complete rifles work better than others and wear less.
I’m no expert, so wait to have this confirmed, however I’m fairly certain that a piston’s place is on a 10.5" gun that simply wont stop short cycling, not necessarily a suppressed one. Here’s a quote from an interview with John Noveske published on Defense Review:
“I only run the guns with suppressors for testing when I did my comparison, and with suppressors, direct-impingement and piston-operated were both very dirty, ’cause the blowback comes to the chamber, not the gas tube.” - John Noveske
I believe westcoastfrog is referring to the bolt lugs. I have heard of but never experienced any issues with bolt lugs on piston guns. I own an upper with a carbine-length Adams Arms system. What I’ve heard about bolt lugs shearing off has something to do with increased unlocking speeds and increased pressure per lug because of that. Whether or not there even is substantially increased pressure on the lugs and whether or not this pressure, if extant, would cause failure remains to be substantially evidenced as far as I know.
Edit: Oh yeah, and if the carrier’s tilting… Cant be too good for the lugs, either…
What this thread may boil down to is that, although some piston-equipped ARs may function just fine… There’s still no reason to use them over DI ARs.
I had a CMMG piston upper over a Rock River lower. One day at the range the weapon stopped feeding rounds. Basically it turned into a single shot AR. When I got home and disassembled the upper I found that the piston rod return spring had jumped over it’s retainer therefore failing to push the piston back into it’s bore for the next shot. It was at that point that I decided piston ARs were not for me. Didn’t think to take photos. Sorry bout that, they would have been interesting to look at now.
Thanks for posting this IG. What a shit storm I started at TOS when I mentioned this very point. It stands to reason that if the BCG is tilting at the rear it has to also be putting pressure at the bolt lugs and it’s tail.
Would the floating bolt “head” due to tolerances with the bolt ring OD, carrier ID and cam pin groove mitigate any effect of limited carrier tilt (use of anti tilt buffer) on the bolt lugs?
Bolt lugs also crack on gas guns, internal piston guns, direct impingement guns, whatever you want to call them.
But, the recoil impulse on a piston gun is certainly different and might be more severe due to the lack of a forward impulse from the gas operation.
Seriously? Think about this. If the rear of the carrier is tilting, that means that the front of the carrier (where the bolt is) is also tliting upwards which is going to put stress on the bolt as the carrier travels rearward and the bolt unlocks.
You’re right about DI guns bolts breaking. Which is why you should be even more concerned.