Build a BCG Like an Idiot? Surprisingly Useful Article from TFB

Surprised I saw this especially considering the source.

http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/12/07/build-ar-bcg-like-idiot-rock-river-arms/

Glad to see that good information is starting to become more widely spread about how shit certain companies procedures are for building new rifles. Maybe it will make a change but it doesn’t seem like this comment will have too strong an impact on the industry, considering the comments section for the article.

Well, the writer did attend William Larson’s class, which is a good thing.

Very true hopefully more people who want to build ARs both professionally and for themselves seek training by qualified individuals instead of the first WikiHow article they can get on Google. Or some random gunshop commando who puts a gas block at a mid length position when the barrel has the gas port at 7". That was a surprising thread.

The derp has already begun to leak…

When will ya’ll offer armorers courses in the VA/NC/TN area?

Big, bad, Billy Larson. Love that guy… taught me a lot. Though he’s softened up a bit over the years. He’s got a kindler, gentler, machine gun hand.

He was a badass when we dorm’d together in college.

:sarcastic:

Sweet Fukk!

I remember when those pictures were leaked. The video can still found online too. NSFW, though.

But but but my rra is just as good as…

What is the proper to install an extractor spring?

Just noticed that they changed the original title. I guess their comment section didn’t like the old one. Can’t wait to have an Iraqgunz course near me either. One of these years right? :smiley:

I actually do believe in staggering gas rings. Not for function but for assembly, as I’ve seen the end of one ring jammed into the gap of another.

Apparently not the way the RRA dude did it.
I would prefer not to have to build a BCG, I prefer to buy quality BCGs and have spares.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The point isn’t to build anything. All the stuff he did are also common repairs that someone may need to make. I have had to replace numerous carrier keys over the years due to blown primers, Q-tips stuck inside, crappy stakings, sheared screws, etc…

That’s a good way to look at it - potential repairs.
I could probably do some, maybe most of the steps in the video, I’ve done some basic repair/replacements like replacing gas rings, the extractor spring and o-ring that came in a SOPMOD kit that I keep in my spares.
I think I’d rather get some training and KNOW that I know what I’m doing rather than do the whole “Hope for the best, but plan for the mess”. That may not be the saying but it sure sounds applicable.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Robert -

I noticed several times he mentioned something along the lines of ‘to do this at home’ which, along with a couple of other items made me believe the clip was not necessary ‘build a bolt carrier group the factory way’ but rather ‘build a bolt carrier group the minimalist way.’ I’m not sure that it was a good idea for a company to produce such a clip.

Since the article commented on the torque - he said it should be done with a torque wrench and then added how to do it with the allen wrenches. 55-60 inch pounds is the norm, 70 inch pounds isn’t going to harm anything in my experience. We are talking less than one foot pound of torque difference here, not cheater bar tightness.

People often refer to the Armalite Tech Bulletin #47, here that bulletin:

Technical Note 47: Increased Carrier Key Torque

[i]For years, veteran ArmaLite® assemblers have tightened carrier keys using a simple Allen wrench. This process has been successful.

As we added employees we decided to use calibrated torque wrenches to assure that we secure the key screws to the proper level. The government standard for carrier key torque is 35 to 40 inch pounds, and we secured torque wrenches set to that value. We then noticed an INCREASE in loose carrier keys. It turns out that we had tightened carrier key screws better without the wrench than with it.

The problem is that the government torque values shown in maintenance manuals are too low.

We have examined the engineering data related to the screw itself, and have increased torque to 55 inch pounds to improve carrier key tightness. We recommend that all AR owners make sure that their carrier key screws are secured to this level, especially if their rifles sometimes shows signs of weak or slow cycling.

If your AR “short strokes,” clean the underside of the carrier key and tighten both screws to 55 to 60 inch pounds. Tighten the front screw first. If your rifle isn’t short stroking, just make sure that the screws are tight and restake if needed.

MARK A. WESTROM
President [/i]

Additionally, the ejector spring. ‘Jake’ mentioned it should snap in. He then said if it didn’t you could use pliers, cautioning that you could harm the spring if you used too much force.

The article mentioned the stakes weren’t good enough, IDK how they could know, IIRC the video never showed the finished stakes (although I could be wrong).

It is nice to have the content of the Brownell’s AR tool catalog on your bench, most of us can’t afford that.

I’ll end by repeating something I said earlier _ RRA should have known they would get creamed by every guy on the internet who has read about building AR’s.

It’s real simple. Go look at the stakings in an RRA. I can tell you for a fact that key wasn’t staked as have most of the professionals who have seen it.

Have you ever seen a properly torqued gas-key come loose (Youngs)?

Why must a gas-key screw be staked, when we LUBE the barrel nut?

My questions are facetious, but also genuine. If the barrel nut doesn’t walk off, then why should the gas-key set screws? Have you or anyone ever seen properly torqued gas-key set screws do this?

I think if you think about the size, dynamics, design, and differences in stress that each are under, for about one nanosecond longer, the answer is quite obvious.

Ever seen a properly torqued A2 flashhider come loose? what kind of forces do you think it’s under?

Better yet…have you ever seen a properly torqued gas-key come loose?