the only barrel i could find that wasn’t 14 inch or less was from blackthorn, (which was recommended to me as a reputable company. as well as m&a parts). the berrel is a standard 16 inch m4 barrel. they had 134 in stock. i ordered one. now i’m antsy… like it’s gonna blow my face off the first time i fire it. any one have a barrel from these guys? i’m thinking i should cancel my order asap, but like i said, i can’t find a simple barrel anywhere. any thoughts?
I can’t speak to teh quality of their barrels but I know they have a horrible reputation, and the fact that they have 130 plus barrel in stock while everyone else is running out speaks largely to this.
Others who have bought stuff from them have received good parts, while others have gotten complete crap. Of the crap recieved taht I have read about lately,
Rusted- Bolt assemblies
Barrel that had extesnion put on off center.
Barrel with extension roll pinned in place.
Barrel with front sight assemblies off center.
Barrel without gas ports drilled completely.
Barrel that shot out an inch or more of the chrome lining
Bolt carrier group missing a gas key bolt.
Bolt carrier group with gas key bolts loose
I don’t know why folks keep buying from them, but I keep reading about it.
If you luck out, then good for you. If you end up with crap you’re pretty much stuck with it becasue thier warranty is some completely unreasonable short period of time like 72 hours or something like that. So by the time you find out you’ve got a problem it’s too late to settle up with them.
Here’s to hoping you’re one of the lucky ones.
yeah after i ordered i had this gut feeling. the only people that had any barrels. i thought i lucked out. then i read about blackthorn on this forum and ar15.com… i’m pretty disappointed at myself now.
they do say that all of their barrels come from wilson and/or mossberg. i’m hoping that’s true, and will be contacting wilson on monday.![]()
If the barrels are completely assembled by Wilson or Mossberg you should be fine. If Blackthorne is doing the final fitting of the barrel extesnions and gas port drilling, as well as sight mounting, on blanks from the manufacturers, then it’s anybodies guess as to how the final product will come out.
i think it would be a very good idea to contact wilson then.
this is what blackthorn says:
Blackthorne purchases the barrels in our kits from Wilson and Mossberg. Again, we simply cannot tell the difference in manufacturers so we cannot honor requests for specific manufacturers. Our barrels are made from chrome-moly 4140 steel, except our Stainless steel barrels, these are made from 416R re-sulpherized gun quality stainless steel. We do not normally chrome line our barrels because this degrades accuracy and, because of advances in the quality of ammunition, is not really needed for corrosion resistance for most people. With this said, we do offer our barrels chrome lined on special order. Chrome lined barrels are $50.00 extra. This should not be necessary unless you operate in or around salt water and have an aversion to cleaning your firearm. If you require more corrosion resistance than normal, get a stainless barrel. Chrome lined barrels are ordered by using the item # AR-Chrome.
and this is the barrel:
http://akpartskits.com/cart/index.php?main_page=product_info&products_id=265
as far as price, it isn’t any cheaper than the other wilson barrel that are on 3 month back order or more.
canceled order… back to square one…
I know you’re bummed about not being able to find a barrel, but trust us when we say that you did the right thing.
Isn’t Blackthorne just the current incarnation of Hesse/Vulcan? They have to change their name every once in a while because of all the bad press they get, or so it seems.
I almost bid on a blackthorne upper awhile ago. Its seemed like a good deal, m4 with heavy barrell and looked good. Im not super spun up on all the specs but they sold me until i researched there name and rep.
Wow Glad i dint run the gauntlet with there product. Glad you were able to cancel before you got nipped. Try quantico arms in oceanside, a few days ago i saw some LMT barrels in stock there they looked to be 14.5 or 16 inch good luck bro.
I thought I had it bad the last few times I bought barrels, but in reality I had choices all over the place. Luckily I’m not in the market for one now, that must suck.
But… you did the right thing. If you asked me for the name of one company whose weapons would “blow your face off”, Vulcan/Hesse/Blackthorne would my first pick.
An important thing to remember is that “Wilson” is not “Wilson Combat”, which is the implication they all manage to send without actually saying it. They’re a 2nd rate contract barrel manufacturer who makes the crap barrels for the bottomfeeders of the AR world (i.e. Sherluk/M&A/Model 1 Sales, et al).