I want to buy a BCM midlength upper and trying to decide between 14.5" and 16". Part of the decision is which muzzle device to go with. I already have a 16" midlength upper from BCM with an A2 and love it, and probably wouldn’t bother putting a compensator on it since recoil is pretty light already.
I’ve never fired an AR with a comp but I’ve read they increase muzzle flash which I’d rather avoid since this rifle will be used for home defense and I’m not sure a comp is really necessary for 5.56; would the barrel being 14.5" instead of 16" change anything in this regard (shorter barrel = more recoil and flash?).
For 16" barrels, will a comp still increase muzzle flash (longer barrel/more powder burned = less flash)? BCM’s 16" uppers come with the Mod 0 now so if they do I will probably sell it to defray some of the cost of the upper and replace with an A2.
I have a bcm mid length 16" with a mod 0, I’ve found that you don’t really notice any extra concussion as a shooter, but if you are standing next to the shooter it’s very noticeable. It has slightly less recoil than my Colt with an A2, I like it.
ETA, couldn’t really say if it has significantly more muzzle flash, I guess it’s just something I never really noticed.
Any comp or brake, including the BCM, will increase muzzle flash, blast, and noise. I wouldn’t choose one for home defense use.
The 16" midlength may also be more reliable than the 14.5" midlength. Basing this on reports from others here, do a search for info.
IMHO, it is pointless to get a 14.5" barrel and then make it 16"+ to stay non-NFA. Just get the 16" barrel and use the shortest muzzle device possible. Having a device pinned in place is a cost up-front and a huge hassle if you ever want to change anything relating to the barrel.
If you don’t care about the modest length, the A2 is a very decent muzzle device for practically no cost, and it neither weighs much nor adds much length. If you want something even shorter and lighter, look into the AR15 Performance SSB. That is a brake, of sorts, with some added blast, but less than most other brakes I’ve tried, and it’s extremely small and light. Still wouldn’t be my first choice for any inside use.
I have not done any night shooting with the BCM/mod 0. I have shot at night with the Colt/A2 and never noticed the flash enough for it to be any kind of problem.
OP, any comp will produce flash, especially at night. While a 5.56 doesn’t produce much recoil, there may still be an issue with muzzle & sight movement. If you find this to be an issue, a comp may be a solution.
I think you would have trouble finding a BCM 14.5 middy that is unreliable; granted you are using proper ammo/buffer combination.
I think a 14.5 BCM middy would be a great option for home defense. Reliability is a non issue, imo. For better or for worse, BCM has slightly opened up the gas port on their 14.5 middies. I have yet to find a scenario where my 16 inch BCM upper will cycle when my 14.5 BCM upper won’t (just my personal experience). You will find that many people around here are opposed to a 14.5 pin and weld, but as long as you intelligently select your rail and your muzzle device, I am a big fan of a 14.5 with pinned muzzle device. A 14.5 with pinned A2X is approximately 1/4 of an inch longer than an M4 with A2 flash hider. In other words, there is a measurable length reduction when compared to a standard 16" setup. Regarding the muzzle devices, I have both the BCM GF comp and the BCM A2X FH. While the BCM GF comp is relatively quiet (when compared with many other comps) and does a reasonable job of reducing flash, it is definitely going to be a bit more concussive and flashy than the BCM A2X. You say you will be potentially using this upper for home defense. That criteria would push me towards the 14.5 with BCM A2X…as short as possible without having to beg for permission and register your firearm, while still keeping blast and flash to a relative minimum.
I only get sparks out of my Mod 0’s at night on a 16" barrel. I don’t recall ever seeing actual flash out of it, night time or otherwise. Can’t speak to the Mod 1/14.5" combo, but the Mod 0 works fine.
The fact that you aren’t positive what you want, suggests a 16" is the way for you to go.
Something always gets left out when the 14.5 vs 16" debate gets fired up… The 16" barrel with an A2 mounted is 17" +/- long. 1 1/2" A2 less 1/2" of threads plus 16"= 17". The OP can confirm by measuring the one he has. The 14" with A2ex will be just over 16 inches. Now hold your thumb and forefinger an inch apart. Is one inch really worth the hassle??
To me? It’s no hassle. I can weld. And if I ever want to switch things out, I can grind or drill out the pin/weld. It’s really not as big of a pain as some of you guys make it out to be.
to be clear, i haven’t measured mine (don’t have the ability) so i probably should have further qualified my initial comment. However, the general anecdotal consensus from those who have measured appears to be that BCM has gone from approximately .076 to .078 on their 14.5 middies. In addition to this, BCM has, relatively recently, removed the online disclaimer that used to follow all of their 14.5 middy uppers. For years, BCM stated outright on their website that their 14.5 middies preferred NATO spec pressures. If you look, such a disclaimer is no longer present on their website. As well, you no longer see the old posts of individuals pissing and moaning about how their BCM 14.5 middy won’t reliably cycle Tula. So…its not scientific, but its pretty clear that BCM has quietly upped the gas port size on their 14.5 middies to something hovering around .078. I have a recently built BCM factory 14.5 middy upper and it is still a relatively smooth cycler, for what its worth.
I have a BCM Mod1 on a 14.5" Colt. It is no louder than a 16" with an A2. I’ve asked guys on the firing line if it seemed any louder than the other rifle I was shooting and they said they couldn’t tell a difference. I can’t speak to flash as I haven’t fired it at night yet.
I stood next to a shooter the other day that had a gunfighter comp on his BCM carbine. There is definitely a noticeable difference in terms of blast. I have a 14.5 inch carbine with a pinned A2X. I have about 5000 rounds through that gun. I am glad I didnt pin a comp on it. The A2s are the way to go on a defensive gun.
Had a chance to shoot steel at night with a WML, the experience sucked hard with a Lantac Dragon on my friends 14.5", but was very pleasant with my BCM flashcomp on my 14.5". Yes, there was more recoil on my rifle (both are PWS Mk114’s running same ammo) but I would not make the trade.