BCM 14.5's are back in soooooooo?......

Guys, I ordered a new BCM 16" chrome line, NON Hammer Forged. Well, I love it but Bravo Now has the 14.5’s in and I want it. My thought was just get the 14.5 and sell the 16 on gunbroker as it has never been fired.

At $399 would I be able to sell my 16 to pay for the new 14.5 and break slick? No interested in a profit but I dont want to loose any money either. The 16 inch is short, I just wanted the 14.5 and I cant get it out of my head.

Thoughts?
Thanks for the input as well.
I moved this from another thread. I got no repsonse, I want to move fast on this.

I see posts from people regretting their 14.5’s with perm attached muzzle devices because it makes any future mods to gas blocks or handrails a serious pain.

I don’t recall seeing the same posts from people with 16’s that wish they had gotten a 14.5.

But, its your decision.

Buy the 14.5 and keep the 16. Two is always better than one.

Once you start it never ends… BCM fuels BRD!!!

Stay way from uppers that have to have something permed into place.

I would like to agree, but I dislike a carbine gas system in anything greater than 14.5" so my 6920 has a Colt M4 barrel and a permed Blackout. It also has a a DD LITE 12.0 FSP so I’m set for the life of that barrel.

I got an e-mail about the 14.5 LW’s being back in stock, but I was on vacation out of the country, buy the time I saw it, which was all of 9 hours later, they were already sold out.

Only reason I am looking for a 14.5" and not the 16" is because I have to perm a brake onto it anyway living in a commi state, so might as well have it as short as possible. Otherwise, I would always go for the 16" since as said before, I could change anything I want on it pretty easily.

As long as you are content with the components a permed brake may not be so bad. If you are a geardo and have to have every new item thar comes to market stay I would suggest staying away. I know I’ve been toying with switching from my FSC556 to a BC and would hate being stuck or having to destroy a brake to remove it. Since you need to perm it might as well, go for it.

I generally don’t have a problem with permanent muzzle devices. My current favorite rifle has a permed muzzle device. HOWEVER, I would not recommend a rifle with a welded flash hider if it was going to be that person’s only rifle (or even their second rifle). I would also not recommend one if the person in question was relatively new to ARs. Since reconfiguring the rifle is a pain in the ass, you should try to be ABSOLUTELY sure of what you want. That means exposure to numerous configurations and knowing what works for you. Keep the 16 inch gun. Then get a SBR (if your state allows). Then you can start thinking about a permed 14.5.

If you are looking for a 14.5 middy, Noveske is getting ready to change over all of their Light Carbine 14.5’s to a mid length gas system. Matter of fact they have been working on the website this afternoon. The photos the 14.5 models are down, and the descriptions have already been changed to reflect the mid gas. I suspect we could see 14.5 middy carbines for sale in the chrome lined barrels soon.

AK.

I’ll go against the crowd here, and say that a 14.5 with perm FH is my ideal configuration (aside from the SBR I can’t have). I don’t need a FF Rail, and if I would ever want one I can just mow the FSB and add a Centurian Arms C4.

You are limiting yourself with a pinned 14.5, and you already seem to be somewhat undecisive, so think about any possible configuration that you may want in the future.

So if a muzzle break is perm. attached, I can’t change the handguard? Or does this only apply to the front sight/gas block combo configuration?

I’ve been looking to purchase a 14.5 with Battlecomp 1.5 and a VTAC TRX Handguard. I should be able to change the handguard in the future if I wanted, right? If not, I have to re-think purchase rational all over again.

The flash hider is obviously fixed, which stops the removal of the FSP/gas block. This then stops the removal of the barrel nut. You can then only use a rail that utilizes whatever barrel nut (GI or aftermarket) is on the gun.

The few cases where people can’t plan for what they are going to do with their weapon are few and far between. There is absolutely NOT a rash of pinned 14.5 owners running around wailing and gnashing their teeth. Its just not happening.

You absolutely can change your handguard, you are just more limited in what you can change it to.

The simple answer is that if you don’t know what you want, don’t buy it now. Wait until you figure out what you are doing, then buy it once, saving yourself time, money, and aggravation.

In a worst case scenario you would tell the smith to swap out the muzzle device when he was changing your rail at the same time.

I see no advantage to a 14.5" pinned over a 16" and plenty of disadvantage. Couple with being a first/only AR and I think it makes even less sense.

The simple answer is that if you don’t know what you want, don’t buy it now. Wait until you figure out what you are doing, then buy it once, saving yourself time, money, and aggravation.

There is a good point in there, wrapped in advice I don’t agree with. That is that if you don’t know what you want, I’d buy the platform with the most flexibility now, and get out and actually shoot the thing so that you can discover what you do want based on actual use. Focus on a quality barrel and BCG, and a basic configuration for the gun, and spend that handguard/flash hider/fancypants money on mags, ammo, and training.

Quite a bit of good advice in this post. I was experienced with duty issued AR’s prior to taking on building up one of my own, and I still spent plenty of money on things trying them out. A 16" with standard handguards a good red dot optic and BUIS would be the best place to start. It will be a more than capable carbine which you can shoot the crap out of and then get something a little more fancy.

My preferred gun is a 14.5 with a pinned FH.
Of course I put a LOT of thought into it before hand and configured it exactly the way I wanted it. I would not suggest doing it as an first gun. The reason we see people with 20 things hanging off their rails is that most people don’t shoot their weapons enough to figure out what works and what doesn’t.

As you get more trigger time you can start to figure out what fits you best. Then you can make those types of decisions with confidence.

Right. People fail to realize that they cannot change/add a rail (if it is a one piece FF), gas block/FSB, and FS/MB.

What I love is when they pin a 14.5 and then 6 months later realize that they want a suppressor and are screwed (as the FS they chose won’t work with the suppressor they want). :haha:

I think the real errors come from noobs buying pinned 14.5. They don’t know what they don’t know (meaning they haven’t figured out how they like their gun configured yet). They see all the HSLD builds on here by members that have extensive background in AR’s and follow their lead. What they fail to realize is that person KNOWS what they don’t know and has built a gun to fit THEIR NEEDS.

C4

This. The ONLY reason I bought a 14.5" LW barrel is because it is going to be a dedicated suppressor host and trunk gun. Putting a 1.1 lb suppressor on the end of a 34" rifle adds about an additional 3 pounds of totational torque if the datum is the back of the butt stock. A 16" is 3.3 pounds all other things being equal. After a long day of shooting, ounces equal pounds and having a slightly shorter barrel makes sense, but all other applications, not really.

Kind of along the same lines, I was reading yesterday about how soft the 14.5" middies shoot and how great they are and thought to myself “great, now that I just finished up my second 16” middy last week I read this sh*t"…

So I cruised over the the BCM site to see that they’re out of stock on 14.5" mid length uppers like I would want (thank goodness) and then started thinking that maybe I should send one of mine off to ADCO and have them chop it down and pin a BattleComp 1.5 on the end…

But I think I’ll just stick with my long, awkward, hard shooting 16" barrels for now…must quit reading equipment reviews on this site :p!