Barrel length, etc.

Sorry for the newbie questions again …

I have heard some different things about barrel length. Some say 16" is okay, others tall me it’s too short and that 18" is better. What’s the difference?

Also: what is the difference between 1:7 and 1:9. What’s the advantages of either?

Last question: I see some are Chrome Moly Barrel, and others are CHROME LINED Chrome Moly Barrel. I know what chrome is but what is a chrome moly barrel?

Thanks.

Theirs a loss of approximately 25 fps for each inch of barrel loss. The wound ballistics of many 5.56mm loads depend on a minimum impact velocity on target for adequate bullet fragmentation. For example M193 and M855 require 2700 fps at target impact. 1:7 is good from 55 gr to 77 gr loads and is also the Mil Spec. 1:9 is good from 45 gr to 69 gr loads and is not the Mil Spec. For the AR15/M16 series rifle Chrome Lined is the only way to go. Chrome Moly is a steel alloy.

I realize that you stated “approximately” in your sentence, however the velocity loss of “25 fps for each inch of barrel loss” is just another Internet fallacy. There is no valid equation to determine the change in muzzle velocity across a spectrum of barrel lengths and a variety of ammunition loads. The change in muzzle velocity will depend on a variety of interactive variables such as the barrel length spectrum involved (e.g. 20” to 16” versus to 16” to 14.5”), the operating velocity spectrum involved (e.g. a 20” barrel firing a load with a MV of 3,000 FPS compared to other barrel lengths versus a 20” barrel firing a load with a MV of 3,250 FPS compared to other barrel lengths) and the bullet weight spectrum involved (e.g. a 40 grain V-MAX versus a 75 grain OTM.) The particular powder used in the loads will even cause variations between the spectrum of barrel lengths used.

Examples

An average difference in muzzle velocity between a 14.5” barrel and a 16” barrel using a 75 grain OTM load is approximately 86 fps. This gives you a difference of 57 FPS per inch of barrel.

An average difference between a 20” barrel and a 16” barrel is 108 FPS for a difference of 27 FPS per inch of barrel.

An average difference between a 20” barrel and a 24” barrel is 79 FPS for a difference of approximately 20 FPS per inch of barrel.

Chromoly steel is much lighter then your typical carbon steel or stainless steel. The chrome lining helps reduce rifling erosion, lengthening the lifespan of the barrel at minor expense to accuracy.

Heavier bullets are better for long distance shooting- say 400yd+. They resist the wind better & maintain velocity better then light bullets at those distances. However, heavy bullets require a faster twist to keep them from tumbling in the air. A 1:8 will shoot every bullet normally made for an AR. Faster twist rates for heavier bullets are made, but better suited to bolt actions where cartridge length isn’t limited by the magazine. Higher velocities can be had by slower twists at the expense of ability to shoot heavier bullets.

Barrel length is more involved then just velocity. If it’s a home defense weapon shorter barrels make the gun easier to maneuver through doors & such. If you’re hunting, you’ll also want to give consideration to the weight of your rifle. I bought a 20" HBAR, and I can tell you I would absolutely not want to lug this heavy thing around on foot for very long.

What are you going to use this rifle for?

I agree it depends on your intended use. I have 16,20, & 22" ARs. For easy carry I like the M4 profile 16". I’d even use it for some coyote hunting. For dogtown or target I’d grab the 22" & maybe the 20". I have mostly 1/9 & think they are fine. I also have one 1/12 AR barrel. I shoot just about exclusively 50-55 grn bullets, with an edge to 50 & 52 grains.

From what I can tell the 16" mid lengthgas chrome lined chromoly is the best all around setup for civilian use. From my limited experience the longer barrels seem to shoot with less recoil due to them mostly having rifle length gas. Also they seem to run a little cleaner. My 16 inch carbine has some pretty snappy recoil but handles well but I like the softer shooting rifle length. Anyone care to comment?

Mule