I will just cut to the chase and say it; My AR-556 trigger sux! I don’t know what S&W did to the factory trigger of my 4 year old Sport 1, but, I like it! From day 1 it was very smooth and not “gritty” like the Ruger trigger feels. I had the Sport1’s trigger checked after owning it for about a month or so and the pull weight averaged out to 5.9 lbs after 3 tries, if I remember correctly. I do remember it was not over 6 lbs.
I don’t shoot competition, I don’t hunt anymore, and where I live the only thing around me is corn, sugar cane, and soy beans. I have a few targets set up at several distances and would like to be able to hit them without having to fight the trigger. Anyway, here are 3 choices in which I would very much like to get an expertise opinion on;
Or, is there a way in which I can do some polising to certain parts of the trigger, buy different springs, or, anything else possible to make my factory trigger smoother and lower the pull weight?
Any advice is greatly appreciated.
Out of those three, my favorite is the BCM. It just feels nicer to me, even nicer than the ALG ACT. I would’nt mess around with different trigger springs, they often cause light primer strikes. If you can stretch that budget, check out the Hiperfire EDT series of triggers.
The BCM trigger really is great for the price, and if I was looking for a trigger that doesn’t break the bank that’d be it. I haven’t used any of the ALG triggers but I’d assume, after running numerous Geissele triggers in my current rifles, that they are good triggers. Another option is the Larue MBT which can be had for $99-$199 depending on how long you’re willing to wait for them to make it and ship. Another option is to go with one of Geissele’s cheaper options like the G2S.
I have the BCM trigger and the equally priced ALG ACT both are quite nice for the price. These triggers are smooth cleaned up Mil Spec triggers without the grittiness found in most of the standard triggers I have had or used.
If you were interested in spending a bit more I also have a few of the Geissele G2S triggers which can be had for about $120 if you catch them on sale every few months and are great triggers. There will be a much more noticeable difference VS the BCM and ALG triggers but if all you are looking for is a more consistent cleaned up trigger pull with out the creep and grit the ALG and BCM triggers should do just that for you.
Either the BCM or ALG will do just fine for what you want. I would also second what some have said about the Geiselle G2S if you can swing it. Its been on sale all weekend and you may still be able to find it somewhere for $125 if you look. It’s a great trigger and is a huge step up from all of the triggers you listed. I have the G2S in one of my ARs and also a Geiselle SDE with the flat trigger bow in one of my others, and I love Geiselle products. I may try the LaRue MBT next but not because I’m not happy with the Geiselle stuff.
You could look at the mini review I did on the Hiperfire EDT2 a little down the page. If you’re going with one of the 3 you listed, I’d go with the known (at least to me) brands. Namely the ALG or the BCM. I doubt that either would feel or pull significantly different from the other.
I think the “willing to wait a bit for it” LaRue MBT-2s is the absolute best trigger deal available for an AR. It is two stage, so different from your s&w trigger, but I think it is a bigger step up than the cleaned up milspec. I have an uninstalled PNT, so can’t compare directly; however it is comparable to my SSA and SSA-E geissele in my opinion.
How long is the usual wait time on the (willing to wait) trigger? Just a ballpark, not going to hold you to it. I’m thinking about ordering one but wondering how long the wait usually is instead of paying an $80 premium to have it quick.
Sorry OP, I was just going to PM cbthedookie, but figured it was a relevant question and the answer may play a part in your decision here if you decided to go with a bit better option.
All GREAT advice! Thank you!
I am kind of pulling towards the BCM trigger.
I had asked in my opening post about polishing the factory trigger parts. Will this make any noticeable difference? Any advice is greatly appreciated.
I agree with the ALG ACT and the BCM PNT. Another to consider is the PSA EPT, but they are temporarily out of stock right now. They have also had some good reviews.
If you take your time and avoid using any power tools you can make a factory mil spec trigger a little better. I’ve had success removing gritty feeling in a mil spec trigger by using some very light wet sandpaper lightly polishing the contact points. It’s a lot of work for just a little result but if you have the time you could give it a shot. I would maybe experiment with it after you get the new trigger just in case you go too far. A light polish and some good grease can make a gritty trigger better though.
I received two about a month ago; I think it took about 3 weeks from submitting the order. They may be down to two weeks or so now. There are a few threads on TOS with reviews and wait times.
I have the Liberty Fighting Trigger on my last lower I bought (from Sons of Liberty Gun Works) and it is very nice. I usually go with an ALG ACT but I really prefer this one now.
I’ve got 3 guns with the G2S in them and really like the value for the cost. Everything else has an ALG ACT in it (including my 3-gun build that’s in process). I’m curious to try the PNT, a couple friends have used them and speak highly of them.