I was wondering if any of the guys here had shot (or fondled) both, and how they felt about a comparison?
Thanks,
Cameron
I was wondering if any of the guys here had shot (or fondled) both, and how they felt about a comparison?
Thanks,
Cameron
Many M4C staff and moderators have trigger time on both, along with several of our IP’s and SME’s. I personally don’t have any trigger time on the SCAR but I have shot several 416’s.
I’ve shot both, nothing extensive, and only on the range.
I’ve only put 11-12 magazines through the SCAR, mostly Full Auto, mostly suppressed.
What exactly are the differences that you are looking for?
They felt like guns to me…?
Are you planning on making a LE/Military purchase?..or is this for civilian use? The H&K416 will never be available for civilian sales. H&K will sell their MR556 though with a target date of late 2009 for around $2500 plus. The FN SCAR will sell for around that price, but models that are getting into dealer hands are selling for $3000-$9000 at this time because of the Obama factor and the “wow” factor.
The H&K is about 1 pound heavier than the SCAR because it uses a longer receiver. The advantages to the longer receiver are that it gives you a longer iron sight radius option, and gives a longer barrel locking point at the gas valve which yields a little better accuracy. The disadvantages of it is that it adds additional weight to the front. The H&K is basically just a high quality piston driven M4. The M4 will be lighter with better balance, but the H&K will be slightly more reliable under extreme conditions and range sessions that exceed 500rds between cleanings.
The SCAR is lighter than the H&K, and better balanced. Most of the controls are the same as a M4, except for the charging handle. Most who have used the SCAR complain about the charging handle because it reciprocates in a bad location. Unlike an AK, M1, or M14, the FN’s charging handle is located right over the fore grip and you are restricted to using a long hold on the grip or a use a vertical grip in order to keep your hand from being bashed during firing. The stock while highly adjustable, also wobbles around a lot and from user accounts is kinda flimsey if you use it for anything other than resting it against your shoulder.
If I was picking between the two, I’d rather have the H&K416. Both rifles have similar accuracy and similar felt recoil, but I feel that the H&K(like all M4 copies) handles much better. If I was not restricted between those two choices and could pick what I wanted, I would go with a LWRC or a Robinson Arms XCR…which I own both. The XCR is essentially a SCAR with a better bolt design, better charging handle, has a higher magazine seat(feeds JHPs with no problem), and will do anything the SCAR can do and it has the versitility of a M4. Plus, it runs for about $1400 out the door.
Thanks for the info Marcus, that is the kind of comparison I was looking for.
Cameron
I have fired a 416 upper of Colt lower, and both LEO and Civi SCAR
The HK is heavy but familar. Really, it’s just a hefty AR15. During shooting the piston is transparent. The recoil impulse is different slightly, but it’s still an AR15 for the most part which is good for people that dont want to learn a new platform. I’m not joking when I say its heavy though. The balance is dreadful
The SCAR has much better balance, and is lighter. Plus the SCAR is far more versatile. Obviously there is the QD barrel system. As and XCR and M96 owner, I can assure you that once you get a QD barrel gun, its a feature that gets really hard to give up. The SCAR is multi caliber if FN makes kits.
The SCAR has a nice stock with many adjustments, but it feels really flimsy; the charging handle location blows in addition to it reciprocating.
I would take the SCAR over the 416. Overall I think it is a better gun. It simply offers the shooter more.
Though, I would take an LWRC over a 416, and XCR over the SCAR.
I put a couple of hundred rounds though an HK 416 back in 2006. I liked it due to the fact that there was nothing to re-learn. It shot really good and was very easy to clean even after thousands of rounds.
Would love to get my hands on a SCAR and run it through the wringer.
Both are nice. I think both are a better option than the stock M4A1.
If I had to pick one, I’d go with the SCAR-L Mk16 Mod.0.
I’ve got a couple thousand rounds through 10.5 inch 416s over the last year. To me, the only real advantage is the fact that after 1K+ rounds I can have the gun spotless in 20-30 minutes.
Other than that, to me, it’s just another AR. I realize this is blasphemy, but I didn’t get any smarter, faster, or better looking because I was shooting a 416.
Have run both,neither extensively.
HK416 felt like a front end heavy, really well made soft shooting 5.56 carbine.
SCAR felt much the same but with some cool ass shit (stock/capability of barrel changes by the operator in the field,lightweight/balanced well). Both were minute of mahdi militaman to 100 meters(furthest ive shot them), both ran well.
I would be comfortable taking either to a gunfight, ive shot a couple of assholes with FN weapons and never had any serious issues with them. I have not with done so with any HK weapons.
I plan on snagging a SCAR H whenever they hit the market, im not planning on grabbing 416.
Just my opinion.
I am still hoping for the MASADA.
Any ideas on when the SCAR heavy will be out?
I spent a lot of time with the SCAR, both Light (Mk 16) and Heavy (Mk 17), but with most time behind the Mk 16. I have shot several thousands of rounds through them combined. I have shot them from 0 to 800 meters.
I have much less time behind a 416, less than 1000 rounds through a 10.5.
I personally prefer the 416 when compared to the Mk16 as a stand-alone shooter. What I have come to appreciate about the Mk16 is the logistical and support burden that it alleviates. It won’t be nearly as impressive to a hobbyist shooter as it will to others, but there are some nice features that are unique to it.
I like the Mk 17 more than the Mk 16. The Mk16 just feels bouncy to me compared to an M4 or other AR derivitive due (I assume) to the larger, higher profile of the recripocating mass of the BCG, lower rate of fire, and stock design. The receiver rails also seem excessively high to me, causing a fairly dramatic difference in barrel-sight relationship at close range, especially if running a MRD piggybacked on an ACOG. The Mk16 also seems excessively bulky for a 5.56 platform to me. Other “feel” type points have been brought up already. The Mk17 however, feels like a 7.62 platform, whatever that means :rolleyes:. The lower ROF seems to better compliment the system as a whole over the MK16.
I personally prefer the shooting characteristics of the 416 over the Mk16, and would be more inclined to purchase it for personal use over the SCAR. The 7.62 versions are a different story, price-point and delivered features will be the determining factors for me when it comes time to lay down green.
+1 to Failure to Stop
I’ve had a little trigger time with both the MK16 and the HK416 and 417. Most of my time has been behind the 416 though. I like the 416 Due to it being the same platform as an AR. I like not having to teach myself how to use yet another weapon. The hight over bore is the biggest problem with the MK16. Also as stated before it’s bouncy and really alittle to much as much fun as it is to change the barrell at the user level. Why? I mean really if you need a weapon for a certian mission (that being your mission you will have the right size barrell given to you) From my prespective I don’t want my young little ones “thinking” they know more about what works (not what looks cool). Also the rails when you start mounting your lasers and what not it’s really not good for being changed around. My biggest problem is the charging handle likes to smash my thumb.
Some of the other roles the Mk16 could be in like the “IAR” for one would be great. Just have to get rid of the mags it comes with and try something like ohhhhhhh P-mags should work.
Any way just my two sence on the matter for what it’s worth.
-Derrick