I would probably go with either a glock 23 if you want a .40 but I would purchase a glock 30 for a .45 since you can get hi-cap mags as backup and you can stick with the glock platform. I personnally like the .40, all he power of the .45 but with the 9mm platform and magazine capacity.
If you absolutely positively have to spend money on a new handgun instead of ammo or good quality training, then be SMART and get another G19, as previously discussed in other threads regarding this same topic…
I will reiterate what has been stated. Unless you’re independently wealthy or something, your hard earned cash will do you our good spent on ammo and good training. After that get a 22 conversion kit for it so you can shoot the crap out of it with cheap ammo.
After all that the only reason I can see for switching calibers is to go with one that you shoot better. I started with the 9 and then shot a friends 45. Shot the 45 better and made the switch. To this day I shoot 45 better than anything. No clue why, could be that I just suck the least with the 45… Never know.
Don’t get me wrong I get the training thing I really do. I was more just interested in the caliber/ platform debate. Never been a big .40 fan but the gen4 glocks seem to fix the problems associated with. 40 and the m&pc seem to be a great 45 platform
Glock 23 if you want a .40 for the same reasons everyone says to buy another G19. only now you have a .40 on a system you know, and you can get a conversion barrel in 9mm. get a .357 sig barrel and a .22 kit, and have four calibers in one gun. its the way to go in my opinion.
Do you really want a .40? Personally, I would not get a G23. If you buy a .40 buy a platform BUILT for .40, not an up-sized 9mm; want a .40 then buy an HK. Get a USPc or a P2000, maybe even a P2000SK if size is truly an issue, if not try to find a P30 in .40. I have never had a .40 platform run as well as the HK’s I have now or have had in the past. The SIGs and Berettas I have had have been beat to hell by 155gr .40’s, not so the HKs, although I am anxious to try an M&P in .40.
as far as knockdown power that exceeds 9mm, i’d have to go 10mm or 357 mag before the difference was big enough to justify the added expense of a new gun, reloading dies, components/ammo and mags.
9 really is a hell of a good round.
that said, if you have the money and you want a new gun, buy one. A man doesn’t always have to be rational with his gun purchases any more than a woman has to be rational with her shoe purchases.
Knockdown power? You are not going to find that with any service caliber handgun round.
If you are an LE officer who has a high probability of shooting around vehicles and through intermediate barriers, then the .40 makes a lot of sense–my first choice would be an M&P40 followed by an HK.
If you are a municipal LE officer or a civilian in a state that allows standard capacity magazines, then it is hard to beat a 9 mm using good quality ammunition, as it is easy to shoot one handed, relatively inexpensive to practice with, has lots of bullets on tap. When I injured my strong hand a few years ago and lost its use for several months, I found out how much more effective I was using a G19 weak handed compared to a 1911. The 9 mm Glocks, M&P, and HK P30 are currently the best handgun choices available in this caliber.
For folks who live in states that limit magazine capacity to 10 rounds and under, along with those stuck prohibitions on expanding ammunition, for LE personnel who may need to shoot through barriers, or for folks who get lots of free ammo, then .45 ACP is a good option. As noted (https://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?t=19887), a properly customized 5" steel-frame single-stack 1911 in .45 ACP is a superb, unparalleled choice for the dedicated user willing to spend a significant amount of money to get it properly initially set-up and considerable time to maintain it. However, for the majority of folks who want a .45 ACP pistol, but don’t want to invest the funds and effort into getting a good 1911, they are far better served with the S&W M&P45, HK45c, or even a G21sf.
doc, knockdown power was somewhat tongue in cheek. it’s just the usual justification i hear for going to something like a 45. over a 9mm.
I’m personally of the “lots of holes as quickly and accurately as possible” school of thought.
I have a couple of 9mm’s, a .40 and a .45
One thing that has been in my mind for a couple of years now, is the point Doc touched on about shooting one handed. Given the choice, if I have two hands then I will use two hands. But there may be times, one hand is all you got.
I love .45’s. But the vast majority of double stack .45’s are more than one hand full (and I have large hands). Obviously this is an individual issue, but my gut says it is common. Besides the trigger, I think people may shoot 1911’s well simply because they can get a good grip. Increased .45 capacity at the cost of a good grip and resultant control & accuracy is a poor tradeoff. YMMV
The last weapon added to my arsenal was the H&K P30 in .40 I was actually at the store to buy a H&K 45, but when I held the P30 I simply knew I had a better grip.
I like the .40 as a round, in part because it is bigger & heavier, and yet I do not believe it is that much more difficult to shoot than a 9mm. Certainly in a H&K P30 .40 is very shootable.
Stay safe.
I’d considered buying an M&P40 recently during the most recent run on 9mm ammunition cleared the shelves. There was plenty of .40 and .45 available - it might be nice to be able to buy something to shoot…
DocGKR has it correct. I’d rather be in a gunfight with someone on my side with a 9mm and good with it, than someone with a heavier cal. who was not.
Bullet placement trumps cal. So training is more important than that debate over Cal. Nobody giving GOOD training gives it away. I’ve been to several courses and haven’t felt the cash was wasted after a one of them.
Most difficult, picking a good instructor and training area. Often I see the control lost with the .40cal isn’t worth the added ballistics over the 9mm.
If the G19 works for you, and you carry and train with it, eventually you might either break it or lose it to the evidence locker if you become involved in a defensive shooting. Best to have a spare instead of owning one of everything else.
If you are independently wealthy, then disregard, buy whatever you want.
Lets talk finite resources. I will assume you don’t have an infinite amount of money or time. Lets allso assume that your shooting effectiveness is roughly equivalient to the amount of time you correctly train (perfect practice makes perfect). So if shooting effectiveness is largely determined by training and training = opportunity + time + will + money and you can provide the opportunity, time and will, then the amount you train can come down to the amount of money you have for training.
At current prices, .45 and .40 is between 33% and 50% more expensive than 9mm. So if you stick to 9mm, not only is your life easier because you only have one caliber to account for, but you also have more money to put into your training budget, which can result in increased total training, thus contributing to increased combat effectiveness. And isnt that what its about anyway. If you want something bright, shiny and new as far as caliber or bullet launching platform then go for it, but you wont find a good rational basis for making the switch to a different platform or caliber.
This is what I would recommend also, there are a few threads discussing the many reasons why this is sound logic.
As far as knock down power? Unless you are talking about knocking down bowling pins, then discussing "knockdown power" ranks right up there with having a serious discussion about "killing zombies".
In the end, it’s about putting rounds on target before the other guy puts his rounds on target. A reliable handgun that you can shoot proficiently while under stress, combined with the use of good tactics is what is important for a defensive handgun.
Do a search on some of Dr. Gary Roberts work, or go to the terminal effects section and read some of the stickies. There really isn’t that much difference between the 9mm, 40, & 45acp.
The Glock 19 is an excellent defensive handgun (I have one on my person as I type this). Learn to become proficient with your Glock 19 first.
would there be any practical reason to buy say an m&p 45c or gen4 23 over another glock 19 other than I want one?
Since you asked for opinions, I’d have to say no… I don’t see any reason for buying the same or a similar pistol in a slightly larger caliber. Don’t listen to what people on the internet say, all common service pistol calibers are basically the same with similar ammunition. If the 9mm was as weak as some people claim I think at least some Euro Police agencies would have switched over the last decade…
I personally also prefer to keep my ammo supply simple. I try to stick to the same caliber for all my semi-autos. Makes it easier and less expensive to buy (or load if that’s your thing) lots of ammo.
But other than that, got for it, new guns and different calibers are fun
After shooting a Gen 4 G23 I came very close to getting one, it was that good. But then I sobered up to why exactly? My battery of Glock 9mms handled all my needs.