ALMOST bought a Sig Romeo 4b optic

I came so close to buying one of these Sig Romeo 4b optics today…

I actually had never heard of this optic before yesterday. But, I saw mention of it online yesterday, and I watched some video reviews. Today, I went to a local shop, and I happened to see that they had several in stock.

I played with the Sig Romeo4b for about 20 minutes. I like the 50,000 hr battery life. It shuts itself off after a while, and then back on when you pick it up. Online tests show it to be waterproof.

Usually, I can’t do red dots because of my eyes. I see a phantom dot next to the real dot. That’s why I have gone with Mepro 21T optics so many times. I have 3 rifles with the Mepro 21T now. And, I’ve owned 3 rifles in the past with that same model on them. So, I’ve actually owned 6 different Mepro 21T’s over the years.

The Mepro reflex sight seems to work better with my eyes. But at 100 yards, I have a little harder time shooting a decent group (50 yards, no problem) than I do with a nice red dot. I have missed using a red dot, because I used to shoot very tight groups before this eye issue developed. But as I get older, this dot issue gets worse for me.

Anyway - it seemed like the Romeo 4 gave me less issues than other red dots. I even mounted one a gun there at the shop and checked it out. Then, I went home and did some more reading, and I took my Rock River PDS back to the shop with me. I put the Sig Romeo4 on my gun and checked it out for about 10 min. I ALMOST bought it - , but it’s still not perfect for my eyes, in that I still sometimes get that phantom dot issue. I also wished the glass was slightly bigger than 20mm. Out of all the red dots I have tried over the last 5 years, I think it probably worked the best for my eyes. But in the end, I changed my mind and decided not to get it, as this issue still bugged me.

I REALLY would like to have 1 rifle set up with a different optic for once. But, I guess I’ll be sticking with the Mepro 21T on all my long guns, after all. The Mepro 21 is supposed to hold the zero even after being removed and put back on. But, I’ll double check it the next time I hit the range.

Here is a video on it if you haven’t seen one before:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=td04ssNsLQY

I saw these for the first time today too. I was actually eyeing the Romeo 3…

I can’t get over the increased cost for what’s essentially a Holosun sight. Same dot/circle-dot reticles, same auto-off and battery/solar tech. I know it’s Sig branded, but are they improved any over the Holosun OEM or PA optics to really justify a large increase in price?

They claim that it is not a Holosun unit and instead a completely in house designed optic. Time will tell if that is true or not.

I had not heard that, but one has to admit, the similarities are striking.

Way too many similarities between the Holosun and this one. The may have designed the buttons and other features and told Holosun to make it so, but if that’s a true SIG design there is some serious irony there. SIG knocking off a Chicom product. What’s the world turning to?

Either way if it’s a good optic it’s a good optic. Maybe the added cost of the Sig brand might be worth it if it comes with not Chicom customer service.

I’ve heard good things about Holosun CS, but not necessarily their products. I admit, combined battery/solar with two reticle choices and 50K hour battery life is certainly attractive, but if I was going to go second tier on an optic for potential more-than-just-a-range-toy use, I would go with Vortex. Known quality, durability, and an industry-leading lifetime, no questions asked warranty to back it all up. Their optics have been duty-approved by LEO and that’s good enough for me. That being said, I have Meprolight Tru-dot RDSs on several of my toys… time will tell if that was a wise choice, but IWI manufacture and mil-spec rated for the price… I took a chance.

Where did they “claim this”?

If it was a SIG C/S rep, they could have easily told you it was imported from the Moon.

It’s a Holosun unite made as SIG OEM, or at least that is my very strong educated opinion - as SIG is free to “clear the air” on this issue anytime they want - and when the sight says “designed in Oregon, made in China”…

The video says it is not holosun, I suspect it is holosun.

In testing It shares the same environment limitations and failure thresholds as the holosun offerings.

It is only IPX71 rated.

Walks like a duck, quacks like a duck…

Every single current thing from Sig Sauer USA is garbage to be avoided until proven otherwise. And I don’t ever wish to be a beta tester for them again. I did it with the 556 several times over. Each 556 with exception of one had its own unique QC issues. They are a joke of a company riding on the coat tails of the SIG/SwissArms reputation. Thanks but no thanks.

I have a Romeo 3 I took in on trade. Right now it’s on my 590. About two hundred rounds through it with bird, Buck, slugs. It’s holding up just fine. Only thing I can say is I wish it had at least one more brightness setting for daytime shooting. Looks fine as is but one more would be perfect.

I’m interested to see how the Sig optics pan out durability wise. Id like to try one of the R1s on my SIG 320…

Well, the local shop here claimed to have called SIg and spoken to someone. They thought it was a holosun too - they claim that SIg assured them it was not.

It would be an amazing coincidence if it is not.

Like I said the operating environment limits are almost the exact same, which is not good.

Cost is in line with holosun as well.

From what I understand with the chinese optics is that you will have a factory(ies) that offer similar products to different vendors. So I would guess that Holosun is not producing the Sig line as much as the OEM factory is producing them for both brands.

Holosun is an OEM manufacturer from what I understand. They produce their own line, as well as the primary arms line. I can’t recall exactly if they are Chinese or Japanese. For Sig’s sake, I hope their line has nothing to do with Holosun (same manufacturer or not) because the similarities and tech are striking, questions are being asked, and they are denying.

even if the oem is holosun, I’d imagine that they’re like most modern manufacturers in China. their lines are flexible enough to make anything from airsoft junk to high end components. it all depends on what level of durability and qc you want in order to meet a price point. most will even let you put your own qc staff in place if you want

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

Well, I actually went ahead and ordered one of these locally. It should be in within the week.

I like how it can be set to have an eotech style reticle. It has auto on and off after just sitting still for 2 minutes. And, the one I ordered has the solar panel on top. So, it augments the battery.

It comes with a high and low mount. Since I will be putting it on a PS90, I will be using the low mount.

There was one on a rifle in the store that I got to play with - it just belonged to one of the employees there.