Aimpoint PRO vs Steiner PX4i

Hello all. I’m new to the forum and just purchased my first rifle not long ago.

I bought an Aimpoint Pro but now I’m thinking I should have went with a 1x4 variable. The Steiner gets great reviews for the cost.

The rifle purpose is a home defense, plinking, coyote hunting out to a couple hundred yards. Probably similar use to alot of people.

Would the steiner be a better option for an all around use?

I think that it would. I feel that a LPV is by far the most versatile optic for a 16" AR.

I’m a hair over 40. I wonder if I had my 20 year old eyes back if I would feel comfortable shooting a coyote at 200 with a RDS. If it was fairly well hidden then I’m not even sure I could see it much less know where to put the dot.

What’s more important to you?? Home defense or dog hunting? Nothing is better than what you have for HD. What rifle did you get? What ammunition are you shooting?

Good point. Right now defense, but eventually I want to buy a sbr for HD purpose.

I bought a daniel defense V7. Shooting 5.56 federal 55gr right now. I just ordered an Umbrella Raptor charging handle, and I have an Arisaka light mount for my HDS hcri light. Other than that I think I will keep it as is.

You’ll be fine with a good 1X LPV for home defense.

For home defense stick with the Aimpoint. The Steiner, P4xi is a relative newcomer and does not have a proven track record in regards to hard use. At it’s price point, one would wonder as to whether the P4xi is more Burris than Steiner.

Not near as fine as he would be with a RDS. Within reason the position of the RD sight’s dot within the FOV will not change the POI. It doesn’t work that way with the etched reticle of the scope. If you get a bad draw or have to shoot from an awkward position your fight with the eyebox takes time. Time will get you killed.

Nothing wrong with the V7 but it isn’t a target rifle and the ammunition you are shooting is far from target grade. Let us say the rifle will shoot 1.5MOA and the ammo 3MOA. That’s 4 and a half. Give up another 2MOA handicap for only having 4X at 200 yards and 2 more for shooter error. You see where I am going? Granted I am setting up a worst case scenario so let’s say you beat the odds with practice and better ammo to reduce your handicap by half. You are still at 4MOA +/-. At 200 yards that’s 8 inches. People shoot 8" plates at 200 yards with red dot sights all day long. That’s a chip shot for the guys who shoot them at 400+ yards! If I were in your shoes I would leave the PRO on the V7 until I got the SBR. At that time I would scope the V7 but with more power than 1X4.

I smell what your cookin. I like it.

Just go out and enjoy shooting the rifle. Don’t drink the precision koolaid. Do a 50-250 zero with the center of the target floated on the top of the dot. It won’t matter much if you hit an inch high or low at across the room distances.

Totally disagree with this guy. Drink the precision koolaid it is really fun. You really need two rifles. One with a Aimpoint and one with a variable.

I guess you didn’t bother to read any of my responses before the one you chose to quote. That figures.

Turn down the intensity dude it was a joke. I agree with your advice, Aimpoint on an SBR and glass on the V7.

For home defense, I prefer red dot sight with laser device over LPV.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

For 'Yote work, I’d want something higher power than a 1-4/5/6. Maybe a 1-8. But probably at least a 2.5-10.

If that’s what you decide to do, I’d put an offset RDS on it. For HD, simply cant the gun 45° and for popping coyotes, run the variable.

Alternatively, you could just buy a Bobro mount for your RDS and a Bobro mount for a 2.5-10+ and swap out from one to the other depending on what you need/want to do. And then once you’ve got your Form 1 or Form 4 back, just keep the variable on the longer gun and the RDS on the shorter gun.

I think for home defense I would prefer a RDS like the PRO. The almost unlimited batter power is a huge plus.

-Mike

I am thinking I will just run this rifle as is for now and when I have the cash saved up I will pick up a SBR and swap the red dot over to that and scope the V7.

Nothing wrong with either one. Quite honestly, you’re going to shoot at a whole lot more coyotes than home invaders. You’re WAY more likely (about a squazillion times or so) to have your sweet home defense carbine stolen while you’re not at home than to shoot a home invader, much less get killed because you were in an awkward position that you couldn’t see through the eye box. If you want a 1-4 variable, just get it. Practice with it up close and far away. Actually get good. Don’t worry about the theoretical tactical advantage of x optic over y within reason. Don’t dump a bunch of money on perfect ammo you can’t afford to practice with. The light is the most important thing you have on your rifle inside a house anyway. A RDS or LPV just makes it easier. Go get your toy, play with it, and have fun.