A long needed ass chewing

American soldier tells Iraqi police what’s up

I’m watching it for my second time. I had to email this link all over. Anyone who has worked with IP’s will get a good laugh out of this.

Eh wasted breath. They are hopeless, out of all the Iraqis that I worked with/trained only two stood out and were actually worth wearing any uniform that said “Police” on it. I don’t know what that Soldier is expecting. A majority of those turds have shot at Coalition Forces at least once since the war kicked off. They finally found out that it’s more beneficial (monetary wise) to side with us. We had those dirtbags plant IED’s, then come around and tell us that they found some to make some money. Can’t trust em and definitely can’t depend on them. Trying to run ECP’s and have them pat incoming Iraqis moving into Fallujah and doing half ass searches. Yell at them again and again and they still don’t listen. Half of those guys understand and speak english, very few will actually let you know. I may not understand Arabic, but I sure as hell can tell when someone is talking about you in a negative way in a different language. Others might have different opinions but this has been my experience take it for what it’s worth. And to also comment on how that Soldier called them women, it’s more of a compliment. Their women do more work than the men do.

That was pretty fuckin’ good. That sarge is right fuckin’ on. I just hope the fuckin’ translator translated all of what the sarge said.

For those who have read David Pryce-Jones’ The Closed Circle: An Interpretation of the Arabs (Harper & Row, 1989), the Iraqis’ avoidance of anything that resembles actually defending Iraq will come as no surprise. The book is not an easy read and is probably longer than it needs to be, but anyone who reads it will no longer be surprised at the sectarian violence and apparent lack of motivation of the Iraqi security forces.

I’ve seen this one before, but can’t remember where. Here maybe? At that time there was some discussion about how this little speech could actually hurt our efforts instead of helping them. I never really worked with the local IPs, but did spend some time with a group of their federal guys and they were fairly squared away. Not perfect, but did take their jobs seriously. Of course I’m sure it helped that they had training from the Marshall Service’s SOG guys.

Didn’t we already have a massive discussion about this not to long ago or am I thinking of a different thread? It got locked and/or blasted if I remember.

Ha, yah that’s the one. I think I was the last poster on that thread. don’t know why it died. Some people were saying that the guy should have been disciplined. I do agree that if his speech doesn’t end with “So who’s coming with me down the road to kick their ass!” it might not have a lasting effect.

There always is a nervous giggler/smiler in every crowd.

The opening scene from “Full Metal Jacket” is listed as one of the related videos!

Yes, some time ago. A good one, if you ask me, but many here didn’t like it.

Here you go…https://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?t=26185&highlight=iraqi's+talk

Hmmmmmm…these Iraqis…they remind of a certain people.

…Ohh I got it! AMERICANS! Iraqis are really no different than Americans! We both want to make a little money, for a better life, whether how it’s being done is ethical or unethical.

But isn’t this the norm for all westernized countries? Iraq is certainly a westernized country, to some degree.

The Iraqis have dealt with alot of shit under Saddams regime. They have to do some unethical practices in order to survive. The same underhanded stuff they had to do in order to survive Saddam.

I can’t blame them for being so lazy and devious.

You have got to be fu*king kidding.

We did.

…and guys who knew a thing or two about COIN were not amused.

Everyone has a right to their opinion. But just out of curiosity Kal do you have any direct experience with Iraqi people overseas?

While it may elicit a chuckle from we home viewers, it was very unprofessional conduct. I think he’s lucky that he wasn’t mobbed, or worse. I also wonder how many of those whom he de-motivated may have jumped ship to the other side or are working both sides of the fence.

Please don’t feed the trolls! (meaning kal)

::sighs:: Yeah this is just gonna be like kicking up a hornet’s nest. I’m done.

COIN is a fantastic, logic based, history tested way to gain support when liberating. That said…

As someone who has not been to Iraq, but has been around, I would say that there comes a time to call a spade a spade. To be “politically correct” at all times can be simply futile when dealing with individuals that seem to possess concrete blocks for heads.

Thats about as straight talking as it can come.

"We both want to make a little money, for a better life, whether how it’s being done is ethical or unethical."

I don’t know what kind of turd burgling friends you hang with, TOS maybe?, but MY American friends do actually have and use ethics.

"But isn’t this the norm for all westernized countries? "
No, it really isn’t, it’s just the norm for unscrupulous and unethical individuals.

"The Iraqis have dealt with alot of shit under Saddams regime. " Yea, so? Change it or fucking move, don’t sit there pissing and moaning about it.

“They have to do some unethical practices in order to survive. The same underhanded stuff they had to do in order to survive Saddam.” See above.

"I can’t blame them for being so lazy and devious. "
Which clearly defines your work ethic and morals as being equal to theirs. shrug.

Before calling me a troll, do yourselves a favor and search my posts on this forum.

You have got to be fu*king kidding.

No I’m not fucking kidding you. Does the Iraqis’ attitude surprise you? It doesn’t surprise me, not one bit. Around here in the US, we have the same types. Always ready to sell out for a buck. Always ready to stab somebody in the back for profit. It happens everywhere.

I don’t know what kind of turd burgling friends you hang with, TOS maybe?, but MY American friends do actually have and use ethics.

Why do you assume I automatically hang with messed up people? Rhetorical question. You’re being emotional.

That being said, I’m all about ethics and never allow myself to be amidst losers. But the US is a big place, and there are bound to be people that mimic the Iraqi practices that this thread is generally about.

Yea, so? Change it or fucking move, don’t sit there pissing and moaning about it.

That’s so easy to say. Cultural/Personal traits are hard to get rid of.

Which clearly defines your work ethic and morals as being equal to theirs.

where the hell is the :facepalm: smiley when you need it. You have no clue who I am, how I was raised, what I’ve seen, what I’ve experienced, etc. I’m a nobody to you. But based on one sentence, it “clearly defines” my personality?

Once again, you are being emotional.

But just out of curiosity Kal do you have any direct experience with Iraqi people overseas?

No. But the type of acts you said the Iraqis engage in are being done here in the states as well. I only used America as an example because I’m an American and I see alot of people being douchebags here all the time.

Fact of the matter is, there are thugs everywhere.