9310 Bolt Data

Carpenter 158 was originally developed as a dies steel and when carburized is best suited for application requiring high core strength and subjected to heavy shock and wear.

Carburized 9310 is a very good steel when high core strength, toughness, fatigue, and wear properties are required. It’s biggest use is in heavy duty gears and crankshafts.

In 1962 Watertown Arsenal published a report outlining the superiority of AISI 9310 over the “go-to” gun steel: AISI 8620. Shortly thereafter Springfield revised the drawing for the M60 GPMG bolt listing AISI 9310 as the material. When the FN Minimi was designed in Belgium they chose something that was the equivalent of AISI 9310 for the bolt in that as well.

Differences between the two alloys are rather small, the only real difference is the addition of 0.10% of molybdenum in 9310, the phosphorous and sulfur are basically impurities left over from smelting, and Carp 158 would have some of these impurities, even though their alloy listing doesn’t mention them. Both alloys can attain core strength in the 160 KSI range and have similar shock, toughness, and fatigue properties

Carpenter 158 Composition (%):
Carbon - 0.10
Chromium - 1.50
Manganese - 0.50
Nickel - 3.50
Silicon - 0.30
Iron - balance

AISI 9310 Composition (%)
Carbon - 0.08 to 0.13
Chromium - 1.00 to 1.40
Manganese - 0.45 to 0.65
Molybdenum - 0.08 to 0.15
Nickel - 3.00 to 3.50
Phosphorous - 0.025 max
Silicon - 0.15 to 0.30
Sulfur - 0.025 max
Iron - balance

So, if all things are equal for the most part between Carpenter 158 and AISI 9310, why only Carpenter 158 for military spec parts? Mainly, the military (specifically the Army) does not now, nor ever did own the design for the AR-15 bolt, and because of this, Colt’s Manufacturing controls the material specifications. If the Army felt there was a problem in getting Carpenter 158, or felt there was something significantly better, they could request Colt change the specifications, but that would cost money to: a) research and prove out an alternate, and b) pay Colt’s to change their drawings. It may very well be that 9310 is a superior steel for M4 bolts, but the cost to do (a) and (b) are higher that the savings you might recoup from fewer bolts purchased, i.e., no return on your investment. Similarly, Colt’s has no incentive to change, carpenter 158 has worked adequately for the last 60 years, so why spend money to fix something not broken.

So why are other people making 9310 bolts?

Carpenter 158 is a proprietary alloy, and only available from Carpenter Technology. If you want some, you probably have to get a few tons of it. AISI 9310 is non-proprietary and available from many different foundries, in smaller quantities, and probably a lot cheaper. Many AR bolt manufacturers make bolts from 9310, and they work just fine and last just as long, but they will never be “proven” until somebody with really deep pockets reaches into those pockets and funds a serious test of the two bolts. And, the only folks with pockets that deep have no incentive to conduct such a test, because they have something that works, either 158 or 9310.