556 silencer durability

Ok First off DISCLAIMER I don’t want to turn this into a pissing match of brand x vs brand y.

I’m simply interested in the overall durability of some of the different brands of cans if run on SBRs. I can’t seem to find any good evidence of especially cans like gemtech and yankee hill and running the thing hard.

I know AAC and Surefire are of a known quality, as are Knights. But realistically for your average joe how long will one last over another?

There’s of course that youtube video of a Gemtech G5 being turned into a paperweight form sustained full auto tests. but If I took out say a Mk18 and ran a bunch of different cans on it which would be likely to fail first.

There are a lot of factors in this. First is barrel length. Second is the type of adaptor. So if you are shooting a 10.5 with a flash suppressor, you are going to wear out the first baffle much faster than say a gun with a 16" barrel and MB.

C4

Ok my fault should have been a bit more specific. let’s just say all QD type silencers and maybe for the sake of argument disregard barrel length for the time being. I understand shorter barrel faster wear on can. but just strictly speaking in quality difference between some of the cheaper (YHM, Gemtech) to the industry leaders

You should see Iraqgunz’s blast baffle. Has a little chunk out of it, and looks worse than the craters on the moon.

Mine (shot only on 14.5 or longer) is as smooth as it was 4 years ago when I bought it.

Friends dont let friends shoot unsuppressed…sounds like you guys are good friends. :smiley:

Him and his supressor fetish. :stuck_out_tongue:

He gets crapped out when we show up with loud guns. :smiley:

For the average user, all those cans you mentioned will last pretty much forever for them.

But when you start getting to SBRs, esp. 10" guns and of course if you add full auto, I’d DEFINITELY go with the welded all-Inconel of the SF, AAC, or KAC.

Let’s try it this way for Jerik1M4…“KISS”…

Using only a 16" barrel…5.56x45mm chamber…always the same outside temp…always just semi-only…always just one 30-rd. magazine/then let the can cool down…only using 62-gr. M855 US GI ammo…no full-mag-dumps/no full-auto.

I’m getting the feeling that “round-count” doesn’t want to be expanded upon/discussed (IE: Number of rounds fired through a suppressor/moderator) by the manufacturers…“service-life” (??).

I think what Jerik1M$4 is looking for is expected “service-life”/“approximate” number-of-rounds he should be able to fire before the suppressor/moderator will need to be replaced…something like “barrel-life”.

Regards, RichardS in MI.
US Army, Retired.

There are too many factors involved to be that simple.

BUT, given the setup you put forth there, I’d be surprised if a can from SF, KAC, AAC, YHM, OPS, Gemtech didn’t easily go past 25K+ rounds.

And “lifetime” is subjective as well- the baffles won’t crumble, but the bore will erode more and more eventually getting to a point where the sound reduction is no longer enough for the user.

I have seen cans used in semi auto on 16" guns that looked almost new at 20,000 rounds, and I have seen a can that was worn to the point of being almost useless in fewer than 5,000 rounds (10" gun, flash hider mount, all full auto)…

Like grant said, the longer your barrel, and the use of a muzzle brake mount, the longer your can will give satisfactory performance. Average Joe will probably have great service from any of the popular companies’ products.

That said, given the hoops we need to jump through to get these stupid things, I would want to hedge my bets and go SF, AAC, or KAC.

And people get all sunk into the notion that no full auto means no silencer abuse.

Mild bursts through a can is easier on the unit than some ape mag dumping a bunch of Semi auto fire.

Yeah the inside looks a little shitty and yet it still performs very well.

3 of my baffles are dinged from a bullet strike, but mine too sounds as good as ever.

edit.

It seems like I remember someone, not naming any names, (Gunz) dumped 3 mags through my 12.5 on Sunday. Even hummed a little Privi Part Match through Ole Black Magic. He did ping some steel at 350 in the process. :smiley:

PRVI went through your can???

whats wrong with PRVI?

FYI- You and I have both shot PRVI match ammo through my can when we were doing some ammo testing/ chrony stuff, etc…

My last deployment I shot probably 3000 rds through my KAC QD suppressor ( not just firefights but training and some fun time too ) , I noticed after a bit that it wasn’t as quiet as it was when I first got it, so I emailed Knights. They told me that the suppressor would last as long as the barrel, if not longer and that all I had to do was soak it in some Rifle Bore Cleaner overnight, as trying to actually clean inside was next to impossible in the field. Soaked it for 24 hours and the sound reduction was amazing, was able to shoot without earpro if I wanted, but made a major difference on our op/lp missions as we were able to shoot dogs on our infil without people knowing, and engage the enemy again without the normal report of an unsuppressed rifle…just that simple cleaning made a huge difference

For the average civilian user, that can is going to outlast two precision barrels, or at least one CHF barrel, and in all likelihood the owner’s interest in that particular can.

I can’t wait to see how fast my 10.X" OPS SBR setup eats through that muzzle brake, but I’m also not expecting amazing auditory results from a setup like that.

What did you soak it in? I’ve tried that dog shit Slip 2000 and literally didn’t get a single piece of carbon to come out. Then my can smelled like hot oranges for the next month. :rolleyes: