308 AR build short cycling

Yes, I have a barrel that has the gas port at the AR15 midlength location. And an AR15 midlength gas tube mostly fits. The ‘dogleg’ is a little bit short since the LR308 has more offset from the bore to the key on the carrier. The tube can be tweaked to correct that. The overall length is 11 3/4".

Armalite’s AR10 carbine gas tube is indeed the correct one to use for my barrel. If you look at Armalite’s website, they list the length at 12 1/16". link

So the AR10 carbine gas tube is about 5/16" longer than an AR15 midlength gas tube. This is just one more example of how the 308 AR world is kind of a mess. Several standards that are being mix 'n matched all over the place.

Just saw your edit. It looks to me like your Rainier barrel has the gas port 5/16" further back than my AP barrel does. This was my complaint with the AP barrel. They say it needs to use an AR15 midlength gas tube but IMHO the correct tube for their barrel is the Armalite AR10 carbine gas tube.

Since you have over an inch of the tube inside the receiver, I think you’re correct that the gas tube is not an issue on your build. Mine, with the AR15 mid tube, had less than 3/4".

Have you confirmed that the gas block is lined up on the gas port correctly?

“Armalite’s AR10 carbine gas tube is indeed the correct one to use for my barrel. If you look at Armalite’s website, they list the length at 12 1/16”. link
So the AR10 carbine gas tube is about 5/16" longer than an AR15 midlength gas tube."

Yep - that is seriously messed up.

So yeah, even though I measured it being the same making me believe it’s not the problem, I will order one and see what happens.
Appreciate the info.

Yeah, (adjustable) gasblock isn’t the issue.
I’ve fired a whole 5 rounds so far, I think before i do any major adjustments and removal etc II’ll get a bunch more rounds down the tube and get it broken in a bit, many times that’s all it takes on a new build.

I don’t know…on yours the Armalite tube may be too long. I’m not sure if there are any potential problems with that.

Some break in will probably help. I’d throw a lighter buffer in there though since you have an H3 now.

your theory is a bit flawed. You are basically taking a Pontiac, installing a Dodge engin and trying to use a Chevy transmission. You either have to Know what fits, how to modify it, or stick with one manufacturer.

People don’t complain about Dodge parts not fitting on a Chevy.

I don’t understand what you’re saying. I’m not the one who decided to put the gas port in the Armalite location on an LR308 pattern barrel. It was made that way. By your analogy it’s like buying a Dodge engine that is supposed to use a Dodge transmission, then finding out it needs a Chevy transmission.

Yeah, going to run a magazine through it, if by then I don’t see change time to start looking at spring/weight/gas-port combo see what needs tweaking.
At this point my money is on ‘break-in’.

Yup, break it in some more. It’s not uncommon to hear of .308 ARs needing breaking in. Lube it up well.

Update, problem fixed.

Ran a mag, tried different buffer weights, no improvement.
Dawned on me to check the gas block (adjustable), realized it was totally CLOSED.
Opened it up to about half, runs like a charm.
Yep. Who’s the idiot now (I mean…which way is open…:jester: )
Moral of the story - always look for the simplest solution first.

Now that it seems to run, mind shooting some groups?

Had some time today to finally sight it in at the 100 yds and do a solid function check.
Ammo Colt 168 gr.

Very windy day but still decent groups, and was able to get on paper in 5 rounds, got scope dialed in in about 15.

Ran about 80 rounds, no failures whatsoever, using 10- and 20 round PMags.
Images:

Group 1with sand-bag under stock, slow fire, group of 5.

Group 2, no sandbag, slow fire, emptying mag.

Group 3 no sandbag, ‘rapid’ fire.

Now I really want to see what this can do with decent ammo and a skilled shooter…

Very nice! I can’t wait to get out and group mine!