300 blk barrel, which one?

I am in the market for a .300blk barrel, and am having a hard time making a decision.

First, I am not sure what all this will be used for, but it will probably have a red dot. Right now the plan is majority subs, with a can (Saker or Omega) and maybe occasionally supers, but no real purpose on that front. This will be replacing the barrel on a “range toy”, so lets focus there for the build.

If it matters, I already have a 12.5 556 SBR, and have been eyeing the idea of an 11.5 as a second SBR, so the 5.56 is covered.

The upper it is going on has a 10" rail that I was able to mount a Saker or Omega on (outside of the rail) but it is big enough for the can to go inside. That is not a goal, but a possibility. Of course, could always swap rails in the future too, but because of that I am primarily looking at 10.5" barrels.

I have a Seekins .750 adjustable gas block to go on it.

I am looking at the following in the mid-higher end range ($200-300)

Noveske 10.5 https://dsgarms.com/nov07000034
Seekins SS 10.5 http://www.capitolarmory.com/seekins-precision-300-blackout-stainless-steel-match-barrel.html
Mega Arms 10.5" (416 SS, nitrided) http://www.megaarms.com/ar-15/ar15-barrels/300-blackout-barrels/

Then on the cheaper side ($150 or under) there are

DSG 8.5": https://dsgarms.com/dsghbarrel-300-001
Faxon 10.5: https://www.rainierarms.com/faxon-firearms-300-blackout-light-barrel-10-5
SOLGW 9": https://sonsoflibertygunworks.com/collections/components/products/9-300blk-pistol-length-gas-system?variant=3083520321

I am not finding many (if any) reviews on the DSG, SOLGW, or Mega barrels, and very little on Faxon. Seems like most of what I can find is around Noveske, Seekins (older posts), and KAK barrels on other sites, along with stuff like Radical, PSA, and a few others.

I know I dont really care about velocity differences, especially with subs, but I know it may one day become the HD rifle just for the extra quiet (once reliability is established), so I am not sure where to go…

http://aeroprecisionusa.com/catalogsearch/result/?q=300+blackout+barrel
Aero Precision.

Thanks - but why would I go Aero/BA vs anything else I have listed?

They are more expensive than multiple options, while still being 4150 steel with QPC coating, which has me a little hesitant.

Do you have any experience with a specific barrel?

I have the SOLGW barrel bu haven’t gotten much time with it yet other then a quick function check. It train well with superbug haven’t tried it with subs or suppressed yet.

I have 5.56 barrels from Faxon and AP / Ballistic Advantage, and have been happy with all of them. Unfortunately those two companies seem to have chosen the silly “GI” profile for their short 300BLK barrels, and I would skip that.

If you decide you want one anyway, AIM sells the Faxon barrel with a pinned gas block:
http://www.aimsurplus.com/product.aspx?item=XFXB105MBLK300AAC&name=FAXON+FIREARMS+Light+10.5"+.300+BLACKOUT+4150+CMV+Steel+AR+Barrel&search=faxon

The Mega looks like a good barrel at a reasonable price. I can’t see spending Noveske money on a short barrel for a range toy.

FWIW, I have 300BLK barrels made by AAC, DS Arms (not DSG Arms), and AR-Stoner (Midway-USA house brand), and all of them have worked fine, with no perceived accuracy differences so far. I haven’t done extensive testing on any of them though - the ammo drought coincided with the part of my life when I had shooting time, so they didn’t get used much, and now that ammo is more readily available I have less time to shoot. :frowning:

It could be argued at 10.5", 5.56 makes just as much sense.

The original Honey Badger used a 6" barrel, while the new one uses a 7" barrel.

The 7.5" is a nice configuration for 300BLK, especially for suppressed use.

http://www.blackrivertactical.com/concrete5/store/#!/7-5-Pistol-Gas-SOCOM-GOV-profile-barrel-300BLK/p/63060505/category=1852006

Without a purpose given by the OP other than possibly replacing a range toy and a desired rail length for the cans mentioned, how can we make a recommendation with such limited information? There’s a lot of pro’s and con’s associated with different barrels, even with the stated majority of subs in use.

BC98 - Thanks, wish you had more time with it though!

Someotherguy- -I understand the time thing, thats the way it goes! like you mention, the money outlay has to match the need or desire, so that is part of the trouble I am having.

Clint - I have looked into shorter barrels, but heard some reliability issues under 8" over on 300blk forum, I am still considering shorter barrels but I dont know which direction to head. Just not convinced I want to go under the rail, though the Honey Badger is a handy little package.

Tom - sorry to have caused confusion, Ill try to clarify.

What purpose do you need other than range toy and possible HD gun in the future?
I have not listed a desired rail length, only mentioned the one the upper was built with, along with the fact that I am open to changing that if needed. The purpose of that part was to explain why I was looking at 10.5" barrels, and that a shorter barrel could be used since the cans will fit inside the rail.

I would love to have some discussion on the pros and cons associated with different barrel lengths, specifically the sub 7", 8.5", and over 10". My understanding is 8.5 is about ideal for all around use, but I am not sure if that is the case.

Thanks!

I’m not sure how to begin, other than stating that most subsonic suppressed only combinations can run well to 7" and a little shorter with a pistol gas system length. Supersonic only combinations can really work well when you extend the barrel length, but after around 12.5" the gains are not as high going longer compared to shorter lengths.
You can make a 7"ish supersonic combo run, but you will need to add action mass if it’s based on the subsonic combo. That combination would need more action mass to maintain a desired cyclic rate. The 7"ish super combinations are brutal as far as erosion goes, and the cans need to be able to handle the muzzle pressure.
A 12.5" barrel with supers could be considered a realistic upper limit for most in barrel length. Sure, you can go longer and gain velocity, but those gains are smaller with an additional loss that adds up with that extended length. Running subsonics in a 12.5" combination could be related to having almost 6" of extra barrel length that you don’t need, with all the negatives associated with that.
I realistically think that 9"ish is about the best compromise between the two. I’ve used a little longer and shorter, but within a realistic limit combining the two without a lot of detriment compared to a dedicated system between either subs or supers.

Awesome info, thank you.

I was just about settled on 8.5-9" for my ideal gun, and that helps solidify the choice. Now to find the barrel for me.

A pleasure to be mentioned. Let us know if we can help!

Nathan thanks! Quick question - you only list 4 .300 barrels on your site, but Rainier has some that you dont. Do you make special barrels for anyone else? Specifically looking at the Chrome Lined 4150 5R Barrel in 8.5" rainier carries, any similar barrels elsewhere?

To all:

I am on the 8.5-9.5 wagon, 9" being preferred.

Again, mainly subs, plan on always being supressed, adjustable gas block and several buffers to tune if needed.

Want stability with subs, and ability to shoot supers for kicks, and I do not mind adjusting buffer or gas block for supers if I have to.

Would love a 1-2 MOA gun, this isnt a precision upper, but I want it to hit where I am pointing, barring failures on my end.

Im right now looking at the ~$200 price range.

Faxon at Rainier: https://www.rainierarms.com/faxon-firearms-300blk-chrome-lined-4150-5r-barrel
KAK Mr. Blond 5r: https://www.kakindustry.com/ar-15-parts/upper-parts/barrels/300-blk/kak-300-blackout-9-inch-pistol-stainless-barrel-5r7
BA Hanson profile as an odd ball because of length: http://graniteridgeoutfitters.com/300-Blackout_c75.htm

Was thinking about AAC, BCM, or Noveske as well, but I dont know that I like .300 enough to spend $250-400 on a barrel. If I really start to love it, then I can always use this as a spare upper or sell it complete to recoup the cost of a more expensive one. Just need to know it wont shoot like crap.

Or, just find a 9-10" cheap barrel like the Faxon lightweight, SOLGW, or DSG 8.5? If they will be acceptable and I am over thinking it, I can deal with that too.

We do, but those barrels are under a black-label arrangement. I am bound to not disclose who all our OEM customers are.

The Rainier configuration (5R, Chrome-Lined) is unique to them.

Of the barrels you listed the only one I would buy is the Noveske. If you are looking at a 9" I personally would just buy a BCM upper.

The problem right now, and I saw this all over shot this year, is a lot of barrel manufacturers think 300 blk is 556. Their gas ports are too small as is their rifling. I have a good friend who is a gunsmith and he sees 300 barrels come in all the time that dont run in one of the 4 configurations. Unless it is a specific use gun, IMO it should run all 4 ways - suppressed supers, suppressed subsonic, unsuppressed supers, unsuppressed subsonic. If you are not looking for it to run all 4 ways you should know that going in and keep it as a requirement. 300 blk was designed so you could pick up the sbr in any configuration and put any ammo in it and it will run.

Personally I dont see a reason to build a 300 over 9". I just received a barrel from x-caliber barrels that is a 7" with a 1:6 twist. If you are going to do a lot of reloading and shooting subs I would only do 1:7 or below. In my brief conversation with Kevin Brittingham at shot, they are using 1:5 on the honey badger. 1:8 is the Saami spec but AAC openly states they think they should have done 1:7. If you are shooting heavy subs I would look hard at the twist. We saw so many barrels at shot that were 1:8 and you could see the gas port was too small. I would much rather get a gun that runs all 4 ways and put an adjustable gas block on it so I can dial to the spec of the gun vs a gun that will only run suppressed.

There is a lot of compromising components available in the market, unfortunate, but that’s what it is.
Chrome lined bores can work well, but it does take time (rounds) to burnish in the bores well enough to suit a precision requirement for some. Even with that characteristic, those bores can have a very long lifespan. Similar to 7.62-5.56 offerings of the same.
As far as modes of operation, not all cans and ammunition varieties operate the action system in the same manner. For a dedicated system, I tend to prefer a desirable operating range similar to the carbine H2/A5H2 in range.
For a system that is required to operate in all four methods of operation, I prefer to tend towards a specific porting size that suits operation without going to the 3.0 ounce carbine buffer, or more than the A5H4 buffer 6.83 ounce buffer that suits each individual need better than a single action system mass for all of the associated unknowns. This could leave you with a carbine H1-H3 or A5H1-A5H4 to fit the use for a range of function.
Our unfortunate reality is that many of the barrel options you run into are not really in that range to do so. Some shift it lower to deal with the issues with the way some cans with supers cycle the action. Some shift it higher to deal with certain subs without a can.
In my opinion, for those wanting all 4 modes should focus on combinations that select a porting that can be a little weak with the H2 with subs with no can on and on a realistic rate with supers with a can for most. That range can allow you to tailor better with different action masses. Even without that tailoring though with specific masses, you can rule out many cans, ammunition, barrels, etc that stack up outside of what others can accomplish.

The vendor that I got my old upper from worked with me a bit on price, so I am picking up a complete BCM upper on Friday. I eyeballed a couple of AAC completes on Gunbroker, but at those prices were getting ridiculous.

There are enough reports around with both the Saker and Omega and the BCM 9" using H or H2 buffers, and lots of people reporting full function in all 4 modes. Though my desires lean strongly to the subs/suppressed mode as the far and away most common.

Thank you all for the information, and Tom, thanks for going into depth on things. Monk, appreciate the push toward the BCM complete. I wish there was a bit more information (or I could find it) on some of the various options to really dig in, but I also didnt want to push the dealer too long researching when they were offering a discount, and they happened to have the BCM in stock.

Thank you!