18 inch barrels with rifle-length gas system: Opinions?

I’m thinking of doing a build with one of the FN 18" CHF chrome lined barrels made for a rifle-length gas system. The lower in the build would have a rifle buffer.
Anybody have experience with such a configuration? I’m mainly curious about the potential for reliability issues cropping up due to the shorter dwell time when compared to a 20" barrel. I know 16" guns with rifle-length gas systems can have issues but haven’t heard much one way or the other about the 18".

There are tons of people running 18" rifle gas barrels with rifle stock and buffer, have been for some time (it’s a very popular setup for 3gun for instance). It is a proven smooth shooting combination that is only going to be screwed up by a bizarre gas port size, bizarre ammo and/or improper assembly of parts.

I myself have an 18" ARP rifle gas SPR-ish build with an ACE Skeleton stock and rifle buffer that shoots very smoothly with IMI 77gr mk262 clone.

The combo of 18" and rifle gas has pretty much been worked out. I think it would really only be a concern with underpowered ammo in very cold weather with the wrong combination of buffer weight/spring.

Agreed. My Faxon 18" gunner profile with rifle gas and Vltor A5H4 buffer (and adjustable gas block) runs great. It’s my patrol upper.

It’s a smooth shooting, reliable setup that puts less stress on operating components than a 16" middy.

If one uses the Crane MK12 port size of .0995 it will run just fine. We have turned out several 18" SPR type barrels to include the ones we did for the Axelson Tribute Rifle.

DPMS Mk12 barrel and rifle buffer, no cycling issues, couple thousand rounds between cleanings low powered reloads to commercial 5.56.

Good to hear that this combination generally seems to work well.

My 18" rifle gas SPR runs great. Im running it with Syrac adjustable gas with JP light weight carrier and silent captured spring though so not quite the same as a full weight FA carrier and rifle buffer.

I have been running a Nordic 18" with rifle gas. It is specifically intended as a 3 gun barrel and has such has a slightly small gas port. It has a VERY smooth recoil impulse and is much more pleasant to shoot than a standard 16". Reliability is 100% from 20-100F. It also works great suppressed, and I have from carbine to H2 buffers with no change in function.

If you haven’t shot one, you would be amazed how smooth the recoil impulse is.

I had one. (18" HBar) Ran without a hiccup.