I erroneously started another thread on the same subject.

I'm for it. It wouldn't be difficult for the staff to set up. The question is would it add extra moderating work? Most of the 2A threads I've read have stayed pretty good. Not too much name calling. If it doesn't bring some of the out-of-hand stuff that's found in the GD, it wouldn't make any more work. But if it follows, then there could be two subs that require extra attention and that's not good.